Trending Jamaican in NYC Right Now, According to Reddit, Instagram, & Articles | Starved.io

Jamaican

Bedford-Stuyvesant

Iconic Jamaican patties w/ flaky dough & flavorful fillings. Spicy beef & chicken patties shine, perfectly paired w/ warm coco bread.

caribbean 6jamaican 6

7 References (Overwhelmingly Positive)

Recent References

first time visiting nyc

~1 year ago

favorite beef patty spot

~1 year ago

Theinfatuation - Juici Patties adds Jamaica's finest to NYC's patty scene

~1 year ago

View full profile- 7 references

2. MANNA'S

Harlem

Pay-by-the-pound soul & Jamaican food - generous portions, awesome flavors, must-try jerk chicken!

soul food 3jamaican 3

3 References (Leaning Positive)

Recent References

what are the best cheap eats around 125th acbd

over 1 year ago

View full profile- 3 references

3. JERK HOUSE

Midtown

Authentic Jamaican flavors and standout jerk chicken conveniently located in Midtown Manhattan.

caribbean 8jamaican 4

8 References (Overwhelmingly Positive)

Recent References

can anyone suggest a good jamaican restaurant in

~1 month ago

recs for jerk chicken places where the jerk

~2 months ago

looking for highcalorie cheap food options around

3 months ago

View full profile- 8 references

4. 1 STOP PATTY SHOP

Hamilton Heights

Top-tier Jamaican patties with a perfect baked texture that outshines the competition. A must-visit local gem for authentic Caribbean takeout.

jamaican 7caribbean 4

9 References (Very Positive)

Recent References

can anyone suggest a good jamaican restaurant in

~1 month ago

best oxtail rice and peas nyc

4 months ago

food specials in the heights

7 months ago

View full profile- 9 references

5. THE DOOR

Jamaica

Authentic Caribbean & Jamaican flavors, renowned for its Rasta Pasta.

caribbean 3jamaican 3

3 References (Overwhelmingly Positive)

Recent References

best rasta pasta in nyc

~1 year ago

last minute most delicious foody spot in queens

over 1 year ago

what ethnic foods can we agree that ny is a top 3

over 1 year ago

View full profile- 3 references

6. MANGO BAY

Fort Greene

Elevated Afro-Caribbean fare w/ vibrant flavors & creative twists. Must-try goat puff pastry & expertly crafted cocktails.

caribbean 9jamaican 4afro-caribbean 3

9 References (Overwhelmingly Positive)

Recent References

Mango Bay in Brooklyn is described as an Afro-Caribbean culinary hidden gem, praised for its elevated ambiance, excellent service, and consistently flavorful dishes. The restaurant features a diverse menu, with standout items like the pepper shrimp, ackee & saltfish egg rolls, tender Bronzino, and succulent jerk chicken and braised oxtails. The cocktail program is also highlighted for serving strong drinks made with premium ingredients, contributing to a vibrant and highly sought-after dining experience that requires reservations.

9 months ago

Mango Bay NYC offers a unique dining experience within a classic Brooklyn brownstone, providing a warm, cozy, and home-like atmosphere. The restaurant features a diverse menu with Caribbean-inspired dishes. The reviewer celebrated a friend's son's birthday here, noting the inviting ambiance and delicious food. Popular dishes enjoyed included a truffle burger, spicy seafood pasta with a perfect kick and rich flavor, and lychee margaritas that were super refreshing. The restaurant also offers other appealing dishes such as mussels, ceviche, and options like jerk chicken and mango curry crab from its menu. The overall experience was highly positive, making it a recommended spot in Fort Greene for special occasions or a lovely night out.

~1 year ago

Mango Bay NYC is an Afro-Caribbean fusion restaurant located in Clinton Hill, Brooklyn, operating under new ownership. The reviewer highlights that the establishment successfully blends African and multiple Caribbean island flavors, creating a distinct identity for each dish without solely relying on one specific island's traditions. The atmosphere is described as fresh, versatile, and lively, matching the innovative culinary approach. The reviewer expresses strong enthusiasm for the food, particularly praising the braised oxtail, deep-fried red snapper, goat puff pastry, and mango chow. While the curry crab was not what the Trinidadian reviewer traditionally expected (being a soft-shell crab), it was still acknowledged as perfectly cooked. The restaurant also offers strong drinks, and the overall experience is recommended as a 'celebration of the diaspora' through food.

~1 year ago

View full profile- 9 references

7. THE ISLANDS

Crown Heights

Top-tier jerk chicken & oxtail; a highly recommended Jamaican & Caribbean gem.

caribbean 11jamaican 5

7 References (Mostly Negative)

Recent References

best oxtail rice and peas nyc

4 months ago

brooklyn food recs needed

10 months ago

good jamaican in brooklyn

~1 year ago

View full profile- 7 references

8. PUFF'S

Crown Heights

Authentic Jamaican/Caribbean patties, loaded and delicious, with must-try oxtail and short rib options.

caribbean 3jamaican 3

5 References (Overwhelmingly Positive)

Recent References

Theinfatuation - Pop's Patties

~1 year ago

request where can i find a patty on a bun in nyc

~1 year ago

best cheesy beef patty recs

over 1 year ago

View full profile- 5 references

9. GREEDY POT

Afro-Caribbean & Southern Soul Food. Huge portions, daily specials. Must-try curried goat!

american 5jamaican 4caribbean 3

18 References (Overwhelmingly Positive)

Recent References

jamaican food

7 months ago

iso cheap meals

7 months ago

ugh where are some good spot in bk i can get food

11 months ago

View full profile- 18 references

10. YAAD MAN THING

East Flatbush

Authentic Caribbean flavors, especially the 'mean curried goat,' with a side of customer satisfaction and occasional portion size comments.

caribbean 3jamaican 3

5 References (Leaning Positive)

Recent References

yaad man is back

~1 year ago

taste of jamaica 876

~1 year ago

tatiana was a miss

over 1 year ago

View full profile- 5 references

11. KINGSTON TROPICAL BAKERY

Wakefield

An iconic Bronx institution serving legendary, house-made Jamaican beef patties and sweet, fluffy coco bread since 1970.

jamaican 11caribbean 8

11 References (Overwhelmingly Positive)

Recent References

nytimes the 100 best restaurants in nyc 11100

4 months ago

best oxtail rice and peas nyc

4 months ago

how much should a beef patty cost at your local

4 months ago

View full profile- 11 references

Achievements

12. PEPPA'S JERK CHICKEN

Kips Bay

NYC's undisputed jerk chicken champ. Authentic Jamaican & Caribbean flavors, with a 'peppa sauce' option to maximize taste. Takeout only, but worth every bite.

caribbean 9jamaican 8

9 References (Overwhelmingly Positive)

Recent References

best oxtail rice and peas nyc

4 months ago

jerk chicken recommendations

~1 year ago

best rasta pasta in nyc

~1 year ago

View full profile- 9 references

13. CUTS & SLICES

Lower East Side

Pioneer of unconventional pizza pies w/ flavors like oxtail & jerk chicken. Pricey but creative & delicious slices.

caribbean 12american 4jamaican 2

18 References (Leaning Positive)

Recent References

recommendations around brownsville and east new

2 months ago

what is the most overrated or overpriced piece of

3 months ago

best oxtail rice and peas nyc

4 months ago

View full profile- 18 references

14. FOOTPRINTS CAFE

East Flatbush

Authentic Caribbean flavors, known for its highly recommended Rasta pasta.

caribbean 3jamaican 3

4 References (Overwhelmingly Positive)

Recent References

what to eat on coney island boardwalk that isnt a

~1 year ago

canarsie today whats your spot

~1 year ago

best rasta pasta in nyc

~1 year ago

View full profile- 4 references

15. NOTABLE

Astoria

Incredible, indulgent, and savory Oxtail Philly Cheese Steak on coco bread [1]! Also serving Oxtail, Egg, & Cheese on coco bread, plus daily Jamaican specials like curry goat [1].

caribbean 4jamaican 3

27 References (Very Positive)

Recent References

ferry rides abd restaurants recs ideas

4 months ago

best oxtail rice and peas nyc

4 months ago

oxtail philly cheese steak on coco bread from

9 months ago

View full profile- 27 references

16. GOLDEN KRUST CARIBBEAN BAKERY & GRILL

Harlem

Jamaican patties w/ less grease, more bake. Great goat curry.

jamaican 3caribbean 2

4 References (Leaning Positive)

Recent References

the highs and lows of eating goat in new york

6 months ago

jamaican food

7 months ago

View full profile- 4 references

17. MARKETTE

Chelsea

Fusion of Jamaican & Scottish flavors. Standout peri peri chicken, oxtail, & amazing 'phony negroni' cocktails [1].

jamaican 2scottish 2fusion 2

9 References (Overwhelmingly Positive)

Recent References

dinner near penn station looking for more high

2 months ago

best mocktails in bkmanhattan that arent 20 real

2 months ago

Markette features Peri Peri Chicken, a succulent grilled chicken dish drizzled with both creamy white sauce and a bright orange peri peri sauce, offering a visually appealing and likely spicy and tangy flavor profile. It is served with a side salad in a unique teal dish.

4 months ago

View full profile- 9 references

18. flava of the bronx

Longwood

Beloved Bronx Jamaican spot, known for its amazing oxtail & rice and peas. A true fave!

caribbean 4jamaican 2