Iconic Brooklyn steakhouse famed for its dry-aged porterhouse and legendary burgers; a classic, no-frills NYC dining experience.
Peter Luger Steak House is a legendary Brooklyn institution that has been serving up iconic steaks since 1887. While many rave about their dry-aged porterhouse and life-changing burgers, some diners feel the quality has dipped, leading to mixed reviews. The restaurant maintains a classic, old-school, and no-frills atmosphere, which is often coupled with famously direct service. Despite differing opinions, it remains a must-visit for many seeking a quintessential New York steakhouse experience.
Peter Luger is celebrated for its dry-aged porterhouse steaks, which many patrons consider the best in the city. The burgers, particularly the lunch-only option, also receive high praise and are frequently called life-changing or new favorites. However, some diners have found the steaks to be inconsistent or underwhelming, and a few have been disappointed with sides like tomatoes and onions. The 'schlag' (whipped cream) is also a noted highlight.
"The porterhouse steak is the signature dish and highly recommended. The lunch-only burger is also frequently lauded as a must-try, with many considering it among the best in the city."
Customers have a polarized view of Peter Luger's. Many consider it an iconic and essential NYC steakhouse experience with exceptional steaks and burgers, while others find the quality has declined and the prices are too high for the value.
Important Note
The restaurant is cash-only, though they do provide receipts. Some diners have reported inconsistent steak quality and 'gruff' or direct service, which may not appeal to everyone.
"Peter Luger is listed as a recommended restaurant."
Neutral"This user mentioned Peter Luger as a restaurant offering delivery for high-end meals."
Positive"Peter Luger was cited as a high-end steakhouse available for delivery, noting the potential cost of dishes like a tomahawk steak."
Positive"Peter Luger is suggested as an alternative to Strip House for steak."
Positive"This commenter simply states that Peter Luger's steak sauce is "The best.""
Positive"The commenter identifies Peter Luger's Steak Sauce as a top-tier condiment."
Positive"The commenter's choice for a final meal at Peter Luger's included shrimp cocktail, cheeseburger with bacon, fries, and a sundae."
Positive"The commenter declared they would go to Peter Luger's for their last meal, regardless of criticism."
Positive"The commenter chose Peter Luger's for their last meal, citing it as a decent steakhouse with sentimental value, despite anticipating criticism."
Positive"Peter Luger was highly recommended for out-of-towners for the experience and good food, with delicious desserts and 'schlog', advising reservations far in advance."
Positive"Peter Luger is recommended."
Positive"Peter Luger's was mentioned as a great option, especially for lunch, and is considered a good time."
Positive"Peter Luger was mentioned as the sole recommendation by this user."
Neutral"This user affirmed that Peter Luger's is still a great experience and delicious, noting it's an institution, but also commented that Williamsburg generally lacks spacious restaurants with expensive decor compared to midtown."
Positive"Peter Luger was enthusiastically recommended, emphasizing its status as an institution and delicious food, even if debated among foodies."
Positive"States that Peter Luger's is 'freaking awful' and advises against going there."
Negative"Reiterates that their experience at Peter Luger's remains as good as it was in the 80s, despite changes in people post-COVID."
Positive"Strongly recommends Peter Luger's in Brooklyn as always perfect. They also provide a comparative rating of steakhouses."
Positive"The user agrees that they also love Peter Luger."
Positive"Despite negative opinions, the user loves Peter Luger, attributing it possibly to nostalgia."
Positive
