Iconic old-school Brooklyn steakhouse. Famous for porterhouse, no-frills vibe & legendary status (though debated!).
A Brooklyn institution since 1887, Peter Luger Steak House is a classic no-frills American steakhouse renowned for its dry-aged porterhouse steaks. While opinions are divided on whether it still lives up to its legendary status and price point, many praise its perfectly cooked steaks, flavorful sides like German fried potatoes, and iconic hot fudge sundae. The old-school ambiance, complete with wood-paneled rooms and efficient, albeit sometimes gruff, service, contributes to its unique and enduring charm, making it a quintessential New York dining experience for many.
Renowned for its dry-aged porterhouse steak, Peter Luger also offers other classic American steakhouse fare. While the steak is a main draw, some find it pricey for the quality. Recommended sides include the German fried potatoes and onion rolls, and the 'Holy Cow' hot fudge sundae is a popular dessert. The burger is also frequently mentioned, though opinions on it are mixed, with some finding it superior at lunch.
"The porterhouse steak is the quintessential order, often recommended to be ordered rare. The burger, available only at lunch, also receives strong positive mentions, as do the German fried potatoes and the 'Holy Cow' hot fudge sundae."
Customer sentiment is polarized, with many praising the classic steakhouse experience and legendary porterhouse, while others feel it's overpriced or has declined in quality. Service is often described as gruff but efficient.
Important Note
Peter Luger historically had a cash-only policy, though debit cards are now accepted. Some diners find the service to be gruff, and opinions on whether the restaurant still lives up to its legendary status are divided.
"Suggests Peter Luger Steakhouse in Williamsburg for a classic steakhouse experience."
Positive"Suggests Peter Luger Steakhouse for a classic steakhouse experience."
Positive"Peter Luger Steak House was suggested, though it is not typically known for baked goods like onion rolls."
Neutral"This user mentioned Peter Luger's as an example of a restaurant whose reviews by Pete Wells they missed."
Neutral"Following up on the Peter Luger pecan pie recommendation, this user added that their store-made schlog is very good with pie, and their key lime pie is excellent."
Positive"The user recommended Peter Luger's pecan pie, calling it incredible."
Positive"Recommends the burger at Peter Luger for lunch, describing it as massive with a substantial amount of well-melted cheese, fitting the 'cheesy' criteria."
Positive"Responding to an inquiry about the price of Peter Luger's burger, this user stated it's 'too much' but acknowledged it's a great burger, recalling it was about $30 ten years ago."
Neutral"This commenter stated that Peter Luger has the best French fries of this type they have ever had."
Positive"This user ranks Peter Luger's burger as overhyped and not worth seeking out, considering it crumbly and suggesting one should order the steak instead if dining there."
Negative"This user suggests Peter Luger for lunch, stating that their burger and fries are 'elite' and it's a good option to avoid crowds early in the day. They also mentioned the burger is only served at lunch."
Positive"A follow-up comment suggests that Luger's, like Keens, typically offers standard 28-day dry-aged steaks, unless a change has occurred."
Neutral"This establishment was mentioned as a potential place for dry-aged steaks."
Neutral"Peter Luger's is mentioned as a steakhouse option, with Delmonicos suggested as a more historic alternative."
Positive"Peter Luger's is recommended as a classic steakhouse to experience."
Positive"Peter Luger's is listed as an example of a New York City steakhouse."
Positive"The Holy Cow Sundae at Peter Luger's is highly recommended."
Positive"Peter Luger is a classic NYC steakhouse located in Williamsburg with a long history. While iconic, there are mixed opinions on whether it's still worth the price, and some of its dishes are considered controversial."
Neutral"Peter Luger's is mentioned as a classic New York steakhouse to consider."
Positive"Peter Luger is suggested as a restaurant that every uncle likes."
Positive
