An iconic NYC steakhouse w/ a legendary porterhouse & surprisingly great burgers. Old-school vibe, no-frills, and always a scene.
Peter Luger Steak House, a Brooklyn institution since 1887, is renowned for its signature porterhouse steak and its distinctive cash-only payment policy, offering an iconic and no-frills dining experience. Despite strong opinions existing about the restaurant, many consider it to be a top-tier steakhouse in NYC, with some even calling its burger 'life-changing'. The ambiance and service are described as old-school and classic, with a no-frills menu that excels in execution.
Peter Luger is celebrated for its dry-aged porterhouse steak, often considered among the best in the city. The burgers, particularly the lunch-only option, have garnered significant praise, with some calling them life-changing. Sides like German fried potatoes and creamed spinach receive mixed reviews, and desserts like the hot fudge sundae and cheesecake are popular. Some find the steak sauce too ketchup-heavy, and a few critics have noted a decline in steak quality.
"The dry-aged porterhouse steak is the signature dish and highly recommended. The lunch-only burger, German fried potatoes, and the 'Holy Cow' hot fudge sundae are also frequently praised."
Customer sentiment is polarized, with many praising the iconic steak and classic experience, while others find it overrated or inconsistent. The burgers and desserts often receive high marks, but opinions on service and value vary widely.
Important Note
The restaurant is known for its potentially gruff service, and while it historically accepted only cash, it now accepts debit cards. Some reviews suggest steak quality can be inconsistent, and prices are high.
"Peter Luger is suggested as a good option for a burger, alongside Corner Bistro and Paul's Palace."
Positive"Had a solo lunch at Peter Luger's bar, enjoying both the burger and the ice cream sundae."
Positive"Peter Luger's staff will take good care of you, and they are known to be complimentary with drinks and desserts on special occasions like birthdays."
Positive"The Peter Luger bar is a good option, offering a good burger and the possibility of a single rib steak for one. The staff is noted to be attentive."
Positive"Peter Luger is close to Brooklyn and has great drinks with an underrated burger. The staff is accommodating, especially for birthdays, offering complimentary drinks and desserts."
Positive"This commenter mentions that most classic steakhouses have good cheesecake and specifically calls out Peter Luger's as a standout."
Positive"A burger at Peter Luger is suggested for a special lunch experience."
Positive"A burger at Peter Luger is suggested for a special lunch experience."
Positive"Commenter listed Peter Luger as a restaurant to visit."
Neutral"This commenter states the Peter Luger burger is worth the hype and also recommends Swooneys and Hearth for lunch."
Positive"This commenter mentions the lunch-only burger at Peter Luger as very special, though notes it had slightly declined in quality on their last visit."
Positive"This commenter recommends Peter Luger."
Positive"This commenter recommends the Peter Luger burger."
Positive"The commenter suggests Peter Luger or Keen's for a meal that is 'older than skyscrapers' as a final NYC dining experience."
Positive"Peter Luger is stated as the choice for a last meal in NYC, hands down."
Positive"The commenter states they went to Peter Luger for their farewell meal in NYC."
Neutral"The author rated the Steak for 2 an 8/10, acknowledging its reputation as a tourist trap but confirming it was delicious."
Positive"Mentions Peter Luger as a potential venue for a private dinner."
Neutral"This user lists Peter Luger as a 'nemesis spot'."
Negative"Suggests Peter Luger Steakhouse in Williamsburg for a classic steakhouse experience."
Positive
