Iconic Brooklyn steakhouse, a no-frills, old-school institution famous for its legendary porterhouse.
A legendary Brooklyn institution since 1887, this steakhouse is celebrated for its iconic dry-aged porterhouse steak and a no-frills, old-school dining experience. While opinions on its current quality vary, many consider it a quintessential New York culinary landmark.
Renowned for its dry-aged porterhouse steak, this steakhouse offers a classic American menu. While the porterhouse is frequently highlighted, some diners have noted declining quality or found other dishes, like sides, to be mediocre. The burgers, particularly at lunch, have also garnered positive mentions, and the hot fudge sundae and cheesecake are often recommended desserts.
"The porterhouse steak is the signature dish, often recommended for its dry-aged quality. The burgers, especially at lunchtime, and the hot fudge sundae and cheesecake are also frequently praised."
Customer sentiment is divided; many praise the steaks and classic experience, while others find it inconsistent or overrated and too expensive. Service can be perceived as gruff but efficient by some, and charmingly direct by others.
Important Note
This establishment is known for its strict cash-only policy, though some reports indicate debit cards are now accepted. Reservations are highly recommended, and service can be perceived as gruff by some diners.
"This commenter encouraged the negative sentiment towards Peter Luger to continue."
Neutral"This user agreed with the previous sentiment that many hyped NYC restaurants are overrated."
Neutral"This user simply stated 'Nonsense' in response to a negative comment about Peter Luger."
Neutral"This user feels Peter Luger is fine but not worth the hype or the journey, comparing it to other overrated NYC dining experiences."
Neutral"This comment emphatically suggests Peter Luger."
Neutral"This user countered the negative sentiment towards Peter Luger, stating it's good if you go early enough for the burger."
Positive"This commenter suggested Peter Luger, punning that going there is a 'missteak'."
Negative"The user likes Luger's for its flavor, mentioning it as an option for a birthday steak dinner."
Positive"Peter Luger is listed as a steakhouse option for a birthday celebration in NYC."
Neutral"A user finds it amusing that the dine-and-dash suspect posted a rave review of Peter Luger steakhouse despite being arrested there."
Positive"A user notes that despite being arrested for dine-and-dashing, the suspect still gave Peter Luger a positive review on her blog."
Neutral"A user quotes the suspect's positive review of Peter Luger steak, describing the steak's texture and flavor."
Positive"A user mentions that a dine-and-dash suspect allegedly offered sexual favors in lieu of payment at Peter Luger."
Negative"This steakhouse was a great dining experience on Thanksgiving one year."
Positive"Peter Luger's was listed as one of the notable burger restaurants included in a new burger league."
Neutral"Peter Luger Steak House was mentioned as a recommendation for a cool steakhouse with great food, similar to Au Cheval."
Positive"A simple endorsement for Peter Luger's steakhouse."
Positive"The commenter believes Peter Luger's is the best steakhouse in NYC, stating that nothing else compares, despite receiving criticism on the subreddit previously."
Positive"This user confirms that Peter Luger's Brooklyn location now accepts debit cards, contrary to previous information."
Neutral"A native New Yorker criticizes Peter Luger's, stating that people under 55 or with significant food knowledge don't hold it in high regard. They suggest better dining options are available nearby."
Negative
