Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (212) 529-6732
Address: 45 EAST 18 STREET 10003
Old-school NYC charm with highly-rated burgers and a unique historical ambiance; great for a casual bite or drinks.
Step into a piece of New York City's history at Old Town Bar, a beloved establishment that offers a quintessential American dining experience. Despite not being a Western saloon, it captures a similar old-school charm that transports diners back in time. It's a popular spot for both casual drinks and meals, with an upstairs area accommodating families. Diners often rave about their burgers and a particularly noteworthy grilled cheese on pumpernickel. While the wings have garnered some less enthusiastic reviews, the overall atmosphere and historical significance make it a must-visit for those seeking an authentic New York vibe.
Old Town Bar offers American cuisine with some Irish influences. While some patrons have found the wings to be dry and flavorless, others highly recommend the burgers and the grilled cheese sandwich on pumpernickel. It's generally considered a good spot for classic bar food.
"The burgers and the grilled cheese sandwich on pumpernickel are frequently highlighted as must-try items at Old Town Bar."
Customers generally have positive experiences at Old Town Bar, appreciating its historical ambiance and suitability for various occasions, including family outings. While some specific dishes like wings receive mixed reviews, others like the grilled cheese and burgers are frequently recommended.
Important Note
While generally recommended for its historical atmosphere and burgers, some patrons have had less positive experiences with specific items like the wings.
"Recommends Old Town Bar and Blackbirds, also sharing a link to a wing review Instagram."
Positive"Agrees that Old Town Bar was not great."
Negative"Had a negative experience at Old Town Bar, finding the wings dry and flavorless, but heard good things about Plug Uglies."
Negative"Recommends Old Town Bar near Union Square for wings."
Positive"The original poster mentioned that their family has already visited Old Town Bar during their trip to NYC."
Neutral"The Old Town on 18th Street is recommended as an old-school burger joint with an upstairs suitable for kids, which the commenter has personally used."
Positive"Recommends Old Town (likely Old Town Bar) for burgers."
Positive"Questions if Old Town Bar is a real dive bar anymore, answering their own question with "no.""
Neutral"The grilled cheese with mushrooms on pumpernickel is good."
Positive"Recommends Old Town Bar for burgers."
Positive"A commenter suggests visiting bars that offer a sense of NYC history, listing Old Town Bar as an example."
Neutral"one of the oldest"
Neutral"not western but hits all the other notes"
Neutral"The women's side is weird."
Negative"Old Town had a urinal party to celebrate their anniversary."
Neutral"Men's room has very old urinals, making the user feel like they're part of history."
Positive
