NYC's oldest steakhouse, est. 1868. Famous for massive prime beef cuts, legendary ribeye & porterhouse. A true classic w/ historic charm.
Step into a piece of New York's culinary history at this iconic steakhouse, operating since 1868 and renowned for its massive cuts of prime beef. The menu boasts tender, flavorful ribeye and perfectly cooked porterhouse, complemented by classic sides like garlic mashed potatoes and creamed spinach. Don't miss the 'Drug Store Old Fashioned Sundae' for a sweet finish to a memorable meal.
This historic American steakhouse, established in 1868, is celebrated for its prime beef selections, including highly recommended porterhouse and ribeye. Classic sides such as garlic mashed potatoes and creamed spinach are popular pairings. While many praise the quality, some recent feedback suggests inconsistency and a less remarkable experience compared to its storied reputation.
"Highly recommended dishes include the tender and flavorful ribeye, a well-cooked porterhouse, and the 'Drug Store Old Fashioned Sundae' for dessert. The French onion soup is also singled out as exceptional."
Customer feedback is mixed, with many praising the quality of the steaks and the historic atmosphere, while others note a decline in consistency or find it underwhelming compared to newer establishments.
Important Note
Some diners have noted a decline in quality and consistency over the years, with a few experiencing underwhelming meals or stomach issues after dining.
"The commenter mentioned losing their beef virginity at Old Homestead Steakhouse, but experienced a subsequent stomach ache."
Negative"In the commenter's opinion, Old Homestead has always been 'meh' and not a standout steakhouse."
Neutral"The commenter states that Old Homestead has fallen significantly in quality and is no longer worth visiting, having had consistently awful experiences in the last 1.5 years."
Negative"The commenter dismisses a previous suggestion and instead recommends Old Homestead."
Positive"Old Homestead is suggested as an excellent alternative to Delmonico's and Gallagher's."
Positive"The commenter was disappointed with Old Homestead on a previous visit, though it has been a long time since then."
Negative"The user mentioned The Old Homestead Steak House as a place that always has tables available, suggesting it as a potential option."
Neutral"The French onion soup at The Old Homestead is described as "suuuuuper roasted" and excellent, considered the best thing on the menu."
Positive"Old Homestead was listed as one of the steakhouses where the commenter had tried a ribeye for $58, describing the experience as decent but not particularly memorable in a conversation about high-priced steaks."
Neutral"Old Homestead is the recommended choice."
Positive"Old Homestead is recommended."
Positive"Old Homestead has great bar seating."
Positive"The Old Homestead, located near Chelsea Market, is recommended as the oldest steakhouse in Manhattan."
Positive"A simple recommendation for Old Homestead Steakhouse."
Positive"The commenter considers Old Homestead Steakhouse to have a better steak than Peter Luger's."
Positive"Directly recommends The Old Homestead steakhouse for dinner."
Positive"The Old Homestead had a deal for a porterhouse for two, Caesar salad, mashed potatoes, and creamed spinach for under $200 with tip, tax, and drinks."
Positive"The commenter believes Old Homestead serves the best actual steak among Manhattan steakhouses of its level, differentiating it from Keens."
Positive"The commenter recalled a very satisfying experience with the wedge salad at Old Homestead, even under the influence of alcohol."
Positive"Found Old Homestead to be very underwhelming for a birthday dinner last year, although they wouldn't say it 'sucks'."
Negative
