TLDR
Historic steakhouse est. 1868 offering massive steak selection in a unique presidential library-style space. A go-to for NYC classics near the Meatpacking District.
Details
Operating since 1868, this historic steakhouse offers a vast array of high-quality beef in a unique, presidential library-like setting [1]. While many diners laud its steaks as superior to other famous Manhattan competitors, recent reviews have shown a divide in opinion regarding its current consistency and value [2], [3], [4]. Guests can expect a classic American menu, though experiences can vary significantly between visitors [1], [5].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American steakhouse staples, featuring highly-regarded porterhouse and rib eye cuts, along with excellent classic sides like garlic mashed potatoes, creamed spinach, and a standout 'suuuuuper roasted' French onion soup [1], [6]. While many enjoy the food, some diners find certain high-priced steaks to be only decent rather than exceptional for the cost [5], [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OLD HOMESTEAD
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Fununique Food Near Meatpacking Districtgreenwich
"The user recommended visiting this historic steakhouse as a dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Reliably Get Prime Rib Roast Beef In
"Notes prime rib is on the menu but without listed pricing."
NeutralFrom post: What Are Some Restaurants And Bars That Tony
"Questioned if this was the steakhouse used for a specific scene in the show."
NeutralFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"The commenter mentioned losing their beef virginity at Old Homestead Steakhouse, but experienced a subsequent stomach ache."
NegativeFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"In the commenter's opinion, Old Homestead has always been 'meh' and not a standout steakhouse."
Neutral