TLDR
Historic steakhouse est. 1868 offering massive steak selection in a unique presidential library-style space. A go-to for NYC classics near the Meatpacking District.
Details
Operating since 1868, this historic steakhouse offers a vast array of high-quality beef in a unique, presidential library-like setting [1]. While many diners laud its steaks as superior to other famous Manhattan competitors, recent reviews have shown a divide in opinion regarding its current consistency and value [2], [3], [4]. Guests can expect a classic American menu, though experiences can vary significantly between visitors [1], [5].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American steakhouse staples, featuring highly-regarded porterhouse and rib eye cuts, along with excellent classic sides like garlic mashed potatoes, creamed spinach, and a standout 'suuuuuper roasted' French onion soup [1], [6]. While many enjoy the food, some diners find certain high-priced steaks to be only decent rather than exceptional for the cost [5], [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OLD HOMESTEAD
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Fununique Food Near Meatpacking Districtgreenwich
"The user recommended visiting this historic steakhouse as a dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Reliably Get Prime Rib Roast Beef In
"Notes prime rib is on the menu but without listed pricing."
NeutralFrom post: What Are Some Restaurants And Bars That Tony
"Questioned if this was the steakhouse used for a specific scene in the show."
NeutralFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"The commenter mentioned losing their beef virginity at Old Homestead Steakhouse, but experienced a subsequent stomach ache."
NegativeFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"In the commenter's opinion, Old Homestead has always been 'meh' and not a standout steakhouse."
NeutralFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"The commenter states that Old Homestead has fallen significantly in quality and is no longer worth visiting, having had consistently awful experiences in the last 1.5 years."
NegativeFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"The commenter dismisses a previous suggestion and instead recommends Old Homestead."
PositiveFrom post: Delmonicos Or Gallaghers For Birthday Steak Dinner
"Old Homestead is suggested as an excellent alternative to Delmonico's and Gallagher's."
PositiveFrom post: Delmonicos Or Gallaghers For Birthday Steak Dinner
"The commenter was disappointed with Old Homestead on a previous visit, though it has been a long time since then."
NegativeFrom post: Steakhouse Manhattandress Code And Reservations
"The user mentioned The Old Homestead Steak House as a place that always has tables available, suggesting it as a potential option."
NeutralFrom post: A List Of French Onion Soups Ive Had Recently
"The French onion soup at The Old Homestead is described as "suuuuuper roasted" and excellent, considered the best thing on the menu."
PositiveFrom post: Does Everyone Have A Corporate Card In Finance Or
"Old Homestead was listed as one of the steakhouses where the commenter had tried a ribeye for $58, describing the experience as decent but not particularly memorable in a conversation about high-priced steaks."
NeutralFrom post: Best Steakhouse With Solo Bar Seating
"Old Homestead is the recommended choice."
PositiveFrom post: Best Steakhouse With Solo Bar Seating
"Old Homestead is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Best Steakhouse With Solo Bar Seating
"Old Homestead has great bar seating."
PositiveFrom post: Best Steak House In Your Opinion In Manhattan Nyc
"The Old Homestead, located near Chelsea Market, is recommended as the oldest steakhouse in Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Mightiest Steakhouses In Nyc Keens Next
"A simple recommendation for Old Homestead Steakhouse."
PositiveFrom post: Mightiest Steakhouses In Nyc Keens Next
"The commenter considers Old Homestead Steakhouse to have a better steak than Peter Luger's."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurant Tonight With 12 Year Old
"Directly recommends The Old Homestead steakhouse for dinner."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Steakhouses For Two 300 Budget Incl Drinks
"The Old Homestead had a deal for a porterhouse for two, Caesar salad, mashed potatoes, and creamed spinach for under $200 with tip, tax, and drinks."
Positive