Historic Meatpacking District steakhouse serving massive cuts of prime beef since 1868. Offers a classic, hearty American dining experience, though reviews vary on consistency.
Step into a piece of New York's culinary history at Old Homestead Steakhouse, a venerable institution that has been serving massive cuts of prime beef since 1868. Nestled in the historic Meatpacking District, this classic American steakhouse offers a robust dining experience that appeals to traditionalists and steak aficionados alike. While its age and reputation for generous portions of high-quality beef are undeniable draws, recent customer feedback suggests a varied experience. Some diners laud it as a go-to for a classic 'meat and potatoes' meal, praising its historical significance and hearty offerings. However, whispers of inconsistency and past controversies, like alleged misrepresentation of 'Kobe beef,' have surfaced. Despite these mixed reviews, Old Homestead remains a prominent name in the NYC steak scene, offering a glimpse into the city's storied past with every perfectly cooked steak.
Old Homestead Steakhouse is primarily known for its steaks and classic American steakhouse fare, with a focus on large cuts of prime beef. It's frequently mentioned in discussions about New York City steakhouses. While some patrons consider it a reliable choice, especially for a straightforward meal, others have experienced inconsistencies. A notable past criticism involved the restaurant allegedly selling 'fake Kobe beef.' Despite this, it's often recommended for those seeking a traditional steakhouse experience, though some reviews suggest it might be overpriced or surpassed by other establishments in the city.
"While specific dishes aren't highlighted, the restaurant is known for its large cuts of prime beef, fitting a traditional 'meat and potatoes' steakhouse experience."
Customers have mixed feelings about Old Homestead Steakhouse. While some recommend it as a classic steakhouse option, particularly for those who enjoy a 'meat and potatoes' style meal or are looking for historic establishments, others express disappointment. Negative feedback includes claims of inconsistent quality, with one user mentioning a past issue with the restaurant selling 'fake Kobe beef.' Another diner found it underwhelming for a birthday dinner, and some suggest there are better steakhouse options available in the city. There's a sentiment that the restaurant may not have been good for years, despite its historical reputation.
Important Note
Past criticisms include allegations of selling 'fake Kobe beef' and general inconsistencies in quality. Some diners find it underwhelming or overpriced compared to other steakhouses in the city.
"Found Old Homestead to be very underwhelming for a birthday dinner last year, although they wouldn't say it 'sucks'."
Negative"States that Old Homestead hasn't been good for years."
Negative"Includes Old Homestead as number 7 on a comparative rating of steakhouses, placing it below NYC options and other non-NYC places."
Neutral"Recommends Old Homestead in the meat packing district."
Positive"The user stated that the Old Homestead Steakhouse is okay but recommended leaving the area and heading elsewhere."
Neutral"Old Homestead is recommended as a steakhouse option that fits the desired vibe, though it can be expensive, potentially costing around $200 per person if everyone orders their own steak."
Neutral"Old Homestead was listed as one of the commenter's recent favorite steakhouses."
Positive"A commenter suggested Old Homestead Steak House as a suitable option for basic 'meat and potatoes' for the picky eater."
Positive"Recommends Old Homestead or Wolfgang's."
Positive"what you're saying is theoretical, not indisputable. Luger's is literally the best example because it's still considered one of the top places in nyc and it's still guilty of giving you inconsistent results. a bad example would be me giving you a no-name place just to cherry pick. one sided sear, burnt steak, gruff service, improper temps, it's not just lugers. Gallagher's, keens, Smiths, amber, etc. remember when old homestead was selling us fake Kobe beef? indisputable would mean they'd all have 5 star reviews, and in every 2 star review there's a hint of truth because we've all experienced it. the ones that actually do as you dream of are few and far between. drop a few names because they represent the minority of the steakhouses in nyc."
Negative"Keen’s, Old Homestead and Strip House would be good options."
Positive"Old Homestead Steakhouse is probably the closest. You're also within a 20 minute walk of Keen's and Strip House."
Neutral
