Reliable Theater District bistro with a famous burger and standout martinis. A must-visit for pre-show dining.
Ciera Velarde reviews Joe Allen, a Theater District bistro known for its pre-theater meals, praising its burger and martinis.
A stalwart of the Theater District since 1965, Joe Allen offers a reliable and charming dining experience perfect for pre- or post-theater meals. The American bistro is known for its efficient service, ensuring you won't miss your show, and its cozy atmosphere enhanced by walls adorned with Broadway flop posters. Standout dishes include a thick, juicy burger with crispy fries and a perfectly made martini with a sidecar.
The American cuisine at Joe Allen is generally well-received, particularly its burgers and martinis. While the menu offers standard fare, the burger with fries is a standout. The banana cream pie is also a highly recommended dessert. However, the shrimp cocktail is noted as being underwhelming and not served on ice.
"The Joe Allen Burger, served with crispy shoestring fries, is a highly recommended dish. The restaurant's martinis are also a notable highlight."
Customers generally have a positive experience, highlighting it as a reliable choice for pre-theater dining with good food and a pleasant atmosphere. Some specific dishes like the banana cream pie and burgers are frequently recommended.
Important Note
The shrimp cocktail is not recommended as it is not served on ice.
"Joe Allen is suggested as a dining option near the theater."
Neutral"The commenter suggests having a steak at Keens and a banana cream pie at Joe Allen."
Neutral"Joe Allen's banana cream pie is specifically recommended."
Positive"A commenter suggested Jo as a possible omakase option, noting its price of exactly $300 per person."
Neutral"Joe Allen was simply mentioned as a suggestion for a pre-Broadway lunch."
Neutral"Joe Allen was suggested as a restaurant option, with a recommendation to make reservations."
Neutral"A commenter recommends Joe Allen's as an "old reliable" choice in the theater district, suggesting it might be more conveniently located than Keen's for the user's needs."
Positive"The original poster mentions looking at Joe Allen as a pre-Broadway option but prefers the options at Blue Dog or Yakitori Totto."
Neutral"Recommends Joe Allen, describing it as very good ('VG')."
Positive"Recommended restaurant to visit before a show, make reservation"
Positive"User recommended to get the banana cream pie."
Positive
