Iconic NYC pub w/ legendary burgers & classic American fare. Timeless vibe, cheerful staff, a true neighborhood gem since '72.
JG Melon is a classic New York institution, revered for its timeless pub ambiance and consistently good American fare. Established in 1972, this Upper East Side gem offers a nostalgic experience with its signature green-and-white checkered tablecloths and cheerful staff. While the legendary cheeseburger is a major draw, other satisfying options like hearty chili and classic sandwiches also contribute to its enduring popularity.
JG Melon is celebrated for its classic American pub food, with a particular emphasis on its legendary cheeseburger, often described as a must-try. Other popular dishes include their hearty chili and turkey club sandwich. While most feedback is positive, a few reviewers have found the burger to be average or even dry, and some have had negative experiences with the fries.
"The classic cheeseburger is consistently recommended, often described as legendary. The cup of chili and cottage fries are also noted as satisfying options."
Customers overwhelmingly praise JG Melon for its classic American pub atmosphere and reliably good food, particularly its burgers. While some note potential long wait times and the cash-only policy, the overall sentiment is highly positive, highlighting its nostalgic appeal and consistent quality.
Important Note
The restaurant is cash-only and can have significant wait times, especially for dinner. Some reviewers have noted that the fries can be disappointing.
"The commenter enjoyed JG Melon's burgers and misses a now-closed UWS location, noting the Third Ave location is still good but hasn't been visited recently."
Positive"The commenter recalls JG Melon's burgers being very tasty, but notes they haven't been there in a while and confirms the price is over $20 with fries."
Positive"The commenter suggests that JG Melon is worth the slight overage in price and that splitting a side can help stay within budget."
Positive"JG Melon's cheeseburger with fries is noted as being over $20."
Negative"JG Melon is recommended for its burgers, though it may exceed the $20 budget."
Positive"JG Melon was mentioned as a classic sit-down burger place, suitable for someone wanting a traditional American burger experience."
Positive"JG Melon was mentioned by this user as another recommendation."
Positive"Jg Melon was recommended as a place to get chili."
Positive"JG Melons was suggested, noted as a cash-only NYC institution. While known for burgers, they also offer great sandwiches and other dishes. The location is on the Upper East Side."
Positive"JG Melon is recommended as a classic NYC spot for burgers."
Positive"JG Melon is recommended as a classic NYC spot for burgers."
Positive"Suggests Melon's as an option."
Neutral"Suggested as a place for classic burgers that teens might enjoy."
Neutral"The Halal option at JG Melon is described as 'going hard,' indicating a very positive experience."
Positive"JG Melon is listed as a recommendation."
Neutral"JG Melon is mentioned as a dining option."
Neutral"JG Melon is mentioned as a dining option."
Neutral"The original poster finds JG Melon appealing and notes they might need to withdraw cash."
Positive"JG Melon is suggested as an option if the user is willing to wait until 11:30 AM and pay in cash."
Positive"This commenter finds JG Melon overrated and suggests the burgers lack seasoning, attributing its popularity to an older demographic."
Negative
