Iconic NYC burger joint with a classic vibe, serving up nostalgic American pub fare and a legendary cheeseburger.
JG Melon is an iconic and legendary Upper East Side establishment, celebrated for its classic American pub ambiance and highly-regarded burgers. Since opening in 1972, it has maintained a timeless appeal with its charming, old-school setting and no-frills approach to comfort food. While the burgers are the main draw for many, other dishes like steak tartare and chili also receive positive mentions, making it a beloved neighborhood spot.
JG Melon is primarily known for its classic American pub fare, with a strong emphasis on its burgers, which are frequently recommended. While many find the burgers to be excellent and nostalgic, a few reviews suggest they are average or even dry. Other dishes like steak tartare, chili, and cottage fries also receive positive mentions.
"The cheeseburger is the most frequently recommended dish, often paired with cottage fries. Steak tartare and chili are also noted as positive menu items."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards JG Melon, often praising its classic New York vibe and highly recommending its burgers. Some, however, find the burgers to be average and note long wait times.
Important Note
The restaurant is cash-only and does not accept reservations. Wait times can be significant, especially during peak hours.
"JG Melon is recommended."
Positive"JG Melon, a cash-only establishment, is recommended and located at E 74th and 3rd."
Positive"This commenter simply stated JG Melons as their choice for a final meal."
Positive"The commenter would have the cured sardine roast, lamb steak with fennel salad, and sheep's cheese agnolotti from Lilia, but also cited JG Melon for its burgers, fries, and apple pie due to nostalgia and personal significance."
Positive"This comment suggests J.G. Melon's popularity is driven by social media hype rather than the burger itself."
Neutral"This user enjoys the vibe at J.G. Melon, mentioning that the hamburger and martini combination is a great experience."
Positive"Responding to a negative comment, this user found J.G. Melon's burger to be very solid, attributing its popularity to the vibe."
Positive"This user did not enjoy their experience at J.G. Melon."
Negative"The user praises J.G. Melon's burger for its simplicity and smaller size, stating it's a satisfying ideal burger."
Positive"J.G. Melon used to be a good spot for a classic burger but is now considered overrated due to constant lines."
Negative"This user strongly dislikes J.G. Melon and questions its popularity."
Negative"This user likes the vibe at J.G. Melon but considers Shake Shack to be fast food, preferring 7th Street."
Neutral"This user believes J.G. Melon might serve the worst burger in NYC and does not understand its appeal."
Negative"J.G. Melon is described as fine, with Shake Shack being a better quality fast food option."
Neutral"JG Melon is a classic NYC spot known for its no-frills, iconic burger and cottage fries, maintaining an old-school feel. It's important to note that the restaurant is cash only and does not accept reservations."
Positive"The commenter suggested that the bartenders at JG Melon might find the request for a Long Island Iced Tea amusing."
Neutral"The commenter finds dining solo at Jg Melon to be a highly satisfying experience."
Positive"JG Melon is a cash-only establishment."
Neutral"JG Melon is a personal favorite."
Positive"JG Melon is considered one of the top NYC burgers and doesn't receive enough appreciation."
Positive
