Iconic UES pub known for legendary, no-frills burgers & cottage fries. A cash-only, classic NYC experience.
A beloved Upper East Side institution since 1972, JG Melon offers a quintessential New York American pub experience. This cash-only spot is celebrated for its iconic, no-frills cheeseburgers and cottage fries, served in a classic, unpretentious atmosphere that feels like a step back in time. It's a go-to for a satisfying, traditional pub meal that has stood the test of time.
JG Melon is celebrated for its classic American pub fare, with the cheeseburger and cottage fries being standout items. While many rave about the burgers, calling them iconic and among the best in the city, a few find them average or even dry. The steak tartare and chili also receive positive mentions. The restaurant is cash-only.
"The cheeseburger and cottage fries are frequently recommended as must-try items. The steak tartare and a cup of chili are also noted positively."
Customers overwhelmingly praise JG Melon for its classic New York pub vibe and consistently delicious burgers and fries. While some find it overrated or note long wait times, most agree it's a nostalgic and satisfying experience.
Important Note
JG Melon is a cash-only establishment and does not accept reservations. Wait times can be significant, especially during peak hours.
"JG Melon is mentioned as a dining option."
Neutral"JG Melon is mentioned as a dining option."
Neutral"The original poster finds JG Melon appealing and notes they might need to withdraw cash."
Positive"JG Melon is suggested as an option if the user is willing to wait until 11:30 AM and pay in cash."
Positive"This commenter finds JG Melon overrated and suggests the burgers lack seasoning, attributing its popularity to an older demographic."
Negative"JG Melon is considered overrated by this user, with a critique of the burger's seasoning, suggesting it caters to a less discerning palate."
Negative"Multiple mentions of JG Melon suggest it's a reliable option for late-night food, particularly burgers."
Positive"JG Melon's kitchen stays open until 2:30 AM most nights and is praised for having one of the best burgers in the city, though it is cash only."
Positive"JG Melon is mentioned as a place with good burgers and a kitchen open late."
Positive"JG Mellon's is listed among the commenter's favorite burger spots in NYC."
Positive"This user expressed a generally negative view of several popular burger spots, including JG Melon, stating they 'suckkkk'."
Negative"JG Melon was suggested as a burger option."
Positive"JG Melon was mentioned as a potential option, but it has waiter service at tables, which might not fit the user's counter-service preference."
Neutral"JG Melon is recommended for a burger, described as a top-tier, everyday burger that most New Yorkers love."
Positive"JG Mellon is suggested for a sit-down burger experience if one doesn't mind spending a bit more."
Positive"Echoing a previous recommendation, this user found the Bloody Mary at JG Melon to be exceptionally good, despite its simplicity."
Positive"JG Melon is recommended for its Bloody Mary."
Positive"JG Melon is recommended."
Positive"JG Melon, a cash-only establishment, is recommended and located at E 74th and 3rd."
Positive
