TLDR
Legendary upside-down Sicilian squares and iconic house-made spumoni; a must-visit old-school BK institution.
Reddit Sentiment for L&B SPUMONI GARDENS(based on 97 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
L&B Spumoni Gardens is highlighted as one of the top 15 best pizza restaurants in New York City, known for its iconic Sicilian squares.
L&B Spumoni Gardens, a long-standing family-owned pizzeria in Brooklyn established in 1939, has introduced a new menu item, the vodka square pizza. This post captures a visitor's experience trying this new offering, suggesting it's an exciting addition for fans of the iconic establishment. The restaurant is well-known for its pizza and homemade spumoni.
Details
A quintessential New York institution, this Brooklyn staple is world-renowned for its unique upside-down Sicilian square pizza [1]. The doughy, cheese-under-sauce crust creates a distinctive mochi-like texture that many consider a local masterpiece [2], [3]. Beyond the pizza, guests can enjoy a full menu of red-sauce Italian classics and must-try house-made spumoni desserts [4], [5].
Food Overview
The restaurant is defined by its thick, square Sicilian-style pizza featuring sweet marinara sauce layered over cheese [1], [3]. While the pizza is highly recommended by many, opinions on the texture and sauce sweetness vary, with some preferring the round slices or fresh cutlet sandwiches [2], [4], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About L&B SPUMONI GARDENS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Mentioned as a superior alternative to DiFara."
PositiveFrom post: I Took My Daughter To Difara For A Premovie
"Ranked as the third best pizza option by the user, following Mama's Too and DiFara."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And
"Still considered an institution despite opinions that it has gone downhill."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And
"Mentioned that quality has gone downhill and they are not known for their plain slice."
NegativeFrom post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And
"Included in a list of recommended pizza spots."
PositiveFrom post: I Had The Gargiulo Burger At Hamburger America
"Mentioned by the user as a comparison point for food quality."
NeutralFrom post: 2026 So Far My Favorite Bites All Are Highly
"A local recommends visiting on a nice day for fresh slices and spumoni."
PositiveFrom post: 2026 So Far My Favorite Bites All Are Highly
"The author praises the light thick crust and calls it better than other popular pizza spots."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Places To Buy Ice Cream Pints In
"The commenter notes the pistachio spumoni is legendary."
PositiveFrom post: Reccs For Someone Who Loves Sarges Lazarras Old
"Considered to be a very old-school institution."
PositiveFrom post: Spumoni And Sicilian Slice From Lb Spumoni
"The commenter compares the pizza texture to chewing on a kitchen sponge."
NegativeFrom post: Spumoni And Sicilian Slice From Lb Spumoni
"The commenter recommends trying the round slice at L&B."
PositiveFrom post: Spumoni And Sicilian Slice From Lb Spumoni
"The commenter and their spouse agree that the pizza is mediocre, arguing the attraction is the outdoor atmosphere rather than the food."
NeutralFrom post: Spumoni And Sicilian Slice From Lb Spumoni
"The commenter found the pizza mid, but felt the spumoni was excellent."
NeutralFrom post: Spumoni And Sicilian Slice From Lb Spumoni
"The commenter considers the pizza highly overrated but found the spumoni acceptable."
NeutralFrom post: Spumoni And Sicilian Slice From Lb Spumoni
"The pizza is described as weak, though the people-watching and spumoni are cited as highlights."
NeutralFrom post: Spumoni And Sicilian Slice From Lb Spumoni
"The commenter states that the establishment is overrated."
NegativeFrom post: Spumoni And Sicilian Slice From Lb Spumoni
"The commenter defends the sauce as delicious marinara and disagrees with the 'ketchup' comparison."
PositiveFrom post: Spumoni And Sicilian Slice From Lb Spumoni
"The commenter prefers Ralph's for spumoni and reaffirms their negative opinion on the pizza quality."
NegativeFrom post: Spumoni And Sicilian Slice From Lb Spumoni
"The commenter dislikes the pizza, comparing it to a wet sponge with ketchup, and also does not care for the spumoni."
Negative