Iconic Brooklyn pizzeria: legendary square slices, unique sauce-over-cheese prep & homemade spumoni since the 40s.
Step into a Brooklyn institution where pizza is king and tradition reigns supreme. Since the 1940s, this family-owned gem has been serving up iconic square Sicilian slices with a unique sauce-over-cheese preparation. Beyond the legendary pizza, don't miss out on their namesake spumoni and other classic Italian-American fare in a setting that feels like a step back in time.
This pizzeria is renowned for its distinctive square Sicilian pizza, featuring a thick crust with sauce applied over the cheese, a preparation method that sets it apart. While the square slices are highly recommended, opinions are divided on other offerings, with some users finding the regular slices and pepperoni pies less impressive. The spumoni, a traditional Italian frozen dessert, is also a popular and well-loved item.
"The iconic square Sicilian pizza, with its unique sauce-over-cheese preparation, is the most highly recommended dish. The spumoni, a traditional Italian ice cream, is also a must-try."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the authentic, old-school pizza experience, with many considering it a must-visit institution. While some find it overrated, the majority celebrate its unique square slices and classic Italian-American offerings.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that the quality may have declined over the years or that certain non-signature items, like pepperoni pies or regular slices, might be overrated. Additionally, the vodka squares are reportedly only sold by the whole pie, which can be inconvenient.
"Spumoni Gardens is considered overrated."
Negative"The Dumbo location of Spumoni Gardens was not impressive and is considered not good."
Negative"While enjoying Dani's, the reviewer found Spumoni Gardens' pizza sauce too sweet."
Negative"Spumoni Gardens is highly recommended for its square/Sicilian pizza."
Positive"The commenter suggests Spumoni Gardens as a must-visit food spot."
Positive"L&B Spumoni Gardens has a small restaurant on-site that was thought to be great for red sauce Italian."
Positive"L&B is mentioned as one of the best Sicilian (square) pizzas in New York."
Positive"This user inquired if LnB refers to Spumoni Gardens."
Neutral"This user is interested in whether LnB fries cutlets to order, as it would be a significant feature."
Positive"This user recommended Spumoni Gardens, along with Brancaccio's and Leoni's."
Positive"This user suggested LnB, stating they fry cutlets fresh right in front of customers."
Positive"Confirming their previous comment, this user acknowledges that L&B Spumoni Gardens is known for Sicilian slices, not grandma slices, but states the Sicilian is great."
Positive"In response to a comment about L&B Spumoni Gardens, the user states that while their Sicilian might be good, they believe Ave U Pizza's grandma slice is better."
Neutral"This user clarifies that L&B Spumoni Gardens is known for its thick Sicilian slices, not grandma slices, and that VanceAdvance may be confusing the two."
Neutral"This user simply tags L&B Spumoni Gardens."
Neutral"This commenter hasn't been to the original L&B Spumoni Gardens in years but heard the Dumbo location doesn't have great things."
Neutral"This user strongly recommends L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn for their square grandma pizza, describing it as a whole experience and noting the lines move fast."
Positive"This user found the original Spunoni's to be amazing and exactly what a slice should be."
Positive"The user mentioned L&B Spumoni as a solid spot with reasonable prices, in comparison to Don Pepe's."
Positive"This user strongly disliked Spumoni Gardens, calling it 'trash' and suggesting Bamontes or Joes of Ave U as better old-school Italian options."
Negative
