Iconic Sicilian square pizza & spumoni; old-school Brooklyn institution.
L&B Spumoni Gardens is a historic Brooklyn institution, serving up iconic Sicilian square pizza since the 1940s. Famous for its thick crust and unique sauce-over-cheese preparation, this family-owned pizzeria is a beloved local gem. Beyond their legendary pizza, they also offer delicious spumoni, making it a must-visit for an authentic taste of old-school New York.
L&B Spumoni Gardens is renowned for its classic Sicilian square pizza, featuring a thick crust with sauce often placed over the cheese. While the square slices and spumoni are highly recommended, some reviews suggest that regular pizza slices might be less impressive. The establishment also offers pasta and other Italian-American fare.
"The square Sicilian pizza, particularly the 'saucey square' or upside-down pizza, is highly recommended. The spumoni ice cream is also a signature dessert that diners suggest trying."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards L&B Spumoni Gardens, frequently recommending its signature square pizza and spumoni. Some debate exists about whether it's overrated, but many consider it an iconic and worthwhile experience, especially the original location.
Important Note
Some diners feel the restaurant can be overrated, and one commenter noted that the vodka squares are only sold as whole pies, which might be inconvenient for some.
"This establishment was recommended as a red sauce joint similar to Bamonte's."
Neutral"The user suggests adding L&B Spumoni Gardens for their creamsicle soft serve."
Positive"For something unique to the area, taking the D/N train two stops to L and B Spumoni is recommended for their square pizza and spumoni."
Positive"The user suggests taking the N/W subway train one stop to 86th Street, implying a location related to a previous recommendation."
Neutral"A user suggests taking a quick Uber to L&B."
Neutral"This commenter simply stated L&B as their choice for a final meal."
Positive"The commenter's final meals included L&B Spumoni, as part of their last bites in the city."
Positive"The commenter recommends visiting the original Spumoni Gardens in Gravesend, Brooklyn for their Sicilian pizza, advising to skip the DUMBO location. They note that going to this area is an experience in itself."
Positive"L&B Spumoni is famous for its square Sicilian pizza slices and its spumoni. The establishment has been serving since the 1940s."
Positive"This user inquired if a solution for L&B delivery to Manhattan was found, expressing interest in the method."
Negative"This user mentioned that their previous workplace received deliveries from L&B, but it was for large orders."
Negative"This user suggested using Taskrabbit for delivery."
Negative"This user suggested checking Goldbelly for delivery options."
Negative"The user questions if L&B, a pizzeria in Southern Brooklyn, is confirmed to have racist owners, as some NYC pizza places are perceived to have, indicating a concern about the establishment's practices beyond just food."
Neutral"The original L&B is considered by the commenter to be the 'pilgrimage-worthy' pizza spot."
Positive"A user confirms that the original L&B Spumoni Gardens location requires purchasing vodka squares as a whole pie."
Neutral"A user mentions that L&B's Bensonhurst location only sells vodka squares by the whole pie, which is inconvenient for them to transport."
Negative"A user compares the original L&B Spumoni Gardens to its Dumbo counterpart, noting the original has a more authentic ambiance while the pizza taste is comparable."
Positive"L&B Spumoni Gardens in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn was described as a 'sleeper hit' for its calamari."
Positive"L&B Spumoni Gardens is strongly endorsed as the preferred choice for outdoor pizza."
Positive
