Iconic Brooklyn pizzeria known for its legendary Sicilian square slices & classic spumoni. An old-school gem w/ over 80 yrs of history.
An iconic Brooklyn institution since the 1930s, L&B Spumoni Gardens is renowned for its unique Sicilian-style square pizza, featuring a thick, airy crust with sauce layered over cheese. Beyond their legendary pizza, they also serve classic Italian-American dishes and their namesake spumoni, a delightful frozen dessert. This family-run establishment offers a nostalgic dining experience that continues to draw crowds for its authentic flavors.
The star of the show is undoubtedly the Sicilian square pizza, characterized by its thick, airy crust and the distinctive method of placing tomato sauce over cheese. Many customers also rave about the homemade spumoni, a traditional Italian frozen dessert. While the pizza is the main draw, classic Italian-American dishes are also available. Some debate exists on whether the pizza is overrated, but many acknowledge its iconic status.
"The signature Sicilian square pizza is a must-try, with many recommending it plain or with minimal toppings to appreciate the crust, sauce, and cheese. Their homemade spumoni is also a highly recommended dessert."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the unique Sicilian square pizza and spumoni, viewing the establishment as a beloved, classic NYC institution.
Important Note
There are differing opinions on whether the pizza is overrated, with some finding it not up to par, especially compared to newer pizzerias. Some also note that the DUMBO location may not be as good as the original Bensonhurst establishment. Additionally, a concern about potential racist ownership was raised in one discussion, though this is not a widely held sentiment in the provided data.
"Recommends L&B Spumoni Gardens on 86th in Brooklyn, calling it an institution and suggesting the square slice is the only way to go."
Positive"The user stated that L&B pizza 'sucks' and that they would die on that hill."
Negative"The user has created a close approximation of the L&B clone pie at home."
Positive"The user expressed immediate love for the L&B Sicilian square and has been trying to replicate it at home."
Positive"The user was reminded of L&B's pizza by the post and decided to revisit it that weekend."
Positive"The user agreed that plain Sicilian is the only way to have it and considers it the best Sicilian pizza in the city."
Positive"The user suggested that the Sicilian slice at L&B is best enjoyed without toppings and called it a 'magical piece' of a specific pizza style."
Positive"The user appreciated the consistency of the crust on the Sicilian square pizza but did not like the toppings."
Negative"This commenter also expresses fondness for L&B Spumoni Gardens."
Positive"The commenter recommends L&B Spumoni Gardens in Coney Island for its great dine-in vibe and typically faster service compared to waiting elsewhere."
Positive"If visiting the original L&B Spumoni Gardens, the commenter strongly recommends also trying a spumoni and visiting the nearby Original John Deli for their roast beef sandwich."
Positive"The user confirms they intend to visit the original L&B Spumoni Gardens location."
Neutral"The commenter suggests grouping pizza places by neighborhood for efficiency, mentioning Williamsburg/Greenpoint as a cluster that would be easier to visit than spread-out locations like Nick's and Di Fara's, and L&B Spumoni Gardens."
Neutral"The commenter notes that L&B Spumoni Gardens is far out of the way, suggesting that the Fulton Street location might be more convenient but advising to skip it entirely."
Negative"The commenter was very impressed with L&B Spumoni, finding the pizza light and airy, and enjoyed trying a center, side, and corner slice."
Positive"The commenter agrees with the preference for a center slice for grandma pies."
Positive"The commenter supports the original poster's preference for a center slice of L&B's Sicilian pizza, emphasizing the 'maximum sauce'."
Positive"The commenter identifies with the original poster's preference for a center slice of Sicilian pizza, noting their heritage but appreciating the Sicilian style."
Positive"The commenter agrees with the original poster's preference for a center slice of Sicilian pizza at L&B."
Positive"L&B Spumoni's Sicilian slice is a favorite for the author due to its soft dough, tangy sauce, and cheese pull. They recommend asking for chili flakes and mention the spumoni as an honorable mention."
Positive
