TLDR
Midtown's beloved American grill, famed for its large, quality burgers and standout waffle fries. A top choice for atmosphere, cocktails, and sports viewing.
Details
This classic American grill is a go-to for many in Midtown, particularly for its highly-praised burgers, which are noted for being large and made with quality meat [1]. The waffle fries are also a standout, eliciting strong positive sentiment [2]. While the food generally receives good remarks, some patrons find the dry-aged meat in the burgers to have a polarizing taste [3]. The restaurant also offers a lively atmosphere with great Martinis and bartenders, making it a popular spot for watching sports.
Food Overview
The burgers at this grill are a major highlight, described as large, made with good meat and cheese, and offering good value [1]. The waffle fries also receive significant praise [2]. The dry-aged meat used in the burgers provides a distinctive flavor that some enjoy while others find it unusual [3]. Other mentions include steak and salad options [4].
Caveats
The dry-aged meat in the burgers offers a unique taste that some customers find polarizing.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SMITH & WOLLENSKY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: If You Could Have Just One Dish From One
"The commenter mentioned the steak salad at Wollensky Grill."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Classic Burger Between These
"In response to a recommendation for Wollensky's Grill, this commenter notes its lower price compared to Minetta's or Au Cheval's burgers and expresses interest in trying it."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Classic Burger Between These
"This commenter recommends Wollensky's Grill, mentioning their burger is large, made with good meat and cheese, and a good value at $25 with waffle fries."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendation Needed Restaurant With Big Salad
"This grill is suggested as a potential option."
NeutralFrom post: Best Burger And Fries
"This user simply states they love waffle fries, mentioning Wollensky's in that context."
PositiveFrom post: Burgers Cooked To Order In Midtown
"For those in Midtown seeking a good burger, Wollensky's Grill is recommended alongside PJ Clarke's."
PositiveFrom post: Burgers Cooked To Order In Midtown
"This commenter prefers Wollensky's Grill for burgers when visiting Midtown."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Watch The World Series And Still Have
"Wollensky Grill has TVs at the bar."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Watch The World Series And Still Have
"Wollensky Grill is suggested as a place to watch the World Series."
PositiveFrom post: Friendly Bars For 50 Solo Manhattan
"The user enjoys the vibe and Martinis at Wollensky's Grill, noting great bartenders, though they don't particularly love the food."
PositiveFrom post: Friendly Bars For 50 Solo Manhattan
"Wollensky's Grill is mentioned as a place the original poster frequents."
PositiveFrom post: Burger Steak Restaurant For My 18 Year Old
"The commenter recommends Wollensky Grill."
PositiveFrom post: Who Really Has The Best Burger Shake Shack Jg
"Wollensky's Grill is recommended for its regular burgers and the user also likes its waffle fries."
PositiveFrom post: If Youve Ordered The Same Thing From 10 Places
"The user vouched for Wolensky's Grill burger for years, stating they've tried many top burger places. Another user noted it's made from dry-aged meat, which gives it an unusual taste that some will love and others won't."
NeutralFrom post: If Youve Ordered The Same Thing From 10 Places
"This user noted that Wolensky's Grill burger is rarely mentioned on "top burger lists.""
Neutral