Steakhouse known for fantastic ribeye, prime rib, & sides [1]. Also serves pasta a la presse and has a walk-in policy with manageable waits [2].
The Grill at Smith & Wollensky is a classic American steakhouse that offers a fantastic dining experience, particularly noted for its superb steaks and a wide array of delicious sides. Many patrons highlight the quality of the ribeye and prime rib, with the pasta a la presse also receiving high marks. The restaurant is also recognized for its accommodating walk-in policy and manageable wait times, making it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.
This American steakhouse is celebrated for its exceptional steaks, including the ribeye and prime rib, as well as its flavorful sides like hash browns and creamed spinach. The pasta a la presse is also a standout dish. For those seeking a great burger, Wollensky's Grill is frequently recommended, with one user noting it's made from dry-aged meat, offering a unique taste [5]. However, one commenter mentioned they don't particularly love the food, despite enjoying the overall experience.
"Highly recommended dishes include the ribeye, prime rib, pasta a la presse, hash browns, and creamed spinach. The burger is also a frequent recommendation, noted for its dry-aged meat."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, praising the excellent quality of steaks and sides. While the food is a major draw, some feedback indicates that the vibe and martinis are enjoyable, though the food itself might not be the primary highlight for everyone [10].
Important Note
One user noted that the dry-aged meat in the burger at Wollensky's Grill gives it an unusual taste that may not appeal to everyone. Another commenter mentioned they enjoy the vibe and martinis but don't particularly love the food itself.
"This grill is suggested as a potential option."
Neutral"This user simply states they love waffle fries, mentioning Wollensky's in that context."
Positive"For those in Midtown seeking a good burger, Wollensky's Grill is recommended alongside PJ Clarke's."
Positive"This commenter prefers Wollensky's Grill for burgers when visiting Midtown."
Positive"Wollensky Grill has TVs at the bar."
Positive"Wollensky Grill is suggested as a place to watch the World Series."
Positive"The user enjoys the vibe and Martinis at Wollensky's Grill, noting great bartenders, though they don't particularly love the food."
Positive"Wollensky's Grill is mentioned as a place the original poster frequents."
Positive"The commenter recommends Wollensky Grill."
Positive"Wollensky's Grill is recommended for its regular burgers and the user also likes its waffle fries."
Positive"The user vouched for Wolensky's Grill burger for years, stating they've tried many top burger places. Another user noted it's made from dry-aged meat, which gives it an unusual taste that some will love and others won't."
Neutral"This user noted that Wolensky's Grill burger is rarely mentioned on "top burger lists.""
Neutral"The user followed the recommendation and dined at Wollensky's Grill, finding it to be the closest option."
Positive"Wollensky's Grill is open until 1 am and is suggested for solo dining, with a preference for sitting at the bar."
Positive"The Grill at Smith & Wollensky is highlighted for its walk-in policy and manageable wait times, recommending the filet or bone-in New York strip, hash browns (enough for two), and creamed spinach."
Neutral"The Grill is described as fantastic, with particular praise for the ribeye, prime rib, and sides, as well as the pasta a la presse."
Positive
