Quintessential NY slices with an old-school vibe. A top-rated, no-fuss spot for classic pizza.
This beloved pizza spot on the Upper West Side is celebrated for its quintessential New York slices, offering a no-fuss, old-school dining experience. It's frequently mentioned as a top choice for those craving a traditional slice, with many locals considering it a favorite in the city. While generally lauded, a few patrons have noted the sauce can be a touch too sweet.
This pizza joint is highly recommended for its classic New York slices, particularly the plain cheese slice. While most customers rave about the traditional taste and old-school atmosphere, a few find the sauce to be a bit too sweet.
"The plain cheese slice is highly recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise this establishment for its classic New York-style pizza, often highlighting it as a favorite and a must-try on the Upper West Side. Some minor critiques mention the sauce being too sweet, but the overall sentiment is very positive.
Important Note
One commenter noted that the sauce can be too sweet.
"This user considers Sal & Carmine's their favorite slice place in the city and praises the overall list of recommendations."
Positive"This user states that Sal & Carmine's is their favorite slice in the entire city."
Positive"This establishment is listed as a recommendation."
Positive"Sal and Carmines was listed as a favorite spot for quick bites on the Upper West Side."
Neutral"Patsy's is highly recommended for its quality, and the commenter also suggested Sal and Carmine and Mama's Too as worthwhile alternatives located just south of Harlem."
Positive"Sal & Carmine's is highlighted as the ultimate, no-frills, delicious, quintessential New York slice joint with an old-school atmosphere."
Positive"Sal and Carmine on the UWS is described as 'excellent' by the commenter."
Positive"Sal & Carmines on the Upper West Side has RC Cola available."
Neutral"Sal and Carmines is recommended as a fast New York-style pizza option."
Positive"This user recommends Sal and Carmine's as a local favorite."
Positive"This user recommends Sal and Carmine's for those in the Upper West Side."
Positive"Sal & Carmine's on the Upper West Side is regarded as the classic, quintessential, no-fuss NY slice."
Positive"Sal and Carmine's is a great classic slice."
Positive"Sal and Carmine is 10000% better than Mama's Too!"
Positive"If the line is too long at Mama's Too!, go to Sal and Carmine's for a NY slice as there's never a line."
Positive"Recommended for a traditional NY slice."
Positive"Listed as a recommended spot in the UWS."
Positive"A user listed Sal and Carmines as a potential dinner spot for the original poster and a child."
Positive"Simply states 'Sal and Carmines', likely in agreement with the parent comment."
Positive"Recommends Sal and Carmines as a great option for pizza slices."
Positive
