Classic NY thin-crust pizza, perfect for late-night cravings. Unhyped, reliable slice spot.
For a taste of classic New York pizza, Sacco Pizza stands out as a reliable neighborhood favorite. This unassuming spot is praised for its traditional thin-crust pies, often described as the perfect greasy, salty drunk food. While some reviews mention an inconsistent experience, many long-time patrons and locals rave about its authentic, unhyped slice.
Sacco Pizza is celebrated for its classic New York-style thin-crust pizza. It's frequently recommended for its greasy and salty slices, making it a popular choice for late-night cravings. While the quality can be perceived as inconsistent by some, the general consensus is that it offers a truly authentic and unpretentious pizza experience, especially a plain slice from a fresh pie.
"The classic New York plain slice is highly recommended, especially when ordered fresh from the pie. It's suggested to skip any additional toppings to fully enjoy the traditional flavor profile."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Sacco Pizza for its classic New York slices, with many calling it a dependable and unhyped neighborhood gem. While a few mention inconsistencies, the overall sentiment leans positive, highlighting its appeal for authentic, no-frills pizza.
Important Note
Some customers have noted that the pizza experience at Sacco's can be inconsistent, with occasional variations in quality. Additionally, their sauce might be too light for some preferences.
"Sacco is described as the only good traditional New York pizza place in the area, although its light sauce might not be for everyone."
Positive"Sacco is recommended as the best place for a classic New York slice."
Positive"Sacco's pizza is considered inconsistent, with some slices being amazing and others terrible, but it's still likely the best in the area."
Neutral"Sacco is mentioned as a good pizza option near Columbus Circle."
Positive"This user, who lives near 58th and 8th, states that Sacco's is the correct answer for good traditional New York pizza in that area."
Positive"Sacco is highly recommended as the best classic New York slice in Manhattan, capturing old-school pizzeria vibes."
Positive"This user suggests getting pizza from Sacco and then heading to Rudy's for hot dogs and beer."
Positive"Sacco Pizza, located between 54th and 55th on 9th Ave, is described as a classic New York slice."
Positive"Sacco on 54th and 9th is recommended as a casual and very good pizza place."
Positive"Sacco's Pizza is mentioned as a lunch spot."
Neutral"Sacco's is recommended as NY's best classic slice joint, with a note to skip the toppings. It is located on 9th ave between 54th and 55th street."
Neutral"Sacco Pizza is described as the best of the old school New York slice joints. The commenter suggests getting two slices and a 7-up and skipping toppings."
Positive"This user recommends Sacco's."
Positive"Recommends Sacco's for the best classic New York 'yo lemme get a slice' experience, suggesting skipping toppings. Notes it's not overrun by tourists."
Positive"Sacco's is one of the last best pizza slice joints."
Positive"Recommended for getting a proper NYC pizza slice in the Hell's Kitchen area."
Positive"User suggests adding Sacco Pizza in Hell's Kitchen to the list of top pizza spots."
Positive"States the classic New York slice is at Sacco's. Recommends getting a plain slice from a fresh pie."
Positive"A user agreed that Sacco's is definitely an unhyped spot for a great slice."
Positive"A long-time resident praised Sacco's on 9th Ave as their reliable neighborhood slice spot for 40 years, also loving the sidewalk serving window."
Positive
