Classic NY slice joint, perfect greasy, salty pizza, a dependable neighborhood spot.
This unhyped neighborhood gem is a go-to for classic New York thin-crust pizza, consistently delivering a satisfying slice. Revered by locals as a dependable spot, it's perfect for a casual bite or late-night craving. Many agree that the greasy, salty pizzas are ideal for those seeking authentic, no-frills New York flavor.
The restaurant is celebrated for its classic New York thin-crust pizza, with many recommending a plain slice from a fresh pie. It's frequently cited as an unhyped, dependable spot for a great slice, with some even calling it the best of the old-school slice joints. A few commenters noted that while good, they wished the establishment stayed open later, describing the pizzas as perfect drunk food.
"The classic New York plain slice is highly recommended, especially from a fresh pie. Customers suggest skipping toppings for the most authentic experience."
Customers generally praise the restaurant for its classic New York-style pizza, often describing it as an unhyped, reliable neighborhood spot. Some wish it stayed open later, noting the deliciousness of their greasy, salty pizzas as perfect late-night or drunk food.
Important Note
Some customers expressed disappointment that the restaurant closes at 9 PM, wishing it stayed open later for late-night cravings.
"Sacco's Pizza is mentioned as a lunch spot."
Neutral"Sacco's is recommended as NY's best classic slice joint, with a note to skip the toppings. It is located on 9th ave between 54th and 55th street."
Neutral"Sacco Pizza is described as the best of the old school New York slice joints. The commenter suggests getting two slices and a 7-up and skipping toppings."
Positive"This user recommends Sacco's."
Positive"Recommends Sacco's for the best classic New York 'yo lemme get a slice' experience, suggesting skipping toppings. Notes it's not overrun by tourists."
Positive"Sacco's is one of the last best pizza slice joints."
Positive"Recommended for getting a proper NYC pizza slice in the Hell's Kitchen area."
Positive"User suggests adding Sacco Pizza in Hell's Kitchen to the list of top pizza spots."
Positive"States the classic New York slice is at Sacco's. Recommends getting a plain slice from a fresh pie."
Positive"A user agreed that Sacco's is definitely an unhyped spot for a great slice."
Positive"A long-time resident praised Sacco's on 9th Ave as their reliable neighborhood slice spot for 40 years, also loving the sidewalk serving window."
Positive"A commenter lamented Sacco closing at 9 PM, calling it a 'shame' because their 'greasy salty pizzas are perfect drunk food'."
Positive"A commenter mentioned Sacco Pizza as one of their former dependable local pizza joints."
Positive"+1 for Sacco's."
Positive"Sacco’s at 54th/9th for classic NY thin crust pizza"
Positive"This user lists Sacco's in Midtown as one of their favorite pizza places that isn't often mentioned."
Positive
