TLDR
Classic, unfussy NY slices with genuine old-school pizzeria charm. The go-to spot for an authentic, no-frills neighborhood slice.
Details
Located in Hell's Kitchen, this spot is celebrated for offering what many consider the most underrated, classic New York slice in the city [1]. It captures an authentic, old-school pizzeria vibe that keeps locals coming back [2]. While generally regarded as a premier neighborhood staple, some diners note that the experience can occasionally be inconsistent [3].
Caveats
Quality can occasionally be inconsistent, with some visitors noting that an otherwise terrific slice may occasionally fall short [3], [5]. Additionally, those who prefer a heavier sauce may find the house style to be a bit light [8].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SACCO PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Even Bad Pizza In Nyc Is Sometimes Badas
"Recommended as a local spot for someone looking for a slice near Broadway."
PositiveFrom post: Decent Foodpizza Near Central Park South Upper
"Suggested as a potential quick bite option."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Slice Recommendation By Us Intrepid
"This user listed Sacco's as one of their top picks for pizza near the US Intrepid."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza Slice Recommendation By Us Intrepid
"This user mentioned Sacco's as an option, noting it is located on 9th Ave around 54th St, which is a bit of a distance from the US Intrepid."
NeutralFrom post: My Favorite Spots In Hells Kitchen
"This commenter agrees with the recommendation for an 'old school slice' at Sacco."
PositiveFrom post: My Favorite Spots In Hells Kitchen
"Sacco Pizza is usually terrific, though one commenter had a disappointing last pie, hoping it was an isolated incident."
NeutralFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Sacco is described as the only good traditional New York pizza place in the area, although its light sauce might not be for everyone."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Sacco is recommended as the best place for a classic New York slice."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Sacco's pizza is considered inconsistent, with some slices being amazing and others terrible, but it's still likely the best in the area."
NeutralFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Sacco is mentioned as a good pizza option near Columbus Circle."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"This user, who lives near 58th and 8th, states that Sacco's is the correct answer for good traditional New York pizza in that area."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Sacco is highly recommended as the best classic New York slice in Manhattan, capturing old-school pizzeria vibes."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"This user suggests getting pizza from Sacco and then heading to Rudy's for hot dogs and beer."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Sacco Pizza, located between 54th and 55th on 9th Ave, is described as a classic New York slice."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Sacco on 54th and 9th is recommended as a casual and very good pizza place."
Positive