Next.js logo

PUGSLEY PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (718) 365-0327

Address: 590 EAST 191 STREET 10458

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Unmatched chicken rolls and classic Bronx pizza. A staple near Fordham U with a legendary local following.

Reddit Sentiment for PUGSLEY PIZZA(based on 14 Reddit opinions)

86% Positive14% Neutral

Neighborhoods

Fordham

Details

Located in the heart of the Bronx near Fordham University, this iconic spot is a local favorite for those seeking late-night eats and classic slices [3], [8]. Visitors often find themselves drawn to the unique chicken rolls that have garnered a cult-like following [3], [4], [9]. Whether you are grabbing a quick lunch or a late-night bite, the consistent quality and neighborhood charm make this a standout destination [8], [14].

Food Overview

The menu focuses on classic Italian-style pizza and specialized rolls that have become local legends [8], [14]. While the plain pizza and vegetable slices are highly praised [1], [14], the chicken roll—particularly the vodka chicken roll—is frequently highlighted as an essential item to order [3], [4], [9].

Highlights / Recommended

"The chicken roll and vodka chicken roll are highly recommended must-try items [3], [4], alongside the plain and vegetable slices [1], [14]."

Customer Sentiment

Patrons express overwhelming affection for the menu, frequently citing it as a must-visit spot in the Bronx [4], [7], [11]. It is widely considered a memorable destination, especially for former students and local residents [8], [9].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About PUGSLEY PIZZA

https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1r9lyac/pugsley_chicken_roll_is_unmatched/
Multiple commenters discuss the legendary status of the chicken rolls, noting their popularity among Fordham University students and local visitors.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1s5dy2v/tell_me_where_to_find_the_next_best_chicken_roll/
This thread reinforces the reputation of the chicken rolls, with users confirming their high quality and nostalgic appeal.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1vgm6j8/looking_for_pizza_recs_for_queens_brooklyn_and/
A positive recommendation for the restaurant as a quality pizza destination in the Bronx, specifically calling out the vegetable slice.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1p01jvr/my_favorite_spots_after_a_week_in_nyc/
A general recommendation for the restaurant, specifically suggesting the plain slice with spicy chili oil.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And

"Recommended as a pizza option in the Bronx."

Positive
Aug 5, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Where To Find The Next Best Chicken Roll

"The user simply expressed affirmation, likely in agreement with the positive sentiment about Pugsley's chicken rolls."

Positive
Mar 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Where To Find The Next Best Chicken Roll

"The user provided the location of Pugsley's as E. 191st in the Bronx."

Neutral
Mar 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Where To Find The Next Best Chicken Roll

"The user confirmed that Pugsley's chicken rolls are indeed very good."

Positive
Mar 27, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tell Me Where To Find The Next Best Chicken Roll

"In response to a mention of Pugsley's chicken rolls, the user expressed a strong desire to try them, even though the restaurant is out of the way."

Positive
Mar 27, 2026View Comment →