Last Updated: ~2 months ago
Phone: (212) 799-2378
Address: 303 AMSTERDAM AVENUE 10023
Underrated UWS slice shop with a classic cheese pizza & a decadent bacon chicken ranch slice. Stick to the pizza!
Bryan Kim reviews Freddie & Pepper's, an Upper West Side slice shop praising its classic cheese pizza and decadent bacon chicken ranch slice, advising to stick to the pizza.
This classic Upper West Side slice shop is an old-school gem that truly excels at no-frills pizza. Their regular cheese slice is lauded for its perfect balance of crust and generous mozzarella, while the bacon chicken ranch slice is a must-try for its over-the-top toppings. Though they offer other options like sandwiches, the real star here is the pizza, making it a go-to spot for a satisfying slice.
The restaurant is primarily known for its pizza, with customers recommending the classic cheese slice and the decadent bacon chicken ranch slice. While they also offer sandwiches, including Chilean options, the general consensus is to stick to the pizza.
"The regular cheese slice is praised for its crust and generous mozzarella, while the bacon chicken ranch slice is highlighted for its rich toppings. The pesto slice is also specifically recommended."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the restaurant, often praising its pizza as underrated and a great late-night option. Some recall it fondly from their time living in the neighborhood.
Important Note
The reviewer strongly advises sticking to the pizza and not ordering sandwiches, including the Chilean chacarero.
"This commenter recommended Freddy and Peppers as a "sleeper" spot for a classic New York slice of pizza, noting its proximity to other mentioned locations."
Positive"This user recommends Freddy Peppers in the Upper West Side as an underrated slice shop."
Positive"The user strongly recommends Freddy and Peppers, specifically for their pesto pizza, stating it's so good they'd prefer it over a fancier place."
Positive"A former resident shouted out Freddie & Peppers on Amsterdam & 74th as one of their great local slice places from the past."
Positive"A former UWS resident recalled Freddie and Pepper's as 'absolutely perfect' for a late-night $2 slice after work, despite acknowledging it wasn't the best pizza ever made."
Positive"Freddie peppers upper west side as well is Underated."
Neutral
