Consistently great, old-school pizza from a beloved, unhyped neighborhood spot with charmingly 'grumpy and nice' owners.
Tucked away on Flatbush Avenue, Antonio's Pizza is a Brooklyn gem that locals rave about, often surprising patrons with its consistently excellent, old-school pizza. It's the kind of unpretentious neighborhood spot that food lovers hope remains undiscovered, preserving its quality and affordability. The owners, described as 'grumpy and nice at the same time,' add to the authentic charm of this beloved pizzeria, making it a must-try for anyone seeking a truly great slice.
Antonio's Pizza is highly regarded for its traditional pizza, with customers frequently praising its quality and consistency. It's often mentioned as a standout, unhyped neighborhood spot, with patrons hoping it remains that way. The pizza is described as old school, and the exterior is also noted as being great.
"The primary recommendation is their pizza, consistently praised as old-school and great."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Antonio's Pizza, frequently praising its consistently great pizza and the endearing, albeit sometimes gruff, nature of its owners. There's a sentiment that the restaurant is a hidden gem, with customers hoping it remains unhyped to maintain its current quality and pricing.
Important Note
Customers appreciate the restaurant's unhyped status and hope it remains that way, suggesting potential for longer waits or higher prices if it gains more popularity.
"The user recommends Antonio's on Flatbush for its great exterior and pizza."
Positive"Identifies their favorite old school pizza shop as Antonio's on Flatbush Ave."
Positive"A user expressed appreciation for Antonio's on Flatbush, hoping they stay open without getting overly popular lines or prices."
Positive"A commenter praised Angelo's Pizza on Flatbush as much better than their previous local spot, noting the owners seem to care."
Positive"A user described the owner at Antonio's (7th Ave) as 'grumpy and nice at the same time' and praised the spot as 'consistently great'."
Positive"A commenter gave a shoutout to Antonio's on 7th Ave."
Positive"This user loves Antonio's on Flatbush and is surprised it's not talked about more often."
Positive
