Upscale American steakhouse w/ top-notch steaks & sides; also an unforgettable sundae.
This midtown Manhattan steakhouse is a popular choice for its high-quality steaks and classic American cuisine. It's often recommended for special occasions and business dinners, with many praising the consistent quality and a lively yet conversation-friendly atmosphere. While primarily known for its steaks, adventurous diners might also enjoy unique options like their celebrated sundae.
This American steakhouse is highly regarded for its steaks, with specific mentions of the dry-aged NY strip and tomahawk ribeye receiving praise. Unique items like a strawberry shortcake-inspired sundae and a corn crème brûlée also stand out. While most feedback is positive, one user reported a subpar steak experience, though good customer service was noted.
"Standout dishes include the dry-aged NY strip, tomahawk bone-in ribeye, beef tartare with tableside steak sauce, and unique sides like corn creme brulee. The strawberry shortcake-inspired sundae is also highly recommended."
Customers generally have a positive view, frequently recommending it for its quality steak, consistent service, and enjoyable ambiance, suitable for various occasions.
Important Note
One user reported a negative experience with a steak, and another mentioned that quality might have changed post-COVID.
"Quality Meats was listed as a recommended restaurant."
Positive"The user hosted a birthday dinner for 8 people at Quality Meats and found it to be a good experience. The steakhouse setting and reservation ease were highlighted, fitting the budget."
Positive"This commenter believes that the quality and service at Quality Meat justify the price, including the $95 tomahawk steak."
Positive"This commenter noted the price increase for the tomahawk steak at Quality Meat, which is now $95."
Neutral"This commenter recalled that the tomahawk bone-in ribeye at Quality Meat was excellent, a sentiment confirmed by another user."
Positive"This commenter described Quality Meat as having good quality steak and solid sides, noting it was reasonably priced for Midtown West."
Positive"This commenter likes Quality Meat, stating it is very consistent and has good service."
Positive"This commenter asked for an opinion on Quality Meat."
Neutral"Quality Meats is recommended as a place that is always good, though not trendy."
Positive"Quality Meats is mentioned as a medium to high-priced establishment conducive to conversation when seated away from the bar and entrance."
Positive"Quality Meats is mentioned as one of the steakhouse options for a birthday celebration in NYC."
Neutral"The user recommended the corn creme brulee at Quality Meats, describing it as 'shockingly good' and a strong recommendation from a friend who worked there."
Positive"Quality Meats is recommended as a steakhouse option in Midtown."
Positive"The commenter finds Quality Meats to have been the best and most consistent for them personally, compared to other steakhouses."
Positive"In Midtown/CP South, Quality Meats is recommended for great steaks."
Positive"Quality Meats is listed as one of the commenter's top 5 steakhouse picks in Manhattan."
Positive"The commenter found Quality Meats solid, noting its corporate steakhouse feel but consistent value and above-average steaks at below-average prices. They also recommend the beef tartare with table-side steak sauce."
Positive"The user was very impressed with the dry-aged NY strip at Quality Meats, recommending it as a more modern steakhouse option."
Positive"This user found Quality Meats to be better than Keens based on their experiences over the last two years."
Positive"A meal for two at Quality Meats, including 4 drinks, 3 shared appetizers, and 1 steak with a side, cost approximately $300."
Positive
