TLDR
Legendary Chinatown spot for Cantonese classics, crispy salt-baked soft-shell crab, and legendary roast meats. Ideal for no-frills, authentic late-night or group eats.
Reddit Sentiment for GREAT N.Y. NOODLETOWN(based on 133 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The post showcases Great N.Y. Noodletown's salt-baked soft-shell crabs and the day's selection of Chinese greens. It also includes a historical photograph of the restaurant's exterior, offering a glimpse into its past.
Great N.Y. Noodletown is presented as one of New York City's most legendary Cantonese restaurants, particularly renowned for its roast duck and char siu. The video captures the ducks being roasted in a traditional clay oven, then chopped and served, often with rice. Other highlighted dishes include soft-shell crab, prepared fresh during its season, wok-fried noodles, and handmade wonton soup. The establishment maintains a traditional, bustling kitchen environment, with chefs expertly preparing dishes. The restaurant appears to be a long-standing favorite, cherished by patrons who have frequented it for years.
Great NY Noodletown is another runner-up for the best sit-down meal in Chinatown, known for its extensive menu of noodles and roast meats.
Details
A legendary Chinatown institution, this bustling spot is widely celebrated for its authentic Cantonese cuisine and exceptional value [1]. Guests flock here for iconic offerings like crispy, salt-baked soft-shell crab and flavorful roast meats [2]. While the menu is extensive and crowd-pleasing, it remains an unpretentious, old-school staple perfect for groups looking for a classic New York dining experience [3].
Food Overview
This restaurant specializes in Cantonese comfort food, renowned for its roast duck, char siu, and wonton noodle soup [1]. Seasonal salt-baked soft-shell crab is a highly sought-after delicacy, praised for its perfect texture when in season [2]. Customers generally love the hearty portions, though some have noted inconsistencies in dish preparation, such as lean BBQ pork or non-crispy calamari [3].
The salt-baked soft-shell crab and roast meats like duck and char siu are consistent fan favorites [1]. Other highly recommended items include wonton noodle soup, crispy pan-fried noodle cakes, and flavorful congee [2].
Overall sentiment is highly positive, with patrons frequently calling it an 'OG' Chinatown favorite for reliable, elite eats [1]. However, some recent feedback notes frustration regarding unclear automatic gratuity policies and a shift away from late-night operating hours [2].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01soft shell crab10 mentions
- 02roast duck6 mentions
- 03salt baked soft-shell crab6 mentions
- 04roast pork4 mentions
- 05congee3 mentions
- 06shrimp wonton noodle soup2 mentions
Caveats
The restaurant is cash-only, and guests should be aware that gratuity is often included in the bill [1]. Additionally, the establishment no longer operates with its historic late-night hours, now typically closing earlier [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GREAT N.Y. NOODLETOWN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Visiting New York In November How Is My Food
"Highly recommended for delicious food in Chinatown."
PositiveFrom post: Visiting For A 3 Night Stay Would You Help With
"Suggested as a great spot to try in Chinatown for a breakfast alternative."
PositiveFrom post: Who Knows The Best Beef Chow Fun Place That Has A
"A brief, neutral mention of the restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: Any Spot Recommendations In Manhattan For A Group
"Recommended as a spot in Chinatown suitable for a group."
PositiveFrom post: The Absolute Best Weekday Lunch Options In Nyc
"Mentioned as a destination lunch option."
Positive