TLDR
An authentic Manhattan chippy serving classic British fried fish and chips; a polarizing spot known for its traditional malt vinegar and crispy-batter aspirations.
Reddit Sentiment for A SALT & BATTERY(based on 21 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
This was the first stop on the fish and chips tour. The reviewer tried a regular cod and chips. The chips were described as fluffy and potato-y but not crispy enough, earning a neutral sentiment. The cod was considered a "good piece," with the overall dish receiving a 6.5 out of 10. The establishment is a British fish and chip shop.
Details
A Salt & Battery serves as a dedicated British chippy in Manhattan, offering traditional staples like fried fish, chips, and mushy peas [1][16]. While many diners laud it as a go-to for authentic-style fish and chips in the city [1][16], others express frustration with the seasoning levels, pricing, and oil quality [4][8]. Opinions remain deeply divided, with some customers finding it a nostalgic staple and others considering the offerings mediocre [9][18].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic British fare, with many diners enjoying the haddock, cod bites, and fried bangers [1]. While the fish and chips receive frequent praise, some reviewers complain that the fish lacks crispiness, the chips can be under-seasoned, and the cooking oil quality is inconsistent [4][8][11].
Caveats
Some visitors report that the restaurant can be overpriced and may leave patrons smelling strongly of grease [8][12]. Additionally, several diners have noted that the food can be under-seasoned, though some point out this aligns with traditional British practices where salt and vinegar are applied by the diner [4][5][7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About A SALT & BATTERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Does Anyone Know Of Any Good Irish Pubs With
"Salt and Battery was recommended as a British establishment located in Greenwich that might serve the desired dish."
PositiveFrom post: Uk Chip Shop Style Fries
"This commenter stated that A Salt and Battery, located in Manhattan, serves mediocre food."
NegativeFrom post: Softpuree Food Spots In Manhattanqueens
"The commenter suggests A Salt and Battery for mushy peas, which are soft and suitable for someone with a wired jaw."
PositiveFrom post: Lenten Fish Fry
"This commenter recommended A Salt and Battery for its excellent fish and chips."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Restaurant Archives 2002 2008
"A Salt & Battery was the commenter's first experience with authentic fish and chips served with malt vinegar, describing the smell as unusual but the taste as very good."
PositiveFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"Generally, UK fish and chip shops ask about salt and vinegar preference when wrapping, implying A Salt and Battery may be under-seasoning or skipping this step."
NeutralFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"This commenter, not from Britain but familiar with fish and chips, stated that A Salt and Battery still has room for improvement."
NegativeFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"A commenter criticized A Salt and Battery for not achieving crispy fish, using old cooking oil, being overpriced, and having a subpar curry sauce."
NegativeFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"This commenter bluntly stated that A Salt and Battery is not very good and that patrons will leave smelling strongly of grease."
NegativeFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"Comparing A Salt and Battery to the now-closed Atlantic Chip Shop and even an Irish pub, this commenter found both alternatives to be superior."
NegativeFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"This commenter simply stated that A Salt and Battery is not good."
NegativeFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"A commenter with UK experience noted that fish and chips batter is often unseasoned, with flavor coming from frying oil and added salt/vinegar, which can initially seem bland."
NeutralFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"The salt level in UK chip shops can vary due to regional cultural influences, with experiences differing based on whether shops were run by Chinese or Greek Cypriot communities."
NeutralFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"Responding to a comment about over-seasoning, this user agreed that it's likely true regarding salt."
NeutralFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"A commenter explained that British fish and chips are typically served unsalted, with salt available for customers to add themselves."
NeutralFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"A commenter suggested that in America, everything is typically over-seasoned."
NeutralFrom post: A Question For The Nyc Brits About A Salt And
"The original poster feels that the fish, chips, and mushy peas at A Salt and Battery are under-seasoned, questioning if salt is even used."
NeutralFrom post: Irish Chipper In Nyc
"A Salt and Battery is considered the closest iteration of 'chippy' chips found in NYC, though the commenter notes it's not entirely authentic."
NeutralFrom post: Irish Chipper In Nyc
"The commenter expresses fondness for A Salt and Battery, particularly their fish and chips."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Fish
"This user's go-to for fried fish is Salt & Battery in the West Village, highlighting their haddock, cod bites, fried bangers, and tartar sauce."
Positive