Next.js logo

BARMASA / MASA

Last Updated: 22 days ago

Phone: (212) 823-9828

Address: 10 COLUMBUS CIRCLE 10019

TLDR

An unforgettable omakase experience w/ luxe ingredients like truffles & caviar. A truly captivating culinary performance.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 42 Reddit comments)

26% Positive52% Neutral21% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo
Next.js logo

Tags

japanese 33fine dining 2edomae sushi 2sushi 30omakase 13fine dining 3View All

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Instagram Posts References

Summary

Details

BARMASA / MASA offers an exceptional and meticulously crafted omakase experience, renowned for its serene atmosphere and the distinctive style of Chef Masa Takayama. The menu showcases luxurious ingredients like truffles, caviar, and foie gras, with standout dishes such as foie gras nigiri and tender abalone, promising a captivating and unforgettable culinary journey.

Food Overview

This Japanese restaurant is celebrated for its omakase sushi experience, featuring high-end ingredients like truffles, caviar, and foie gras. Standout dishes include foie gras nigiri and abalone. While the quality is often praised, the extremely high price point is a recurring theme in customer feedback.

Highlights / Recommended

"Dishes frequently highlighted include the foie gras nigiri and exceptionally tender abalone. The overall omakase experience, encompassing high-end sushi and otsumami with unique Western influences, is also highly recommended."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally regard the restaurant as exceptionally high-end, with a focus on omakase sushi and a price point to match. While the food and service are often described as exceptional, the cost is a significant consideration for many.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This thread extensively discusses Masa's perceived value relative to its high cost, with many commenters feeling the price no longer aligns with the quality or that the chef's absence impacts the experience. Some users suggest alternative high-end sushi options.
In this discussion about affordable omakase, Masa is acknowledged as a top-tier option but is noted as being prohibitively expensive for most, highlighting its status as a very high-end dining destination.
A user highlights Masa's 'unreasonably attentive' service, noting that servers refill water so quickly that patrons can barely take a sip before it's refilled, as an example of exceptional hospitality.
Masa is recommended for its unique 'blasphemous' sushi and otsumami, which incorporates Western touches not commonly found even in Tokyo. It's described as the originator of its style and unique to New York.
This thread discusses high-end dining options, with Masa mentioned as a potential tasting menu experience likely costing $700-$900 per person, underscoring its extreme price point.
In a conversation about restaurant websites, a commenter specifically praises MASA's website as being well-designed.
Discussions touch on Masa's tipping policy, with one comment noting it traditionally doesn't accept tips due to Japanese custom and a past lawsuit, while another mentions an optional tip line now appearing on checks.

Recent Mentions

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"This commenter praised another user's detailed review of Masa, agreeing that Shion offered a superior overall experience and appreciating the lack of a simple complaint about pricing."

Positive
Nov 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"This commenter felt Masa should lose two of its three stars, considering the chefs there as primarily in training and expressing disappointment."

Negative
Nov 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"This user pointed out that a major issue with Masa is that the chef himself is not always present, and there's no price adjustment or heads-up for diners when this occurs."

Negative
Nov 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"This user questioned whether Masa should have been present more often, implying it might have impacted their rating."

Neutral
Nov 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"Following up on a previous comment, this user shared surprise about Per Se retaining its stars, noting a past negative experience but also hearing that the restaurant has improved significantly since a critical review."

Neutral
Nov 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"This commenter argued that Masa is no longer competitive in the modern sushi scene, citing issues like Masa not always being present, the high price point, and the chef's training being from an older, less refined era. They suggested that in Tokyo, Masa would receive a lower rating and be significantly cheaper."

Negative
Nov 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"A short, strongly negative reaction to Masa losing a star."

Negative
Nov 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"Reflecting on Masa's opening, this user notes that while friends initially raved about it, increased competition and rising prices make it hard to justify the top rating, especially compared to other excellent sushi options. They also draw parallels to other fine dining restaurants like Per Se and Alinea experiencing similar perceived declines in value or quality over time."

Negative
Nov 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"This user expressed surprise that Per Se has maintained its three stars, having not yet dined at Masa."

Neutral
Nov 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"A brief, negative sentiment towards the restaurant."

Negative
Nov 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"This user believes Masa's loss of a star was inevitable due to the significant gap between its price and perceived quality, stating the sushi was very good but not extraordinary enough for the cost."

Negative
Nov 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"This commenter suggested that Masa's price had become insane, implying that even Michelin reviewers might be concerned."

Negative
Nov 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Masa Have Lost Their Third Michelin Star

"This user found the appetizers incredible and the nigiri comparable to other high-end sushi restaurants, but questioned Masa's three-star rating and exorbitant pricing."

Neutral
Nov 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Up To 500head Where Would You Go

"The commenter humorously recalls experiencing Masa for free in the past due to a past relationship with a chef."

Neutral
Sep 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Up To 500head Where Would You Go

"The commenter states the tasting menu at Masa is likely $700-$900 per person, making it out of the original poster's budget."

Negative
Sep 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Up To 500head Where Would You Go

"Masa is mentioned as a place with a tasting menu, though the commenter is unsure of current price points."

Neutral
Sep 18, 2025View Comment →

From post: Its Emp Right

"The user questioned why Masa having three stars would be a good thing in the context of the original post."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Its Emp Right

"The user suggested Masa as a possibility if the restaurant in question has three stars."

Neutral
Aug 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Moving Back Whats Our First Meal

"The commenter suggests considering Masa for a celebratory meal."

Neutral
Jul 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Urgent Best Happy Hour Spot In Midtown Money Is

"Bar Masa is suggested as a possible option for the requested outing."

Positive
Jul 18, 2025View Comment →