Last Updated: 16 days ago
Phone: (212) 420-0012
Address: 191 CHRYSTIE STREET 10002
A rustic, hidden gem nestled in an alley, offering American cuisine with highly praised dishes, though some find it overpriced.
Tucked away at the end of a graffiti-adorned alley, Freemans is a rustic American restaurant that evokes a bygone era of New York. It's frequently described as a hidden gem, offering a cozy and intimate dining experience. While many rave about the quality of the food, with specific mentions of exceptionally good duck and lamb dishes, and standout sides like roasted carrots and broccolini, there are dissenting voices. Some critics find the establishment to be an overpriced tourist trap, leading to a mixed reputation. For those seeking a private dining experience, Freemans offers rooms suitable for groups, making it a potential option for celebrations.
Freemans offers rustic American cuisine, with some patrons specifically recommending the duck and lamb dishes, as well as sides like roasted carrots and broccolini, describing them as 'truly amazing.' However, there are also negative reviews calling the restaurant expensive and terrible, with one user noting that the lasagna is no longer on the menu.
"Roasted carrots and broccolini are specifically praised as 'truly amazing' side dishes. The duck and lamb dishes are also mentioned as being exceptionally good."
Customer opinions on Freemans are divided. Some praise it as a hidden gem with great food, particularly recommending dishes like the duck and lamb, and sides such as roasted carrots and broccolini. Others, however, consider it a tourist trap and have had negative experiences, citing it as expensive and
Important Note
Some diners consider Freemans an expensive tourist trap, and one user noted that the lasagna is no longer on the menu.
"Freemans in the LES is a rustic, hidden gem with good value and generous portions. It offers private dining options like the Wine Room or Blue Room and was recommended for its suitability for groups."
Positive"Freemans is recommended as a brunch spot in the Lower East Side (LES)."
Neutral"Freeman's was recommended as a brunch spot option, fitting the original post's desire for good food and a nice scene."
Positive"The user strongly advises against recommending Freemans, suggesting the original poster try the place before making a decision."
Negative"The user warns that Freemans is a tourist trap and advises dining there solo before committing to it for a large event."
Negative"The original poster, after considering Freemans for their event, felt it 'would have been great'. Despite this positive view, it was not chosen due to a lack of outdoor space and unavailability for their date."
Positive"The commenter shared their positive experience hosting an event in the wine room at Freemans. They noted that while it lacks a view, it met other criteria relevant to the original poster's search for a birthday venue."
Positive"tuesmoon disagrees with the negative assessment of Freemans, stating they had 2 great meals there recently."
Positive"Henrygrins expresses pity upon hearing Freemans is now terrible, noting they used to be great in the 00s."
Neutral"Maximum_Biscotti recommends avoiding Freemans, calling it actually terrible and expensive."
Negative"Had a positive experience at Freeman's for a 50th birthday celebration and mentions a reasonable food/beverage minimum for private rooms."
Positive"Recommends Freeman's for a private dining experience, especially noting their 12-person private dining room."
Positive"Believes Freemans is the restaurant they were looking for. Mentions that the lasagna is no longer on the menu."
Positive"Suggests Freemans as a possibility for the first restaurant."
Neutral"The restaurant owner finds the process with CB2 unnecessarily difficult and doesn't understand the purpose of the extensive review."
Negative
