Next.js logo

ANGELO'S PIZZA

Last Updated: ~2 months ago

Phone: (212) 245-8811

Address: 1697 BROADWAY 10019

TLDR

NYC pizza perfection, known for not being burnt & generous cheesesteak fillings.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 6 Reddit comments)

67% Positive33% Neutral

Tags

italian 2pizza 2View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Details

For a classic New York pizza experience, Angelo's Pizza is a must-visit, consistently earning praise for its quality pies. Many locals and visitors alike champion it as a top-tier option, particularly for those seeking authentic, well-executed pizza in the bustling Midtown area. Its reputation extends beyond just pizza, with mentions in comparative discussions about cheesesteaks, where Angelo's is often cited as a benchmark for generous fillings, setting a high standard that other establishments are measured against. If you're looking for a reliable and delicious pizza joint that clearly knows its craft, Angelo's is a standout choice.

Food Overview

Angelo's Pizza is highly regarded for its quality pizza, with customers specifically noting that it is not burnt, setting it as a standard for excellent NYC pizza. It's also mentioned in discussions about cheesesteaks, with comparisons suggesting Angelo's sets a high bar in terms of the amount of filling provided, indicating a satisfying and generous portion.

Highlights / Recommended

"Angelo's Pizza is frequently recommended for its excellent pizza. It's also noted for its cheesesteak, which is praised for having a generous amount of filling."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards Angelo's Pizza, with multiple mentions highlighting it as a benchmark for quality, especially when compared to other establishments. It's frequently recommended as a top choice for pizza in the Midtown area, with specific praise for not being burnt and setting a high standard for filling in dishes like cheesesteaks.

Reddit References

Recent Mentions

From post: Nyc Trip Plan Lunch Help

"The commenter recommends Angelo's for pizza as a good option near Midtown."

Positive
Jun 25, 2025View Comment →

From post: How Is Ceres Pizza

"Angelos is listed as a good example of NYC pizza that is not burnt."

Positive
May 15, 2025View Comment →

From post: Danny And Coops Cheesesteak

"In a reply discussing Danny & Coop's, the author compares it to Angelo's, implying Angelo's sets a standard, particularly regarding the amount of filling."

Positive
Apr 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Danny And Coops Cheesesteak

"The author felt Danny and Coop's was a letdown compared to Angelo's, rating it only 65% as good. This implies a strong positive view of Angelo's."

Positive
Apr 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Danny And Coops Cheesesteak

"The author hasn't had Angelo's cheesesteak but is interested in trying it."

Neutral
Apr 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Group Dinner Recommendation In Midtown

"The commenter suggests Angelo's Pizza as a potential option for the group dinner request."

Neutral
Apr 18, 2025View Comment →