TLDR
Old-school Midtown classic known for 31-day dry-aged steaks. A reliable go-to for business dinners and special occasions with generous portion sizes.
Instagram Posts References
Benjamin Steakhouse is highlighted as an old-school New York restaurant. The owner emphasizes that all their restaurants, including Benjamin Steakhouse, carry the 'Benjamin Restaurant Group touch'. It is mentioned as one of the locations visited by the owner during their day.
Details
This Midtown destination is celebrated for its meticulous 31-day dry-aging process, which defines the quality of its steak offerings [7]. Known as a reliable choice for business client dinners and special events, the restaurant consistently delivers an upscale, old-school atmosphere [8], [9], [17]. While many diners appreciate the generous portion sizes, some perceive the overall experience as a standard, mid-tier option compared to legendary institutions [6], [10], [13].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic American steakhouse fare, anchored by steaks that undergo a 31-day dry-aging process [7]. Diners often recommend sharing large-format items like the porterhouse, though some advise skipping the filet mignon [2], [5]. Classic sides such as creamed spinach, onion rings, and mashed potatoes are popular accompaniments, and the restaurant is noted for its generous serving sizes [2], [13].
The classic porterhouse for two and the NY Sirloin are consistently highlighted as standout orders [2].
Feedback is generally positive, with guests frequently praising the restaurant as a solid choice for professional and celebratory dining [8], [17]. While some patrons find the quality perfectly satisfying, others view it as a functional but average steakhouse experience [6], [10].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01steak2 mentions
Caveats
Some diners feel the quality does not always surpass more iconic New York steakhouses, leading some to categorize it as an average or 'meh' option [6], [9].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BENJAMIN STEAK HOUSE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: After Looking At Every Menu On Restaurant Week I
"The user suggests Benjamin's as a restaurant with a good menu for Restaurant Week."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Restaurant For A Post Wedding
"Mentioned as a potential steakhouse option for a post-wedding dinner."
NeutralFrom post: Where Did The Ny Strips Go Where Are They Best
"The restaurant is simply mentioned as a suggestion."
NeutralFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Listed as one of various steakhouses."
NeutralFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user suggested that most steakhouses, like Benjamin Steakhouse, offer large portions."
Positive