Classic American steakhouse w/ elegant ambiance. Perfect for celebrations & a superb steak.
This esteemed steakhouse offers a sophisticated dining experience, perfect for special occasions or a classic night out. Reviewers consistently praise the impeccable quality of their steaks and the elegant, yet comfortable, ambiance. It's a place where traditional steakhouse fare meets modern refinement, ensuring a memorable meal.
This American steakhouse is celebrated for its exceptional steaks, with many calling it the 'best classic American steakhouse.' While specific dishes are not frequently mentioned, the focus remains on perfectly prepared steak cuts. The general sentiment leans heavily towards positive recommendations.
"The porterhouse for two and the NY Sirloin (strip steak) are recommended. Sides like onion rings and creamed spinach or mashed potatoes are also suggested. The tomahawk steak is mentioned as being dry-aged."
Customers highly praise this steakhouse, frequently calling it 'incredible' and the 'best classic American steakhouse.' The food, particularly the steaks, receives consistent acclaim, contributing to a very positive overall sentiment.
Important Note
One commenter felt that while Benjamin's porterhouse is similar to Peter Luger's, the quality isn't as high. Another mentioned it can be a splurge.
"The commenter considers Wolfgang's and Benjamin's to be excellent choices, recommending the classic 'porterhouse for two' or the 'NY Sirloin' (strip), with sides of onion rings and creamed spinach or mashed potatoes. They advise against ordering filet mignon at a New York steakhouse and suggest skipping Peter Luger."
Positive"The commenter suggested steakhouses like Benjamin as a potential option for hosting a private breakfast event for a large group."
Neutral"Benjamin's has a similar style of porterhouse to Peter Luger's, but the commenter feels the quality is not as good."
Negative"Recommends Benjamin as a very good steakhouse option in Midtown, noting that it can be a splurge."
Positive"Benjamin Steakhouse is suggested as a place that offers a weekday prix-fixe lunch special, making it a potential option for a solo diner."
Neutral"The commenter recommends trying Benjamin's Steakhouse."
Neutral"Benjamin's is listed as a great but pricey steakhouse option."
Positive"Benjamin Steakhouse is suggested as a very good option for steak."
Positive"Benjamin Steakhouse is noted as being pretty good."
Neutral"Benjamin's is recommended as a great Midtown option, offering more choices and easier table availability than Keen's."
Positive"Benjamin's is highlighted as an underrated American steakhouse option, conveniently located near Bryant Park, where tables are generally available."
Positive"The user strongly recommends Benjamin for restaurant week, noting it offers a "crazy good deal" and that their regular steak is only $60."
Positive"Benjamin is this user's favorite steakhouse, described as old-school and better than Luger-esque establishments, leading them to wish they always chose Benjamin over new steakhouses."
Positive"Benjamin Steakhouse was recommended by a user as an overpriced breakfast option, alongside Monterey."
Positive"This user's personal favorite steakhouse is Benjamin Steakhouse, implying a positive experience there."
Positive"This user suggests Benjamin's as another suitable option for the original poster's steak preference."
Positive"Benjamin Steakhouse is listed as one of the commenter's preferred spots in the Grand Central area."
Positive"Benjamin Steakhouse is listed as a general recommendation for the area."
Neutral"Benjamin Steakhouse is described as one of the best steakhouses located just a block away from Grand Central."
Positive"This commenter recommended Benjamin Steakhouse."
Neutral
