TLDR
Vibrant West Village Italian spot known for handmade pasta and wood-fired Neapolitan pizza, offering a charming, European-inspired aesthetic.
Instagram Posts References
Olio e Più is a highly recommended Italian restaurant in NYC, recognized for its authentic, handmade pasta and wood-fired Neapolitan pizza. The restaurant boasts a romantic atmosphere with European influences, making it a notable dining destination.
Olio e Più is featured as a prime destination for pasta in NYC, recognized as a top spot for its Italian offerings that are 'worth the hype'.
Details
A popular Italian spot in the West Village known for its vibrant, romantic atmosphere and European-inspired interior [2]. While some visitors praise its handmade pasta and Neapolitan pizza as highlights [2], it has faced criticism for inconsistent quality and being perceived by some as a tourist-heavy destination [4], [5]. Recent feedback is polarized, with diners often debating whether the experience lives up to its online popularity versus being an overrated choice for authentic cuisine [3], [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on Italian staples like handmade pasta and wood-fired Neapolitan pizza [2]. Customer opinions are divided; some praise the truffle pasta [1], while others have had poor experiences with the carbonara, specifically citing issues with excessive oil or poor consistency [3]. Dishes like the bolognese have also been described as undercooked [4].
Highlights / Recommended
"The handmade pasta and wood-fired Neapolitan pizza are frequently highlighted as the restaurant's core offerings [2], with specific praise occasionally directed at the truffle pasta [1]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •carbonara(6)
Customer Sentiment
Customer reception is highly polarized, ranging from recommendations for group dining and atmosphere to strong labels of the establishment as a tourist trap [4], [5]. While some appreciate the value and space for gatherings, others frequently critique the food quality and service as mediocre or inconsistent [3], [4].
Caveats
Potential diners should be aware that the restaurant is often described as noisy, especially when outdoor seating is in use [3]. Some patrons have also reported instances of rude service [6], and critics have alleged that the restaurant's online reputation may be artificially inflated through rating manipulation [3], [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OLIO E PIU
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Wheres The Good Food In Midtown Thats Not 50 And
"The food is loved, but the user notes it can get pricey."
NeutralFrom post: Which Nyc Food Place Has The Rudest Staff But
"Olio e piú is mentioned briefly in the context of restaurants with potentially rude staff."
NeutralFrom post: How Does My Memorial Day Weekend Plan Sound For
"Olio e Più is listed as a good Italian restaurant option near Bleecker Street and Washington Square."
PositiveFrom post: Quiet Long Lunch Near West 4th Station
"Olio e Più was suggested as a restaurant choice."
NeutralFrom post: Birthday Dinner Recs
"This user suggested considering chain restaurants like Oliu e Più for group dinners, noting they offer good food, space, and a decent price point."
PositiveFrom post: Birthday Dinner In West Villagesoho
"The original poster was considering Olio e Più for a birthday dinner due to its nice interior, good pricing, and proximity to the Comedy Cellar. However, they noted that it has been referred to as the 'Olive Garden of the West Village,' which was not the desired vibe."
NegativeFrom post: West Village Dinner
"This user explicitly advised against choosing Olio e Piu."
NegativeFrom post: Where To Eat On Thanksgiving Day Non Tg Food
"Olio e Più will offer both Thanksgiving specials and its regular menu on Thanksgiving Day."
PositiveFrom post: Buddakan Vs Olio E Piu
"The commenter believes both Olio e Piu and Buddakan are subpar and suggests exploring other options in NYC."
NegativeFrom post: Buddakan Vs Olio E Piu
"The commenter implies that Olio e Piu is not an ideal choice."
NegativeFrom post: Buddakan Vs Olio E Piu
"The commenter labels Olio e Piu as a 'tourist trap'."
NegativeFrom post: Buddakan Vs Olio E Piu
"The commenter states they would not recommend Olio e Piu, calling it 'dogshit'."
NegativeFrom post: Buddakan Vs Olio E Piu
"This commenter describes Olio e Piu as mediocre, referencing an article about them gaming TripAdvisor algorithms. They also mention their bolognese was undercooked during a previous visit."
NegativeFrom post: Buddakan Vs Olio E Piu
"The commenter explicitly states they would choose Buddakan over Olio e Piu, identifying Olio as a 'tourist trap'."
NegativeFrom post: Olio E Piu Am I Missing Something
"This commenter stated the restaurant is 'overpriced and not v good'."
NegativeFrom post: Olio E Piu Am I Missing Something
"This commenter explained that putting carbonara in a container will overcook the eggs and that it needs to be eaten within minutes of preparation to be good."
NeutralFrom post: Olio E Piu Am I Missing Something
"This commenter stated they 'Never liked that place, so overhyped'."
NegativeFrom post: Olio E Piu Am I Missing Something
"This commenter humorously suggested the dish resembled 'lomein tossed in oil and garlic to cut cost'."
NegativeFrom post: Olio E Piu Am I Missing Something
"This commenter stated they 'got sick from this place around a year ago'."
Negative