Next.js logo

PENNY FARTHING RESTAURANT

Last Updated: 1 day ago

Phone: (212) 387-7300

Address: 103 3 AVENUE 10003

TLDR

Renowned for its unparalleled seafood, especially oysters. Offers unique bar seating for an approachable dining experience.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 33 Reddit comments)

73% Positive21% Neutral6% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

american 6seafood 4modern american 3seafood 9View All

Neighborhoods

East Village

Details

This establishment is a celebrated spot for seafood aficionados, with many diners raving about their incredibly fresh oyster selection and other oceanic delights. The unique all-bar seating makes it an approachable option, even for solo diners seeking a top-quality meal. While generally lauded, a few patrons have noted concerns about value for money due to portion sizes.

Food Overview

The restaurant is highly recommended for its exceptional seafood, with many customers specifically calling out the oysters as the best they've ever had. Razor clams are also a standout dish. While most feedback is positive, one commenter noted that the portion sizes were small relative to the price, and another felt it wasn't ideal for a full sit-down meal.

Highlights / Recommended

"The razor clams are highly recommended, and the oysters are frequently cited as being the best customers have ever had. The general consensus is that most seafood dishes are excellent."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • oysters(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a very positive view of the restaurant, praising its seafood and overall dining experience. Some find it to be a top-tier choice for seafood lovers and even compare it favorably to acclaimed establishments.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

Multiple users highly recommend this restaurant, with one user specifically mentioning it for a birthday celebration and highlighting the best oysters and fantastic service. Another user also preferred it over another well-known restaurant.
Customers rave about the razor clams, calling them a must-try, and generally praise all other offerings. The oysters are also specifically mentioned as being outstanding.
The restaurant is recommended due to its exclusive bar seating, which is noted as being very accommodating for solo diners looking for a good meal.
This spot is praised for its excellent lighting, interactive bar seating, and selection of seafood, making it a great choice, especially for summer dining.
A user specifically mentioned this restaurant for an incredible seafood meal, highlighting their positive experience with the cuisine.

Recent Mentions

From post: Seeking Birthday Restaurant Recommendations

"The user recommended Penny as a potential dining option."

Positive
Aug 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Date Night Manhattan Dinner Recommendations

"This user recommends Penny for its delicious food, great service, and accommodating nature towards gluten-free diets. They also note it has a great wine list."

Positive
Aug 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Seafood Restaurant With A Nice Ambience

"This commenter has a negative view of Penny, criticizing the service, materials used for plating, and the overall atmosphere, comparing it unfavorably to more established restaurants."

Negative
Jul 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Seafood Restaurant With A Nice Ambience

"Penny is liked for its top-notch lighting, interactive bar seating, and seafood selection, making it ideal for summer."

Positive
Jul 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Sunday Night Dinner Solo Diner Bar Seating

"Penny is suggested because it exclusively offers bar seating, making it easy for solo diners to get a spot."

Positive
Jul 1, 2025View Comment →

From post: Good Seafood Options Around Villages

"Penny is mentioned as a restaurant."

Neutral
Jun 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Asked For Three Restaurants To Check Out

"The user suggests Penny as a recommendation."

Positive
Jun 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: What Fell Off The Ny Times List

"This user loves Penny and compares it to Le Bernardin, stating both offer different yet equally wonderful dining experiences."

Positive
Jun 5, 2025View Comment →

From post: What Fell Off The Ny Times List

"This user noted that Penny, along with Bridges and Borgo, are all new restaurants."

Neutral
Jun 4, 2025View Comment →

From post: Solo Dining This Friday Where Should I Try To

"Penny is suggested for those who enjoy seafood, but unfortunately, it is closed for the current week."

Neutral
May 21, 2025View Comment →

From post: Casual Fine Dining In Manhattan

"This user recommends Penny as a suitable option for the casual fine dining request."

Positive
May 15, 2025View Comment →

From post: The 25 Best Restaurants In Nyc The Infatuation

"The author simply states "Penny lol", expressing amusement, skepticism, or disdain towards Penny, possibly regarding its inclusion on a list or its general reputation."

Negative
May 11, 2025View Comment →

From post: The 25 Best Restaurants In Nyc The Infatuation

"The author found Penny to be good, but was taken aback by the price relative to the portion sizes. They felt the food was not unique enough to justify the high cost."

Neutral
May 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: The 25 Best Restaurants In Nyc The Infatuation

"The author mentions that they really enjoyed Penny, a restaurant that some other people reportedly find over-hyped. Their positive experience stands in contrast to some other opinions."

Positive
May 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Need Some Help With Restaurant Recommendations

"Penny is recommended by the commenter for seafood, suggested as an option for the user's boyfriend's birthday dinner."

Positive
May 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: What Are Your Favorite Seafood Dishes In Nyc

"Describes the oysters at Penny (though only one variety is served) as the best oysters of their life."

Positive
May 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: What Are Your Favorite Seafood Dishes In Nyc

"Recommends razor clams at Penny, and praises everything else on their menu."

Positive
May 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: Coming To Nyc Mid May

"The commenter states that Penny is a must-visit restaurant."

Positive
May 6, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Restaurants That Are Also Amazing Drinking

"ChefSuffolk suggests Penny."

Neutral
Apr 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Help Seafood Focused Nyc Spots For A Picky Mum

"Considers Penny good but not suitable for a full sit-down dinner."

Neutral
Apr 24, 2025View Comment →