Iconic square slices, especially the spicy pepperoni. A legendary NYC pizza spot.
This iconic New York pizzeria is a must-visit for its famous spicy pepperoni square slices, a thick-cut Sicilian pie topped with crispy, cupped pepperoni that many deem perfection. While the vodka slice also receives praise for its creamy mozzarella, opinions are mixed, with some finding the pizza overrated and overpriced. Despite controversies, it remains a popular spot for those seeking a classic, flavorful pizza experience.
The restaurant is renowned for its Sicilian-style square slices, particularly the spicy pepperoni variation, which features crispy, cupped pepperoni. Other popular items include the vodka slice. While many rave about the quality, some find the pizza to be mediocre or overpriced, with one commenter noting the spicy pepperoni slice was served cold and too expensive.
"The spicy pepperoni square slice is consistently highlighted as a must-try, often praised for its crispy, cupped pepperoni and unique flavor profile. The vodka slice is also a popular choice."
Customer opinions are sharply divided. While many praise the spicy pepperoni square slice and consider it a must-try, others find the restaurant to be overrated, overpriced, and have noted a decline in quality. Some also cite allegations of racism against the owners as a reason to avoid the establishment.
Important Note
Some customers have raised concerns about alleged racism by the owners, which has led to a boycott for some. There are also claims that the quality has declined and that the pizza is overpriced.
"The 'Spicy Spring' square pie, a famous pepperoni Sicilian slice, had spicy, crisp, and greasy pepperoni. The pizza's upside-down construction resulted in a moist, doughy, and chewy crumb, though the undercarriage was not crispy after delivery."
Negative"The user visited Prince Street Pizza and found it to be their favorite slice."
Positive"This commenter questions the popularity of Prince Street Pizza and suggests trying Upside instead."
Negative"Prince St. Pizza is described as 'very good'."
Positive"The user strongly dislikes Prince St. Pizza, considering it 'kind of garbage'."
Negative"The commenter criticizes Prince St. Pizza for its 'criminally priced' menu."
Negative"This user strongly prefers John's of Bleecker over Prince St. Pizza, also mentioning avoiding 'bigotry' at the latter."
Negative"The commenter recommends Prince St. Pizza as an alternative to John's of Bleecker."
Positive"The user advises against visiting Prince Street Pizza (PSP)."
Negative"The user suggests Prince Street Pizza, stating it remains a good option for both tourists and locals."
Positive"The original poster chose Prince St. Pizza as a classic alternative when their initial choice wasn't available, and enjoyed their vodka grandma slices and little pepperoni cups."
Positive"Prince Street Pizza is described as a classic and alright, though the commenter personally prefers Upside Pizza."
Neutral"Prince Street Pizza is considered overrated and tasteless, with the commenter strongly suggesting L'Industrie as a superior alternative worth waiting in line for."
Negative"Prince Street Pizza is acknowledged as good, with its vodka slice being excellent. However, the commenter notes that equivalent pizza can be found elsewhere without the insane lines."
Neutral"The commenter recommends skipping Prince Street Pizza because its quality has declined from what it used to be, not due to other controversies."
Negative"The commenter questions why the positive opinion on Prince Street Pizza's quality is being downvoted, reaffirming that the pizza is indeed good."
Positive"The commenter advises skipping Prince Street Pizza in favor of L'industrie, Mama's Too, or Lucia in Soho."
Negative"The commenter expresses a negative opinion about Prince Street Pizza using a thumbs down emoji."
Negative"The commenter advises skipping Prince Street Pizza due to alleged racist behavior and suggests it's not worth the stomach space."
Negative"Prince Street Pizza is described as pretentious, with the commenter preferring Lucia or Ceres for pizza in Soho."
Negative
