Iconic spicy pepperoni squares & garlicky grandma slices. Worth the wait for a classic NYC pizza experience, though some find it overrated.
A staple in Nolita, Prince Street Pizza is renowned for its unique spicy pepperoni square slices, which are a must-try for any pizza aficionado. While many rave about the quality and flavor, some find the experience a bit overrated or overpriced. Despite controversies, the pizza itself continues to draw crowds and satisfy many with its distinct taste.
Prince Street Pizza is famous for its Sicilian-style square slices, particularly the spicy pepperoni. Customers often rave about the crispy, greasy pepperoni and the flavorful crust. However, some find the pizza to be overpriced, undercooked, or overrated, with a few mentioning a decline in quality over time. The vodka slice and grandma slice also receive mentions, with some enjoying the creamy mozzarella and garlicky notes.
"The spicy pepperoni square slice is frequently mentioned and highly recommended, as is the vodka slice."
Customer sentiment is polarized, with many praising the signature spicy pepperoni square and vodka slices, while others criticize the quality, price, and alleged controversies surrounding the owners.
Important Note
Some customers report a decline in quality over time, and there are significant allegations of racism against the owners, leading some to boycott the establishment.
"Prince Street Pizza is suggested as a fast, cheap, and delicious choice for a classic New York pizza slice, ideal for those needing a quick bite before catching a train."
Positive"Prince Street Pizza is noted for making an absolutely loaded slice of pepperoni, described as good stuff, although it is a Sicilian style."
Positive"The commenter suggested Prince Street Pizza for pepperoni slices."
Positive"This user advises against Prince Street Pizza, linking to a negative review and suggesting they have been in decline and are now focused on Goldbelly orders."
Negative"This user recommends Prince Street Pizza in Nolita for its amazing, super garlicky grandma slice."
Positive"The user noted Prince Street Pizza's low ranking with negative votes, expressing amusement."
Neutral"Suggests skipping Prince Street Pizza, calling it a 'TikTok tourist trap' and mentioning the owners are racist."
Negative"Prince Street Pizza has owners who are known to be racist."
Negative"Prince Street Pizza has fallen off in recent decades and has racist owners."
Negative"Recommends skipping Prince Street Pizza and suggests several other pizzerias instead."
Negative"The user was disappointed with Prince Street Pizza's pepperoni square, even without waiting in line."
Negative"The user regrets waiting 45 minutes for Prince Street Pizza's pepperoni square, finding it good but not worth more than a 5-minute wait."
Negative"The user enjoyed the vodka slice at Prince Street Pizza so much they bought another after dropping the first, but stopped going due to hearing about the owners' alleged racism."
Neutral"The user enjoyed the vodka slice at Prince Street Pizza so much that they bought another after dropping the first, but stopped going due to hearing about the owners' alleged racism."
Neutral"The user enjoyed the vodka slice at Prince Street Pizza so much that they bought another after dropping the first, but stopped going due to hearing about the owners' alleged racism."
Neutral"Prince Street Pizza is recommended to be dropped due to not being that good and the owners being bigots."
Negative"Prince Street Pizza is mentioned as having owners who are 'bigots', with a link provided to an article detailing accusations of racism."
Negative"The vodka slice at Artichoke Pizza is suggested as potentially better than Prince Street Pizza's."
Neutral"Prince Street Pizza is recommended to be skipped."
Negative"Despite its greasy appearance, the author found Prince Street Pizza's pepperoni square slice to be addictive, noting that the first bite is deceptive but leads to finishing the whole slice."
Positive
