TLDR
Iconic square Sicilian slices featuring heavily-loaded, crispy pepperoni. A polarising city staple known for both its bold flavors and significant public controversy.
Reddit Sentiment for PRINCE STREET PIZZA(based on 51 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
This establishment is recommended as part of the GoCity New York Mini Guide for its casual dining and pizza.
Prince St. Pizza has partnered with Milk Bar to create a distinctive Pepperoni & Hot Honey Sundae. While the sundae is sold at Milk Bar, the collaboration highlights Prince St. Pizza's iconic pepperoni as a key ingredient, blending its savory flavors into a unique dessert experience.
Details
Famous for its signature square Sicilian slices, this spot is often considered a quintessential NYC culinary experience [38]. While many praise the addictive, loaded pepperoni and vodka slices [12], [30], [36], the establishment has faced significant controversy and boycotts due to the owners' past racist remarks [4], [14], [23]. Additionally, some patrons have expressed disappointment regarding declining quality and high prices at newer locations [27], [39], [41].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on Italian-American style pizza, specifically renowned for its garlicky, loaded pepperoni Sicilian square slices [3], [26], [30]. The 'Spicy Spring' and vodka slices are frequently cited as highlights [3], [30], [33], though some diners find the crust under-crisp upon delivery [3] or note that the 'Fancy Prince' slice offers a sweeter, saucier profile [10].
Highlights / Recommended
"The pepperoni square slice is the most frequently recommended item, often described as loaded and addictive [12], [30]. The vodka slice also receives high marks for its flavor profile [33]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •pepperoni square(2)
- •vodka slice(2)
- •pepperoni slice(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customer feedback is deeply divided; while many crave the signature pepperoni and vodka slices, a substantial portion of the community actively avoids the shop due to the owners' history of racist comments [4], [16], [23]. Others cite a noticeable decline in quality and suggest that the wait times often exceed the value of the experience [6], [20], [27].
Caveats
Potential diners should be aware of widespread reports regarding the owners' past racist conduct, which has led to many locals choosing not to patronize the establishment [4], [14], [25]. Furthermore, visitors often warn that the shop can be a 'tourist trap' with long lines and inconsistent quality compared to its reputation [20], [25], [27].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PRINCE STREET PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Need A Reco For Your Favorite Pizza In Soho That
"Mentioned with negative sentiment regarding the owners."
NegativeFrom post: Need A Reco For Your Favorite Pizza In Soho That
"Highly recommended, noting its square pizza is incomparable."
PositiveFrom post: Need A Reco For Your Favorite Pizza In Soho That
"Simply mentioned by name."
NeutralFrom post: Need A Reco For Your Favorite Pizza In Soho That
"Considered good but not the real NYC slice."
NeutralFrom post: Need A Reco For Your Favorite Pizza In Soho That
"Described as a slice shop."
NeutralFrom post: Need A Reco For Your Favorite Pizza In Soho That
"Included in a list of SoHo-area pizza spots."
NeutralFrom post: Ceres Question Best Choice And Ordering Process
"The commenter mentions visiting Prince Street Pizza as an alternative when other shops were closed."
NeutralFrom post: Stuck In My Hotel For The Day What To Order In In
"Recommended as a nice quick bite for a visitor, specifically the pepperoni slice."
PositiveFrom post: Stuck In My Hotel For The Day What To Order In In
"Suggested for pizza."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Day Nyc Need Food Recommendations Updated With
"The user notes concerns about Prince Street Pizza having past racist incidents and is hesitant to patronize it, despite its popularity."
NegativeFrom post: 7 Day Nyc Need Food Recommendations Updated With
"Prince Street Pizza is considered essential and better in NYC than its other branches, including the one in LA."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Go In The Les If It Was Your
"Prince Street Pizza is recommended for a slice."
PositiveFrom post: Local Ny Birthday Food Crawl East Village And
"The commenter noted that Prince Street Pizza is on the route and that omitting pizza from a New York food itinerary would be an insult to the city's culinary heritage."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user simply listed 'Prince St Pizza' as an example of overpriced pizza."
NegativeFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This commenter noted that the new Prince Street Pizza in Carroll Gardens is charging $7.50 a slice, which they find to be more than the going rate for other notable slice shops in the neighborhood and are unwilling to pay."
NegativeFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user suggested the new Prince St Pizza in Carroll Gardens is overpriced, charging $8 a slice."
NegativeFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"Pepperoni pizza (7/10) and vodka pizza (8/10) from Prince Street Pizza were rated positively, though noted as not as good as previous visits, but still considered great."
PositiveFrom post: Fermento Pizza The Best Slice No One Is Talking
"Commenter mentioned that Ceres, L'Industrie, Prince St, and Lucia are all within a 10-minute walk in SoHo."
NeutralFrom post: Odds Of Getting Into Langans Tomorrow Sunday
"Prince Street Pizza is suggested as a fast, cheap, and delicious choice for a classic New York pizza slice, ideal for those needing a quick bite before catching a train."
PositiveFrom post: One Shot One Perfect Pepperoni Slice Where
"Prince Street Pizza is noted for making an absolutely loaded slice of pepperoni, described as good stuff, although it is a Sicilian style."
Positive