TLDR
Iconic, crispy-crust Sicilian pepperoni squares that have long defined the NYC slice shop experience, though now subject to mixed reviews regarding consistency and controversy.
Reddit Sentiment for PRINCE STREET PIZZA(based on 44 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The reviewer tries multiple slices from Prince Street Pizza, including the classic regular pepperoni and a four-cheese slice. They express particular excitement for the pepperoni slice, praising its crispy crust, greasy pepperoni, and tangy sauce. The reviewer also enjoys the four-cheese slice, noting its delicious char and cheese pull. The post concludes with the reviewer calling the pizza 'unbelievable' and 'really, really nice'.
This post discusses NYC pizza, highlighting that the dough to topping ratio has been perfected. It features slices of pizza with pepperoni and a classic margherita style, as well as a square slice with pepperoni.
The author visited Prince Street Pizza to try their brand new dessert pizza, which was launched in collaboration with McCormick. The pizza features McCormick's newly crowned "up-and-coming flavor," blackcurrant, in a glaze over a sweet apple crumble topping.
Prince Street Pizza experiments with dessert by launching a limited-edition Black Currant Big Apple Pie Pizza in collaboration with McCormick.
Details
Renowned for its iconic, heavily loaded Sicilian-style pepperoni squares, this establishment is often considered an essential stop on an NYC pizza crawl [19], [27]. While many patrons remain loyal to the signature crispy, greasy pepperoni and tangy sauce [20], [21], others report a recent decline in overall quality and flavor depth [36]. The experience is further complicated for many by lingering controversies regarding the owners' past behavior [3], [4], [12], [14], [28].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on Italian-American pizza, highlighted by thick, Sicilian-style squares that are famously loaded with pepperoni cups [19], [20], [36]. Highly regarded options include the pepperoni and vodka slices [21], though some diners note that quality can be inconsistent compared to past experiences [21], [36]. Additionally, the shop occasionally experiments with unconventional items like the limited-edition Black Currant Big Apple Pie dessert pizza [37].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PRINCE STREET PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Plan My Once In A Lifetime Nyc Pizza Crawl Doctor
"Mentioned as a classic spot to visit in conjunction with other recommended pizza places."
NeutralFrom post: Brunch At Bubbys In Tribeca I Give It An 810 It
"Mentioned waiting 45 minutes in the rain and feeling it was not worth it."
NegativeFrom post: New York Food Adventures During The World Cup
"Still offers solid pizza, though the quality seems to have declined slightly over time and the sauce lacks depth."
NeutralFrom post: Need A Reco For Your Favorite Pizza In Soho That
"Mentioned with negative sentiment regarding the owners."
NegativeFrom post: Need A Reco For Your Favorite Pizza In Soho That
"Highly recommended, noting its square pizza is incomparable."
Positive