Famous for its spicy pepperoni square slice [1], a classic NYC pizza experience. Also known for its vodka grandma slices. Offers a rich, savory contrast to sweet treats [2].
This New York City pizzeria is renowned for its iconic spicy pepperoni square slice, a must-try for pizza enthusiasts. While many praise the unique crispiness of the pepperoni and the satisfying crust, some reviews suggest a decline in quality over the years. Additionally, there are significant discussions and concerns regarding past racist incidents involving the owners, which have led some patrons to reconsider their patronage [1, 2].
This pizzeria is best known for its spicy pepperoni square slice, often described as having crispy, curled pepperoni cups and a satisfying crust [1]. The vodka grandma slice is also frequently mentioned and enjoyed, noted for its creamy mozzarella and rich sauce [2, 3]. However, some patrons feel the quality has declined, and the 'spicy' aspect of the pepperoni pizza is sometimes questioned [4, 5].
"The spicy pepperoni square slice and the vodka grandma slice are highly recommended, with the pepperoni known for its crispy cups and the vodka slice for its creamy mozzarella and rich sauce."
Customer sentiment is divided, with many praising the quality of the pepperoni and vodka slices [1, 2]. However, recurring negative feedback points to concerns about the owners' past racist remarks and a perceived decline in food quality over time [3, 4].
Important Note
There are significant concerns raised about the owners' past racist remarks, which have led some customers to avoid the establishment. Some patrons also feel that the quality of the pizza has declined over time and that certain items are overpriced, especially at newer locations.
"The user notes concerns about Prince Street Pizza having past racist incidents and is hesitant to patronize it, despite its popularity."
Negative"Prince Street Pizza is considered essential and better in NYC than its other branches, including the one in LA."
Positive"Prince Street Pizza is recommended for a slice."
Positive"The commenter noted that Prince Street Pizza is on the route and that omitting pizza from a New York food itinerary would be an insult to the city's culinary heritage."
Positive"This user simply listed 'Prince St Pizza' as an example of overpriced pizza."
Negative"This commenter noted that the new Prince Street Pizza in Carroll Gardens is charging $7.50 a slice, which they find to be more than the going rate for other notable slice shops in the neighborhood and are unwilling to pay."
Negative"This user suggested the new Prince St Pizza in Carroll Gardens is overpriced, charging $8 a slice."
Negative"Pepperoni pizza (7/10) and vodka pizza (8/10) from Prince Street Pizza were rated positively, though noted as not as good as previous visits, but still considered great."
Positive"Commenter mentioned that Ceres, L'Industrie, Prince St, and Lucia are all within a 10-minute walk in SoHo."
Neutral"Prince Street Pizza is suggested as a fast, cheap, and delicious choice for a classic New York pizza slice, ideal for those needing a quick bite before catching a train."
Positive"Prince Street Pizza is noted for making an absolutely loaded slice of pepperoni, described as good stuff, although it is a Sicilian style."
Positive"The commenter suggested Prince Street Pizza for pepperoni slices."
Positive"This user advises against Prince Street Pizza, linking to a negative review and suggesting they have been in decline and are now focused on Goldbelly orders."
Negative"This user recommends Prince Street Pizza in Nolita for its amazing, super garlicky grandma slice."
Positive"The user noted Prince Street Pizza's low ranking with negative votes, expressing amusement."
Neutral"Suggests skipping Prince Street Pizza, calling it a 'TikTok tourist trap' and mentioning the owners are racist."
Negative"Prince Street Pizza has owners who are known to be racist."
Negative"Prince Street Pizza has fallen off in recent decades and has racist owners."
Negative"Recommends skipping Prince Street Pizza and suggests several other pizzerias instead."
Negative"The user was disappointed with Prince Street Pizza's pepperoni square, even without waiting in line."
Negative
