Classic NYC steakhouse known for its visible dry-aging meat locker & hickory-grilled steaks. A splurge-worthy spot with a historic ambiance.
Gallagher's Steakhouse offers a quintessential New York City steakhouse experience, dating back to 1927. It's renowned for its visible meat locker showcasing expertly dry-aged steaks, grilled over hickory for a distinct smoky flavor. While many rave about the quality and tenderness of their steaks, some diners have noted past concerns about health ratings and occasional inconsistency. The ambiance is classic and old-school, making it a popular choice for a traditional steak dinner.
Gallagher's is a classic American steakhouse celebrated for its dry-aged USDA Prime beef, grilled over hickory. While many patrons highly recommend the steaks, with the rib steak being a particular highlight, some reviews mention inconsistency and past concerns about health ratings. The prime rib sandwich with au jus is noted as a unique lunch special.
"The dry-aged steaks, particularly the rib steak, are highly recommended. The prime rib sandwich with au jus is a notable lunch-only special."
Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, praising its classic steakhouse atmosphere and the quality of its dry-aged steaks. However, there are some concerns regarding inconsistent food quality and past health code violations.
Important Note
Some users have expressed concerns about past health code violations and inconsistent food quality, though recent information suggests improved ratings.
"Gallagher's had a good beef tartare, according to the user, though it has been a couple of years since their last visit."
Positive"Gallagher's had a good beef tartare, according to the user, though it has been a couple of years since their last visit."
Positive"Gallagher's had a good beef tartare, according to the user, though it has been a couple of years since their last visit."
Positive"Gallagher's had a good beef tartare, according to the user, though it has been a couple of years since their last visit."
Positive"Replying to a comment about Gallaghers' sides, the original poster suggested they might have ordered incorrectly."
Neutral"This commenter disagrees with the original poster, finding the sides at Gallaghers to be better than those at Peter Luger's."
Positive"The user found Gallaghers to be good, but preferred Peter Luger's sides. They also noted that Hawksmoor is now available in NYC."
Positive"This steakhouse is mentioned as a strong contender for steak, though the commenter slightly prefers Keen's."
Positive"This steakhouse is recommended for its killer lunch special. It is suggested as a potential option for a solo birthday dinner."
Positive"This steakhouse is briefly recommended as an option for steak."
Positive"This user had a negative experience at Gallagher's on their last visit, contrasting it with better experiences at Strip House and Wolfgang's."
Negative"Gallagher's is mentioned as being around the area for steak, although the user acknowledges mixed opinions."
Neutral"Gallagher's is recommended."
Positive"Gallagher's Steakhouse is presented as a steakhouse option for a $250 dinner."
Positive"Gallagher's is stated to be bad, with a negative comparison to Strip House, Club A, and Hawksmoor. The user explicitly says Gallagher's sucks."
Negative"Gallagher's is ranked as the least preferred among several steakhouse options, including Wolfgang's and Delmonico's."
Negative"A direct negative recommendation against dining at Gallagher's."
Negative"The user strongly advises against Gallagher's, citing a history of health code violations and a negative personal experience with cold, under-seasoned food. They state that Gallagher's is not among the many great steakhouses in NYC."
Negative"Asks if Gallagher's is casual enough for the user's needs, suggesting it as a potential option."
Neutral"States they have booked Gallagher's after receiving suggestions, indicating a positive decision based on the recommendations."
Positive
