Iconic NYC steakhouse w/ visible dry-aging meat locker. Classic vibes & expertly grilled steaks since 1927.
Junod visits Gallagher's Steakhouse, a classic Manhattan establishment, for a meal that is "utterly delicious, but sort of nauseating," echoing his complex feelings about his father.
Step into a piece of New York history at this iconic steakhouse, a Broadway favorite since 1927. Experience the thrill of their visible dry-aging meat locker, a nod to their classic roots, before indulging in expertly grilled, high-quality steaks. With a blend of old-school charm and modern culinary touches, this establishment offers a truly authentic NYC steakhouse experience.
This American steakhouse is renowned for its USDA prime dry-aged steaks, grilled to perfection. While steaks are the main draw, other popular dishes include their hash browns, creamed spinach, and a highly recommended cheesecake. There's also a notable 'sleeper' prime rib sandwich with au jus available at lunch. While most feedback is positive, some diners have expressed that certain steaks could be more flavorful or better charred.
"The dry-aged steaks are a signature item, with specific mentions of the Porterhouse and Rib steaks. The prime rib sandwich with au jus, available at lunch, is highlighted as a 'sleeper' hit. The cheesecake and clams casino are also recommended."
Customers generally praise the restaurant for its classic NYC steakhouse experience, high-quality dry-aged steaks, and attentive service, particularly at the bar. Some recent mentions of past health code concerns have been addressed with updated ratings.
Important Note
Concerns have been raised in the past regarding the restaurant's health rating, with some users citing a 'C' rating. However, more recent comments indicate the restaurant has since regained an 'A' rating. Some diners have also noted inconsistent steak charring or flavor.
"Gallaghers was suggested as a dining option."
Positive"This commenter suggests Gallagher's as a good option for an old-school steakhouse experience in the heart of the theater district, noting it's easier to get a seat at the bar compared to Monkey Bar."
Positive"Gallagher's provided a very hospitable experience at the bar, where the commenter enjoyed drinks, snacks, and a nearly full dinner while chatting with the bartender. They preferred the bar experience to a table dinner."
Positive"Gallagher's on 52nd and Broadway is recommended for its lunch special when dining at the bar."
Positive"Gallagher's is noted for dry-aged meat if that is a preference, though Delmonico's is preferred for its meat preparation, service, and ambiance."
Neutral"Gallagher's is noted for dry-aged meat if that is a preference, though Delmonico's is preferred for its meat preparation, service, and ambiance."
Neutral"Gallagher's has been a disappointment, failing twice to deliver a steak with a decent char."
Negative"Gallagher's has been a disappointment, failing twice to deliver a steak with a decent char."
Negative"During a period of brief employment at Gallagher's, a 'C' rating was received, which was not surprising given the perceived unsanitary conditions."
Negative"During a period of brief employment at Gallagher's, a 'C' rating was received, which was not surprising given the perceived unsanitary conditions."
Negative"Gallagher's should be skipped as it's not on the same level as other mentioned restaurants."
Negative"Gallagher's should be skipped as it's not on the same level as other mentioned restaurants."
Negative"Experiences at Gallagher's have been limited to work lunches, suggesting it's suitable for such occasions but not for personal dining choices."
Negative"Experiences at Gallagher's have been limited to work lunches, suggesting it's suitable for such occasions but not for personal dining choices."
Negative"Both Delmonico's and Gallagher's are seen as mid-tier, but Gallagher's would be chosen over Delmonico's if a choice must be made."
Positive"Both Delmonico's and Gallagher's are seen as mid-tier, but Gallagher's would be chosen over Delmonico's if a choice must be made."
Positive"Gallagher's is good, but Delmonico's offers a more complete experience."
Neutral"Gallagher's is good, but Delmonico's offers a more complete experience."
Neutral"Gallagher's is considered a tier or two below Keens. The steak is believed to be dry-aged, which might be a preference."
Negative"Gallagher's is considered a tier or two below Keens. The steak is believed to be dry-aged, which might be a preference."
Negative
