Classic NYC steakhouse w/ dry-aged prime beef, open-flame grilled. Historic vibe & visible meat locker.
Step into a New York institution that has been serving expertly dry-aged steaks since 1927. Gallagher's Steakhouse offers a classic, old-school dining experience with a nod to its history and a visible meat locker. Enjoy high-quality, USDA Prime beef grilled over hickory, with their rib steak being a particular highlight.
Known for its dry-aged USDA Prime beef, grilled over hickory, Gallagher's offers a classic steakhouse experience. The rib steak is frequently mentioned as a standout, and the prime rib sandwich with au jus is noted as a lunch-only 'sleeper' hit. While many praise the quality, some reviews suggest inconsistency, and there have been past concerns regarding health ratings, though recent updates indicate an 'A' rating.
"The dry-aged rib steak is a frequently praised item. The prime rib sandwich with au jus is recommended as a lunch-only special. The three-course lunch special is also highlighted as a great value."
Customers generally praise the classic steakhouse atmosphere, with many recommending the dry-aged steaks and the value of the lunch specials. However, some express concerns about inconsistent quality and past health code ratings.
Important Note
Some users have expressed concerns regarding past health code violations, although recent information suggests the restaurant has regained an 'A' rating. There are also mentions of inconsistent steak quality and some negative experiences.
"Gallagher's offers a $34 three-course prix fixe lunch deal and reasonable prices on other lunch menu items (excluding steaks), fitting within the budget. The restaurant provides an old-school NYC feel with an impressive meat aging room, excellent food, and highly-rated cheesecake. It's noted as not being too noisy and suitable for leaving a positive impression."
Positive"The commenter's husband made them view the historic urinals in the men's restroom at Gallagher's."
Neutral"Gallagher's has a 'C' rating."
Negative"The bar at Gallagher's offers a classic NYC steakhouse scene with old-school bartenders and service, including historic urinals."
Positive"Gallagher's is recommended for a classic steakhouse experience with good bar seating."
Positive"Gallagher's is a good spot for solo patrons to chat with others at the bar."
Positive"Gallaghers is recommended as a steakhouse option in Midtown."
Positive"The commenter suggests Gallaghers."
Positive"Gallagher's is described as a very good steakhouse, particularly for those accustomed to old-school service."
Positive"Gallagher's is recommended, with the commenter stating 'hands down'."
Positive"The user lists Gallagher's as one of their regrets."
Negative"This commenter simply recommends Gallagher's."
Positive"The commenter finds it surprising that Gallagher's competes with other top steakhouses."
Neutral"Gallagher's is listed as one of the commenter's top steakhouse picks in Manhattan."
Positive"Gallagher's is described as a go-to spot with classic vibes, great quality aged steaks, and attentive service."
Positive"The commenter enjoys Gallagher's storefront display of meat."
Positive"The commenter finds Gallagher's steak to be a large piece of meat but not executed as nicely as Peter Luger's."
Neutral"This user finds Gallagher's to be superior to Keens."
Positive"The user recalls Gallagher's as their first major steakhouse experience, appreciating the great servers, food, and history."
Positive"The commenter's favorite steakhouse is Gallagher's, and they particularly enjoy its storefront display."
Positive
