Iconic NYC steakhouse w/ visible meat locker & open-flame grilled, dry-aged steaks. Old-school charm meets modern dishes.
This classic American steakhouse, a fixture since 1927, offers an authentic old-school New York dining experience. Known for its expertly dry-aged steaks, often cooked over an open flame and showcased in a visible meat locker, it blends traditional charm with modern culinary touches. Patrons can enjoy high-quality steaks alongside contemporary dishes, all within a historic atmosphere that even includes unique references to its past.
This American steakhouse specializes in dry-aged steaks, often grilled over an open flame, and features a prominent meat locker for display. While known for its high-quality steaks, it also offers more contemporary dishes. Some diners highlight the steak, burgers, and a prime rib sandwich as standouts, though a few have expressed concerns about inconsistent quality or seasoning.
"The prime rib sandwich with au jus is highlighted as a must-try lunch special. Other praised items include dry-aged steaks, burgers, and cheesecake."
Customers generally praise the restaurant for its classic steakhouse ambiance and well-prepared, dry-aged steaks. Some reviews mention the historic charm and attentive service.
Important Note
There have been past concerns regarding health code violations, though some users note that the restaurant has since improved its rating. Some reviews mention inconsistent food quality or seasoning.
"An old article from 2010 suggests that Porterhouse New York was among several high-profile NYC restaurants that served Creekstone Farms beef."
Neutral"The user recommends the cheesecake at Gallaghers."
Positive"This user mentioned that Gallagher's also serves Baked Alaska."
Positive"Gallagher's is listed as an example of a New York City steakhouse."
Positive"The user noted that Gallagher's frequently opens up tables closer to the date and reiterated their preference for the restaurant's meat over Hawksmoor NYC's."
Positive"The user suggested Gallagher's as an alternative to Hawksmoor NYC, located in the theater district and cooking steak on charcoal, stating a preference for its meat."
Positive"A Valentine's Day dinner at Gallagher's was ruined by the extremely close tables, which allowed a tourist couple to overhear and intrude upon their conversation, leading to an unsolicited and lengthy interaction."
Negative"Gallagher's is listed as a quintessential classic NYC restaurant, alongside Keens and Delmonicos. The commenter also suggested Little Italy for white tablecloth old NYC fan fare."
Neutral"This user mentioned Gallagher's in the Theater District as a potential option, noting it's not too far and delivery might be good, although they haven't personally tried delivery from there."
Neutral"Gallagher's is mentioned as a dinner recommendation."
Neutral"Gallagher's steak house was recommended."
Neutral"Gallagher's is recommended as an old-school New York dining establishment in the theater district, offering a traditional experience with proper wait staff service and very good food."
Positive"Gallaghers was mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"This steakhouse was mentioned with positive rumors and noted that while some steaks are under $65, most are in the $50-60 range."
Neutral"The original poster mentioned visiting Gallaghers and finding their New York Strip and Porterhouse steaks to be great."
Positive"The author describes their meal at Gallaghers as solid with a nice vibe, highlighting the steak, mac and cheese, and gorgonzola salad as excellent, but found the peppercorn sauce oily and the steak tartare disappointing."
Neutral"Gallagher's is suggested for steak, noting it's expensive but offers a festive holiday atmosphere near Broadway."
Positive"Gallagher's Steakhouse is listed as a touristy option in Times Square."
Neutral"Gallagher's Steakhouse is suggested for steak."
Positive"The user collects matchbooks from various NYC restaurants and Gallaghers is one of them."
Neutral
