Legendary Brooklyn pizzeria w/ decades of history. Once the undisputed king of NYC pizza, opinions are now mixed on whether it still holds the crown.
Di Fara Pizza, a legendary Brooklyn institution, has been serving up iconic pizzas for decades. While once considered the undisputed king of NYC pizza, recent opinions suggest a decline in quality since the passing of its founder, Dom DeMarco. Despite this, many still hold fond memories and some recent visitors report a positive experience, particularly with the square slices.
Di Fara Pizza is renowned for its classic Italian-American pizza, with many praising its traditional style. While some recent reviews indicate a decline in quality, with mentions of inconsistency and even burnt crusts, others maintain that the square slices and overall pizza remain exceptional. The experience can be subjective, and some believe the magic has faded since the original owner's era.
"The square slice and regular slice at Di Fara are frequently mentioned, with some users claiming they are still excellent and among the best in NYC. The pepperoni pizza is also highlighted as a good option."
Customer sentiment is divided, with many lamenting a perceived decline in quality since the founder's passing. However, some still find it to be excellent and worth the visit.
Important Note
Customer opinions are sharply divided, with many suggesting the quality has significantly declined since the founder's passing. Some also note that the original location can be out of the way and the wait times can be considerable.
"While waiting in line for pizza at Di Fara, the commenter spent about an hour next to Eddie Huang, who ended up paying for their pizza."
Positive"The original poster clarified that they expected a Di Fara pie, not a frozen pizza, and expressed that they would never use Wonder again after this experience."
Negative"This commenter expressed disbelief that Di Fara Pizza would partner with Wonder, calling it a travesty and stating the user likely received a frozen pizza, not actual Di Fara. They urged against supporting Wonder due to its nature as a private equity venture with frozen food."
Negative"This user criticized Wonder but also placed blame on restaurants like Di Fara Pizza for licensing their brand to the platform. They suggested Di Fara's quality has declined over time."
Negative"The user was unimpressed with a square pie ordered from Di Fara Pizza via Wonder, describing it as flavorless and arriving cold. They expressed regret for trying Wonder again."
Negative"In response to a suggestion that there are great pizza spots in the Heights, the user stated they expected a Di Fara pie and asked for recommendations for other pizza places in the area."
Neutral"The user confirms that the Di Fara Pizza on Ave J is the same one, noting it may have declined after the original owner's death."
Neutral"The user asks if Di Fara Pizza on Ave J is the same as the one mentioned, as they did not enjoy it."
Neutral"The user regrets waiting 1.5 hours for Di Fara Pizza, calling it the most frustrating experience."
Negative"Strongly recommends Da Fara on J Street in Brooklyn for pizza, suggesting a wait of up to 10 minutes for a slice due to constant sales. It's noted that waiting for a fresh 'slice pie' is sometimes necessary."
Positive"Di Fara Pizza is mentioned as an old famous pizza place, though its quality has reportedly declined recently."
Neutral"This user ranks Di Farra low among highly rated pizza shops, disliking its sauce for being over-seasoned. They prefer L&B Spumoni Gardens."
Negative"This user found Di Farra to be inconsistent, having had an amazing square pie once and a run-of-the-mill experience another time. They find it hard to recommend due to inconsistency and distance."
Neutral"This user defended their experience at Di Farra, stating that their slice and square pie proved it's worth taking a chance despite sub opinions. This was a response to a negative comment."
Positive"This user stated that people missed the window for Di Farra almost a decade ago. This suggests a significant decline in quality or relevance over time."
Negative"This user disagreed with verndogz's positive experience at Di Farra, describing the pies as burnt with under-proofed dough. They believe many other NYC pizzerias offer better slices at a lower price."
Negative"This user went to Di Farra in July and found it as good as when Dom DeMarco made the pies. They feel it's worth taking a chance despite negative opinions on the sub."
Positive"This user believes they missed the window to experience Di Farra at its best, expressing regret with a sad emoji."
Negative"This user stated that they have somehow yet to go to Di Farra. This implies it's a well-known pizza place they have been meaning to visit."
Neutral"The user initially removed Di Fara's from their list due to negative reviews after Dom's passing but decided to take a chance and was pleasantly surprised that the pizza was as good as they remembered."
Positive
