Legendary Brooklyn pizza joint, a true NYC classic. Worth the wait for a slice of history.
A legendary Brooklyn institution, this pizzeria has been serving up iconic Italian-American pizzas for decades. While some debate its current standing compared to its legendary past, it remains a must-visit for pizza aficionados seeking a taste of New York history. Be prepared for a potential wait, but the unique flavor profile and storied legacy make it a worthwhile pilgrimage for many.
This pizzeria is renowned for its classic Italian-American pizza, often described as having a unique flavor profile. While some long-time patrons and new visitors still rave about it, particularly the regular, cheese, and pepperoni slices, a significant portion of feedback suggests that the quality has declined since the passing of the original owner, Dom DeMarco. Some find the pizza can be inconsistent, with certain pies being burnt or lacking flavor, while others still consider it top-tier.
"The regular slice, cheese slice, pepperoni pizza, and square slice have been recommended. Some users specifically praise the Sicilian slice."
Customer sentiment is divided, with many praising its iconic status and unique flavors, while others note a perceived decline in quality since the founder's passing.
Important Note
Quality is reported to be inconsistent, with some finding it has declined significantly since the original owner passed away. It may not be worth a special trip for some, and the original location can have long waits.
"Strongly recommends Da Fara on J Street in Brooklyn for pizza, suggesting a wait of up to 10 minutes for a slice due to constant sales. It's noted that waiting for a fresh 'slice pie' is sometimes necessary."
Positive"Di Fara Pizza is mentioned as an old famous pizza place, though its quality has reportedly declined recently."
Neutral"This user ranks Di Farra low among highly rated pizza shops, disliking its sauce for being over-seasoned. They prefer L&B Spumoni Gardens."
Negative"This user found Di Farra to be inconsistent, having had an amazing square pie once and a run-of-the-mill experience another time. They find it hard to recommend due to inconsistency and distance."
Neutral"This user defended their experience at Di Farra, stating that their slice and square pie proved it's worth taking a chance despite sub opinions. This was a response to a negative comment."
Positive"This user stated that people missed the window for Di Farra almost a decade ago. This suggests a significant decline in quality or relevance over time."
Negative"This user disagreed with verndogz's positive experience at Di Farra, describing the pies as burnt with under-proofed dough. They believe many other NYC pizzerias offer better slices at a lower price."
Negative"This user went to Di Farra in July and found it as good as when Dom DeMarco made the pies. They feel it's worth taking a chance despite negative opinions on the sub."
Positive"This user believes they missed the window to experience Di Farra at its best, expressing regret with a sad emoji."
Negative"This user stated that they have somehow yet to go to Di Farra. This implies it's a well-known pizza place they have been meaning to visit."
Neutral"The user initially removed Di Fara's from their list due to negative reviews after Dom's passing but decided to take a chance and was pleasantly surprised that the pizza was as good as they remembered."
Positive"The commenter recommends Di Fara's in Midwood, stating that even after Dom passed away, the slices are still as good as remembered."
Positive"Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn is stated to have some of the best pizza in the city and is located in a neighborhood with many bakeries."
Positive"Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn is stated to have some of the best pizza in the city and is located in a neighborhood with many bakeries."
Positive"The commenter stated that a comparison to the past is impossible, as Dom was an irreplaceable 'X-Factor'."
Negative"A critique is made of the DiFara location on Kent Avenue in Williamsburg, calling it a 'disgrace' and specifically noting that the Original Square pizza lacks any discernible cheese or tomato flavor."
Negative"The commenter fondly remembers Dom's pies as outstanding, noting that the pizza was still very good shortly after Dom's passing. However, recent experiences indicate a decline in quality, with the 'magic gone' despite increased competition."
Neutral"A visitor recounted a recent experience, describing the pizza as one of the worst slices they'd ever had, citing a cardboard-like crust, insufficient sauce and cheese, and a stale taste, a stark contrast to the saucy and oily memories of the original."
Negative"The commenter mentioned visiting a DiFara location at the South Street Seaport a few years ago, finding it 'pretty close' to the original, but noted that this location has since closed."
Positive"The opinion is that the name has been 'sold out' and while the original location's pizza is not bad, it's not worth a special trip."
Neutral
