TLDR
Legendary Brooklyn institution serving iconic slices topped with fresh basil and olive oil. Once a gold standard, now a debated icon with varying reports on consistency.
Reddit Sentiment for DI FARA PIZZERIA(based on 39 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Di Fara is recognized as one of the top 15 best pizza places in New York City, revered for its classic, hand-crafted pies.
Bryan Kim reviews Di Fara, a legendary South Brooklyn shop serving salty, crunchy pies that maintain the legacy of founder Dom DeMarco.
Details
A legendary fixture in South Brooklyn since 1965, this shop has long been considered a foundational influence on the city's pizza scene [4]. While the pizzeria is celebrated for its traditional Neapolitan influence, including a flavorful sauce, fresh basil, and perfectly crisp crust [1], [4], its reputation has become a subject of intense debate following the death of its founder, Dom DeMarco [1], [23]. Recent experiences are polarized, with some diners still finding the pizza phenomenal while others report significant inconsistencies in quality and crust texture [23], [27].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic New York-style and Neapolitan-influenced pies, characterized by a notably salty, crunchy crust and a heavy, generous hand with fresh basil and olive oil [4]. While the sauce and cheese are often lauded for their quality [36], recent feedback highlights frustration with inconsistent crusts that can be soggy or burnt [23], [27].
The classic cheese and basil pizza remains a staple recommendation for those seeking the traditional flavor profile [1]. Both the regular and Sicilian slices have been noted as terrific options by recent visitors [29].
Customer sentiment is deeply divided, with some loyalists praising the restaurant's legacy and high-quality ingredients, while many others express disappointment regarding inconsistent food quality and high price points [21], [23], [27]. Additionally, partnerships with delivery platforms like Wonder have drawn sharp criticism for resulting in cold or flavorless experiences [4], [7].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01pizza5 mentions
- 02square slice4 mentions
- 03square pie4 mentions
- 04regular slice3 mentions
- 05plain slice2 mentions
- 06sicilian slice2 mentions
Caveats
Quality may vary significantly depending on who is preparing the pizza, and many patrons have reported a decline in the overall experience since the original owner's passing [3], [23], [33]. Additionally, ordering through third-party services like Wonder has been associated with poor quality and cold food [4], [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About DI FARA PIZZERIA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Stopped going after three consecutive flavorless, soggy pies; finds the high price point inconsistent."
NegativeFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Claims the place has always been overrated, even before the original owner passed away."
NegativeFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Argues the current iteration is an improvement over the former owner due to basic sanitation standards, even if the pizza is mediocre."
PositiveFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Praises the service; when a pie was made with a hole, they offered a free replacement immediately."
PositiveFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Believes the restaurant is a victim of unfair haters and finds the pizza still phenomenal."
Positive