Iconic Brooklyn pizzeria with a legendary past, now facing mixed reviews on quality but still a must-try for some.
Di Fara Pizzeria has a storied legacy as a premier pizza destination, celebrated for its classic Italian-American pizzas. While many fondly recall enduring long waits for what was considered the best pizza in the country, recent sentiment suggests a decline in quality since the founder's passing. Despite mixed reviews, some still champion specific items like the square slice or pepperoni pizza, while others suggest exploring newer or alternative pizzerias.
Di Fara Pizzeria is renowned for its classic-style pizzas, with many customers recommending the regular slice and the square slice. However, there's a notable divide in opinion regarding its current quality, with some believing it has decreased since the founder's passing, citing inconsistency and occasional burnt pizzas. Despite these concerns, the pepperoni pizza and plain slice are still mentioned positively.
"The regular slice and the square slice at Di Fara Pizzeria are frequently recommended. The pepperoni pizza is also mentioned positively, with some customers finding even the plain cheese slice to be great."
Customers have mixed feelings about Di Fara Pizzeria. While some consider it a top-tier pizza spot, with specific praise for the square slice and pepperoni pizza, others feel the quality has significantly declined since the founder, Dom DeMarco, passed away. Some reviews mention inconsistency and burnt slices, while others defend the current offerings.
Important Note
Customer feedback suggests that the quality of pizza at Di Fara Pizzeria may be inconsistent and has declined since the passing of the original owner, Dom DeMarco. Some users report burnt slices or pizza that tastes like it's been sitting out, and it may not be worth traveling for if you're seeking the absolute best.
"Di Fara in Brooklyn is listed as a pizza place to try."
Neutral"The commenter's final meals included pizzas from Di Fara, specifically mentioning it during the time when Dom was still alive."
Positive"Di Fara's is considered to be as good as everyone says and might be the best New York style pizza around. It is recommended to head to South Brooklyn and stand in line for a whole pie, stating it's worth the wait."
Positive"The commenter visited Di Fara when the original owner was alive, experiencing a two-hour wait for pizza; this is more of a factual historical note than a direct current opinion on the food."
Neutral"The user unequivocally recommends taking Di Fara off the list of places to visit."
Negative"The user states that Di Fara's pizza quality has declined in recent years and is no longer worth traveling for."
Negative"Di Fara's is described as pretty good, low-key, and top-tier for its original style, but not massively unique and perhaps not worth a significant detour for something better."
Neutral"Having visited Di Fara since childhood, the user confirms that the quality has indeed decreased over time."
Negative"The user finds Di Fara's to be great and points out that visitors won't have to deal with lines of people taking selfies."
Positive"The commenter strongly advises against visiting Di Fara, stating that its quality is no longer even decent and is worse than an average New York slice."
Negative"Despite reports of decline, a recent visitor found Di Fara's Sicilian slice to be the best they had ever tasted, without exaggeration."
Positive"The user agrees that Di Fara's quality has declined since Dom died, making it not worth the effort to visit."
Negative"The commenter notes that Di Fara's quality has unfortunately declined since Dom, the patriarch, passed away."
Negative"Di Fara's was considered the best by this user about a decade ago, but they have heard that its quality has since declined."
Neutral"The commenter advises against visiting Di Fara due to its distant location, reported inconsistencies since the patriarch's departure, and a personal bad pizza experience."
Negative"The user mentions "OG Difara" in a discussion about slow pizza places, implying it is a well-known, possibly slow, but iconic establishment."
Neutral"The user is saddened by Difara's absence from the list, noting a significant decline in its quality since the original owner ("
Negative"Di Fara is listed as a good example of NYC pizza that is not burnt."
Positive"This user mentions that DiFara is on their list of pizza spots to check out in NYC."
Neutral"This user states that Dom DiFara was once considered the most respected person in New York pizza, though that status has changed over the last decade."
Neutral
