TLDR
Legendary Brooklyn institution serving classic hand-crafted pies with a signature flavorful sauce and crispy, charred crust. A must-visit piece of pizza history, though experiences can vary.
Reddit Sentiment for DI FARA PIZZERIA(based on 49 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Di Fara is recognized as one of the top 15 best pizza places in New York City, revered for its classic, hand-crafted pies.
Details
Renowned as a foundational Brooklyn institution, this pizzeria is celebrated for its hand-crafted, classic pies featuring a deeply flavorful sauce and a perfectly crisp, charred crust [1]. Despite its legendary status, the establishment has faced mixed reviews recently regarding consistency and quality following the passing of its founder [2]. While some patrons still enjoy a terrific, high-quality slice, others have expressed disappointment with recent experiences [3], [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on traditional Italian-American style pizza, highly regarded for fresh ingredients like homemade sauce, real mozzarella, and basil [1], [5]. While some maintain that the classic square and round pies remain exceptional, others have reported issues such as flavorless or under-proofed dough and burnt crusts [2], [3], [4].
Highlights / Recommended
Mentioned Dishes:
- •pizza(5)
- •square slice(4)
- •square pie(4)
- •regular slice(3)
- •plain slice(2)
- •sicilian slice(2)
- •slice(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customer sentiment is deeply polarized, ranging from those who consider it a phenomenal, authentic benchmark of New York pizza to others who lament a decline in quality and inconsistency [1], [2]. Many visitors find the experience worth the wait, while others express significant frustration with long queues and the perceived drop in standards [3], [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About DI FARA PIZZERIA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Stopped going after three consecutive flavorless, soggy pies; finds the high price point inconsistent."
NegativeFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Claims the place has always been overrated, even before the original owner passed away."
NegativeFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Argues the current iteration is an improvement over the former owner due to basic sanitation standards, even if the pizza is mediocre."
PositiveFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Praises the service; when a pie was made with a hole, they offered a free replacement immediately."
PositiveFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Believes the restaurant is a victim of unfair haters and finds the pizza still phenomenal."
PositiveFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Quality has declined significantly since the owner's death due to expansion, noting inconsistent crust, inferior sauce, and less fresh basil."
NegativeFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"The plain slice does not look as good as it did years ago in its prime, noting changes in cheese, sauce, and crust."
NegativeFrom post: Revisiting Difara Has Its Decline Continued Or Is
"Impressed that the next generation is now allowed to prep food, whereas previously Dom did everything."
PositiveFrom post: I Took My Daughter To Difara For A Premovie
"The user mentioned that the long wait times for service were frustrating."
NegativeFrom post: I Took My Daughter To Difara For A Premovie
"Found the quality inconsistent depending on who is making the pizza since Dom passed away."
NegativeFrom post: I Took My Daughter To Difara For A Premovie
"Defends the quality of ingredients, specifically the sauce and cheese, noting their high quality despite debates over the dough preparation."
PositiveFrom post: I Took My Daughter To Difara For A Premovie
"Claims it is an average slice for twice the price, comparing it negatively to Junior's."
NegativeFrom post: I Took My Daughter To Difara For A Premovie
"Considers the pizza here the second best, ranked behind Mama's Too and ahead of L&B."
PositiveFrom post: I Took My Daughter To Difara For A Premovie
"Believes the pizza is no better than an average NYC slice."
NegativeFrom post: I Took My Daughter To Difara For A Premovie
"The author enjoys the square pie at this shop."
PositiveFrom post: I Took My Daughter To Difara For A Premovie
"The author visited for a pre-movie dinner and found the pizza to be terrific, noting it was back to its great quality, and praised the bargain price for two."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And
"Tasty, but noted as quite expensive."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And
"Included in a list of recommended pizza spots."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter suggests Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user had a negative experience with a $10 slice of Di Fara Pizza in Las Vegas, finding it terrible, and an even worse $11 slice at Disney."
Negative