Iconic Brooklyn pizzeria w/ 60-yr legacy. Debated quality post-founder, but still a classic slice worth trying for some.
Di Fara Pizza, an iconic Brooklyn establishment, has been serving up classic Italian-American pizzas for six decades. While once legendary, a significant debate exists among patrons regarding its current quality, with many lamenting a decline since the passing of its founder, Dom DeMarco. Despite this, others still find the pizza to be a worthwhile experience, particularly the square slices, though consistency remains a point of contention.
Di Fara Pizza is renowned for its classic Italian-American pizzas, particularly its hand-crafted pies and square slices. While many hold fond memories of its legendary status, a recurring theme in customer feedback is a perceived decline in quality and consistency since the passing of its founder. Some reviewers still praise specific dishes like the Sicilian slice or pepperoni pizza, while others find the pizza to be inconsistent or even disappointing.
"The regular slice, cheese slice, and pepperoni pizza are mentioned as notable options. Some users specifically recommend the square slice, with one commenter calling the Sicilian slice the best they've ever had."
Customer sentiment is divided. Many believe the quality has significantly declined since the original owner passed, while others still find it to be a great pizza experience, especially certain slices.
Important Note
There is a strong and recurring sentiment among many reviewers that the quality of Di Fara Pizza has declined significantly since the passing of its founder, Dom DeMarco. Some suggest that it is no longer worth traveling for or that the experience is inconsistent.
"The user briefly mentions Di Fara in the context of other restaurants available through Wonder."
Neutral"A user mentioned Di Fara Pizza as a potential food spot."
Neutral"The user recalls thinking that paying $5 a slice at Di Fara Pizza was excessive in the past."
Negative"Di Fara in Brooklyn is recommended as a place for great pizza."
Positive"DeFara in Brooklyn is recommended for pizza."
Positive"Di Fara is listed among original Neapolitan institutions that make their own sauce, use double zero flour, real mozzarella, and basil, and are cooked in coal-burning ovens."
Positive"Di Fara was visited before its viral fame and was considered one of the freshest and best-balanced slices, representing a high-end pizza experience."
Positive"The user stated that Di Fara Pizza is good, even with the hype, but expressed uncertainty about its current state."
Neutral"While waiting in line for pizza at Di Fara, the commenter spent about an hour next to Eddie Huang, who ended up paying for their pizza."
Positive"The original poster clarified that they expected a Di Fara pie, not a frozen pizza, and expressed that they would never use Wonder again after this experience."
Negative"This commenter expressed disbelief that Di Fara Pizza would partner with Wonder, calling it a travesty and stating the user likely received a frozen pizza, not actual Di Fara. They urged against supporting Wonder due to its nature as a private equity venture with frozen food."
Negative"This user criticized Wonder but also placed blame on restaurants like Di Fara Pizza for licensing their brand to the platform. They suggested Di Fara's quality has declined over time."
Negative"The user was unimpressed with a square pie ordered from Di Fara Pizza via Wonder, describing it as flavorless and arriving cold. They expressed regret for trying Wonder again."
Negative"In response to a suggestion that there are great pizza spots in the Heights, the user stated they expected a Di Fara pie and asked for recommendations for other pizza places in the area."
Neutral"The user confirms that the Di Fara Pizza on Ave J is the same one, noting it may have declined after the original owner's death."
Neutral"The user asks if Di Fara Pizza on Ave J is the same as the one mentioned, as they did not enjoy it."
Neutral"The user regrets waiting 1.5 hours for Di Fara Pizza, calling it the most frustrating experience."
Negative"Strongly recommends Da Fara on J Street in Brooklyn for pizza, suggesting a wait of up to 10 minutes for a slice due to constant sales. It's noted that waiting for a fresh 'slice pie' is sometimes necessary."
Positive"Di Fara Pizza is mentioned as an old famous pizza place, though its quality has reportedly declined recently."
Neutral"This user ranks Di Farra low among highly rated pizza shops, disliking its sauce for being over-seasoned. They prefer L&B Spumoni Gardens."
Negative
