Details
This Brooklyn pizza spot is highly acclaimed for its sourdough pizza and pies, with a consistent quality that has endured even with increased attention. In addition to their pizzas, they also offer fantastic sourdough bagels on weekends [1]. The owner, Dave, has perfected the sourdough recipe, making the offerings exceptional [1].
Food Overview
The pizza here is a standout, with many praising its sourdough crust and overall quality, even comparing it favorably to New Haven style pizza [1]. Some users recommend the large pies, noting that smaller ones can sometimes be burnt [1]. Beyond pizza, they also offer excellent sourdough bagels on weekends, particularly recommended with their unique cream cheese flavors like pickled jalapeño or burnt scallion [1].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended are their sourdough pizzas and pies, with a special mention for the Caesar salad with anchovies. On weekends, their sourdough bagels are also a must-try, especially with unique cream cheese flavors like pickled jalapeño or burnt scallion."
Customer Sentiment
Customers overwhelmingly praise the quality and taste of the food, with many calling it amazing and some of the best pizza in the city. Long-time patrons report having no bad meals over many years of ordering [1].
Caveats
The restaurant does not appear to take reservations and may have long wait times during peak hours, making it less suitable for large groups where time is a constraint. Some users have noted that small pizzas can be burnt, and the bacon on certain pizzas may appear undercooked to some.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About WHEATED
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Are Your Favorite Spots In Prospect Lefferts
"Wheated is recommended for pizza, located a bit east of Prospect Lefferts Gardens."
PositiveFrom post: Super Thin Style Pizza
"Recommended Wheated in Kensington for pies that are so thin they turn into crackers if not eaten hot."
PositiveFrom post: Flatbush Recommendations 8 People
"If the group is fine with takeout and finding seating in Prospect Park, Wheated is a suggested option."
NeutralFrom post: Flatbush Recommendations 8 People
"Wheated does not appear to take reservations and can have long wait times during peak hours, making it not recommended for groups where time is a factor. However, their pizza is described as amazing."
NeutralFrom post: Is Patsys Or Totonnos Still Good
"The user asks if the commenter has tried Wheated."
NeutralFrom post: Best Pizza Place With Brooklyn Lager
"This commenter highly recommends Wheated on Church Ave in Brooklyn for their excellent pizzas and local craft beer, including a lager and IPA. They also mention a wide selection of whiskey."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This user states that Wheated has a pizza called 'Romano' that is quite similar to New Haven pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This New Havener suggests that LaLa's and Wheated in NYC will scratch the itch for New Haven style pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This commenter states that Wheated is the first place that comes to mind for great New Haven style pizza in Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"The original poster plans to try Wheated based on the recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This user specifies Wheated's location as Prospect Park South/Flatbush."
NeutralFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This user notes that Wheated is close to Park Slope and has excellent pizza and cocktails."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This commenter agrees that Wheated is very good and confirms it's not in Park Slope."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This user corrects the location of Wheated to Ditmas Park, not Park Slope."
NeutralFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This user expresses their enjoyment of Wheated."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This user agrees with the recommendation for Wheated."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This commenter believes Wheated does 'New Haven Style' pizza even better than New Haven, praising its sourdough crust and bar."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This commenter suggests Wheated serves a New Haven style pie in Park Slope."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This user notes that Wheated's regular menu pizza is 'New Haven inspired' with a thinner crust, but they occasionally offer a legit NH style which is the closest in NY."
PositiveFrom post: Closest Representation Of New Haven Pizza In Nyc
"This user suggests Wheated does or did offer 'New Haven Style' pizza and is well-regarded, though it doesn't have a coal oven."
Positive