Top-tier sourdough pizza & killer cocktails. Must-try thin crust & unique pies.
This Brooklyn-based pizzeria has garnered significant praise for its exceptional pizza, with many recommending it as one of the best in the city. Patrons frequently highlight the quality of their sourdough crust and pies, with some even suggesting their sourdough bagels are a must-try. Beyond pizza, the restaurant also boasts a notable whiskey selection and well-crafted cocktails, making it a well-rounded dining experience.
This restaurant is renowned for its pizza, with a strong emphasis on sourdough crusts and unique pie creations. The Chicago Tavern Style Plain Cheese pie is particularly highlighted for its cracker-thin crust and tangy-sweet sauce. Many consider it among the best pizza places in the city, and their sourdough bagels are also a popular item. Additionally, they are recognized for their good cocktails and whiskey selection.
"The sourdough pizza and pies are highly recommended, with a specific mention of the Chicago Tavern Style Plain Cheese pie for its thin crust and unique sauce. Their sourdough bagels are also a standout item, and their Caesar salad has received significant praise."
Customers overwhelmingly praise this establishment for its outstanding pizza, particularly its sourdough offerings and unique pies. It's also noted for its excellent whiskey selection and cocktails.
Important Note
One user noted that the small pies at Wheated tend to be burnt, recommending the large pies instead.
"The user listed Wheated as a pizzeria option in Brooklyn."
Positive"The user specifically recommended checking out Wheated if the original poster is serious about pizza."
Positive"This user advises getting the large pies at Wheated, as the small ones are often burnt, but praises them overall."
Positive"This user also recommends Wheated pizza."
Positive"This user directs towards Wheated for pizza, describing it as unique and exceptional."
Positive"Wheated is considered one of the commenter's favorite pizza places and is described as "so damn good.""
Positive"The commenter enjoys the owner Dave's chaotic Instagram presence."
Positive"Wheated has perfected its sourdough pizza and pies, with new menu additions also being incredible. The quality has remained consistent despite increased press, and their sourdough bagels are also fantastic."
Positive"The user likes the appearance of the salad at Wheated and mentions they make their own anchovy salad similarly at home."
Positive"The commenter states that everything at Wheated is amazing, with no bad meals in over 10 years of ordering."
Positive"The user asks about the quality of the anchovies in the salad at Wheated."
Neutral"The commenter highly praises Wheated, calling it one of the best pizza places in the city."
Positive"This is a short comment agreeing with the previous recommendation for Wheated."
Positive"This comment recommends Wheated in Brooklyn for a Caesar salad with anchovies, describing it as a killer one."
Positive"A user states Wheated in Brooklyn makes a good Caesar, which another user enthusiastically agrees with."
Positive"A user states Wheated in Brooklyn makes a good Caesar, which another user enthusiastically agrees with."
Positive"The user highly anticipates visiting Wheated, noting the owner's passion for their craft, which is evident on Instagram."
Positive"The user simply recommends Wheated."
Positive"The user recommends Wheated in Flatbush."
Positive"The user recommends Wheated, along with Astarita and Ogliastro, all located in Brooklyn."
Positive
