TLDR
Exceptional sourdough-crust pies and a standout whiskey list in a cozy Brooklyn tavern. A must-visit for serious pizza lovers looking for a top-tier experience.
Details
Renowned for its exceptional sourdough-crust pizzas, this Brooklyn tavern is a top-tier destination for those serious about quality pies [1], [2]. Beyond the pizza, the establishment offers a stellar selection of whiskey and local craft beers [3], [4], and even transforms into a bagel shop on weekend mornings [5]. While the dining experience is highly acclaimed, visitors should be prepared for potential wait times as the popular venue does not accept reservations [6].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on high-quality, sourdough-crust pizzas often compared to New Haven-style, known for being crispy and distinct [1], [4]. While the 'Romano' pie and various sourdough offerings receive high praise [5], some critics debate the topping choices [7]. On weekend mornings, the kitchen shifts to serving chewy, high-quality bagels with unique cream cheese spreads like pickled jalapeño and burnt scallion [5].
The large pizzas are highly recommended for their consistent quality [2]. Additionally, the pickled jalapeño and burnt scallion cream cheeses are standout accompaniments for their morning bagel service [5].
Feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with diners frequently calling the pizza 'absurdly good' [1] and highlighting the excellent beverage program [3]. Some customers note that the small pies can occasionally arrive burnt, and the lack of reservations can lead to long wait times [2], [6].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01caesar salad2 mentions
- 02pizza2 mentions
Caveats
Small pies are occasionally reported to arrive burnt, so larger pies are suggested instead [2]. Furthermore, the lack of reservations means you should plan for a potential wait [6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About WHEATED
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: The Different Flavors Of Paletas At The Mexican
"The user claims this is the best pizza they have ever had."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Favorite Spots In Prospect Lefferts
"Wheated is recommended for pizza, located a bit east of Prospect Lefferts Gardens."
PositiveFrom post: Super Thin Style Pizza
"Recommended Wheated in Kensington for pies that are so thin they turn into crackers if not eaten hot."
PositiveFrom post: Flatbush Recommendations 8 People
"If the group is fine with takeout and finding seating in Prospect Park, Wheated is a suggested option."
NeutralFrom post: Flatbush Recommendations 8 People
"Wheated does not appear to take reservations and can have long wait times during peak hours, making it not recommended for groups where time is a factor. However, their pizza is described as amazing."
Neutral