Grand, theatrical American classic w/ tableside presentations. A legendary spot for the sophisticated.
This iconic establishment, once a hub for the city's elite, has been stylishly renovated to maintain its grand and theatrical atmosphere. It offers attentive service with plentiful tableside presentations, focusing on elevated American classics. Standouts include unique crab cakes and a crispy duck with perfectly rendered skin.
The Grill offers elevated American classics with a focus on indulgent dishes and impressive tableside presentations. While known for its steak, particularly prime rib and filet, other standout dishes include unique crab cakes and a crispy duck. Desserts like the chiffon cake are also highly regarded.
"Standout dishes include the unique crab cakes, crispy duck, off-menu prime rib sandwich, steak tartare, and the chiffon cake with lemon curd."
Customers praise the restaurant's grand and theatrical atmosphere, attentive tableside service, and elevated American classics. It's frequently recommended for special occasions and business dinners.
Important Note
The restaurant is described as very expensive, and some reviewers note that certain popular dishes may sell out.
"The Grill is noted for having great food and being a lovely dining experience."
Positive"The Grill is very expensive, but its prime rib is reportedly very good."
Positive"The Grill was mentioned as an excellent option by the commenter."
Positive"The commenter dismisses The Grill as a recommendation, jokingly referring to it as 'Eater 2017,' implying it might be outdated or less relevant now."
Negative"The Grill is recommended as a dining option."
Positive"This user recommends inquiring with The Grill about purchasing their lemon chiffon cake, noting its exceptional deliciousness despite the potential high cost."
Positive"The Grill is recommended for its celebratory vibes and generally meets the criteria for a special occasion, though it's not a traditional steakhouse."
Positive"The Grill is recommended for a memorable experience with fun presentation, fitting for a special second night out."
Positive"The Grill is recommended as a go-to spot for very special occasions, offering great service, a gorgeous interior, and incredible food."
Positive"The Grill was suggested as the best, closest option near the theater district, noted for its classic New York ambiance and gorgeous dining room, but it closes at 11 PM."
Positive"For a 'price doesn't matter' crowd, this commenter suggested The Grill for an experience like 'fancy titans of industry'."
Positive"The Grill is recommended as the best, with good ambiance and drinks."
Positive"The commenter suggests The Grill as a place that fits the user's needs."
Positive"Recommends The Grill, describing it as terrific and very plush."
Positive"The filet at The Grill is described as 'life changing'."
Positive"In Midtown/CP South, The Grill is recommended for great steaks, with a note that it's not strictly a steakhouse. Pasta a la presse and crab cakes are recommended starters."
Positive"The duck press pasta at The Grill is highlighted as being very appealing."
Positive"The Grill may be a steakhouse, but it doesn't feel like one, and Keens is suggested as a better alternative."
Negative"Clarifying a previous comment, the asker inquired if the wait staff at The Grill recommended steak, to which the response was that they usually ask for recommendations and mention the top dishes sell out."
Neutral"In response to criticism, the commenter states they have enjoyed steak at The Grill more than at staples like Peter Luger."
Positive
