Next.js logo

THE WHITBY HOTEL

Last Updated: 2 months ago

Phone: (212) 939-7556

Address: 18 WEST 56 STREET 10019

TLDR

Elegant hotel dining w/ standout afternoon tea & acclaimed au poivre steak frites.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 5 Reddit comments)

80% Positive20% Neutral

Tags

american 2tea 4afternoon tea 2View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Details

Experience refined British-inspired dining in a sophisticated setting. This hotel restaurant is celebrated for its exceptional afternoon tea service, offering a delightful escape. For those seeking a more substantial meal, the au poivre steak frites is a standout dish, lauded for its remarkable pepper sauce.

Food Overview

The culinary experience here is highlighted by its highly-regarded afternoon tea, often compared favorably to other establishments. The au poivre steak frites is a must-try, with its pepper sauce receiving exceptional praise. While most feedback is positive, the focus appears to be on these specific offerings.

Highlights / Recommended

"The au poivre steak frites is highly recommended for its exceptional pepper sauce, and the afternoon tea service is frequently praised as a top-tier experience."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a very positive sentiment, frequently recommending the restaurant for its afternoon tea and specific dishes like the steak frites.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

A commenter raves about the au poivre steak frites, calling the pepper sauce the best they've ever had, and highly recommends it.
Multiple users recommend The Whitby Hotel for afternoon tea, suggesting it as a lovely, potentially less expensive alternative to The Plaza.
This post features a recommendation for The Whitby Hotel's tea service as a good option, especially if looking for an alternative to The Plaza.
The restaurant is mentioned in the context of having an afternoon tea, with a note about its British management.

Recent Mentions

From post: Best Steakhouse With Solo Bar Seating

"The au poivre steak frites at The Whitby has the best pepper sauce the commenter has ever had."

Positive
Nov 3, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tea Room W 9 Yo Daughter

"Recommends The Whitby as a lovely and potentially less expensive option for afternoon tea compared to The Plaza."

Positive
May 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tea Room W 9 Yo Daughter

"Recommends The Whitby for classic afternoon tea."

Positive
May 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Special Anniversary Lunch Near Central Park

"The commenter recommends The Whitby Hotel as an alternative to The Plaza for tea, especially if not with children."

Positive
Apr 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Food Recs For Pride And Prejudice Screening

"(British management) has an afternoon tea"

Neutral
Mar 14, 2025View Comment →