Last Updated: 3 months ago
Phone: (212) 228-2004
Address: 321 EAST 14 STREET 10003
Killer artichoke pizza, but be warned: it's a polarizing pie! Some love it fresh, others find it inedible.
This East 14th Street pizza joint is a real conversation starter, known for its distinctive artichoke pizza. While some patrons swear by it, describing it as a 'killer pie' when served fresh, others have had profoundly negative experiences, with one user calling it one of the most disgusting things they've ever tasted. The white pizza has also faced criticism for being inedible. The restaurant, once a trendy spot, is now viewed by some as a relic of past hype, best reserved for late-night cravings rather than sober dining, with a sense that its current location doesn't quite capture the magic of its original spot.
The pizza, particularly the artichoke pizza, elicits strong reactions. It's praised by some as excellent when fresh, with the original Chelsea location being a notable mention. However, others find it to be inedible, disgusting, and only suitable as 'drunk food.' The white pizza specifically is called out as inedible. The general sentiment suggests a decline from its earlier hype.
"The artichoke pizza is frequently mentioned, with some recommending it when fresh. However, its quality is highly contested."
Customer feedback is highly polarized. While some find the artichoke pizza to be a 'killer pie' when fresh, others strongly advise against it, with one commenter having an extremely negative reaction. The white pizza is described as inedible by one reviewer. Some feel the restaurant is overhyped and only good as 'drunk food,' with the current location not living up to its past reputation.
Important Note
Some customers feel the current E14th St location doesn't match the quality of its former spot. The restaurant is also described as more of a 'drunk food' option rather than a place for sober appreciation.
"Artichoke Basille's Pizza is cited as a past example of a hyped and trendy foodie destination that, like L'Industrie, was started by regular guys with no experience and eventually lost its buzz."
Neutral"Cosmicfeline_ states the original Artichoke in Chelsea is good, particularly the artichoke slice, but not much else impresses them. They haven't been in years."
Positive"Dsxm41780 recommends definitely avoiding Artichoke Basille’s Pizza."
Negative"The author had an extremely negative reaction to the artichoke pizza years ago, nearly vomiting and calling it one of the most disgusting things ever tasted."
Negative"The author considers Artichoke Basille's Pizza (and Prince St Pizza) to be drunk food that is gross when eaten sober, noting the E14th location doesn't hit the same as its old spot."
Negative"The author stated that the white pizza at Artichoke Basille's Pizza is inedible."
Negative"A commenter admitted to being a 'closeted lover' of Artichoke Basille's, stating they make a killer pie but it has to be fresh."
Positive
