Next.js logo

MY PIE

Updated

Phone: (917) 371-0000

Address: 690 LEXINGTON AVENUE 10022

TLDR

Roman-style pizza a taglio w/ 48hr dough prep. Try the potato gorgonzola or truffle mushroom slices!

Reddit Sentiment for MY PIE(based on 11 Reddit opinions)

55% Positive45% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

italian 6roman 4pizza 9View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Instagram Posts References

Summary

Details

This Roman-style pizzeria offers a unique pizza a taglio experience, emphasizing a special blend of flours from Rome and a 48-hour dough preparation for their rectangular slices. Their pizzas are cooked in a specialized electric Italian oven, with options like truffle oil mushroom and buffalo mozzarella frequently highlighted.

Food Overview

The restaurant specializes in Roman-style pizza a taglio, known for its unique dough preparation using a special flour blend from Rome and a 48-hour process. Popular recommended dishes include the potato gorgonzola pizza and truffle oil mushroom pizza.

Highlights / Recommended

"The potato gorgonzola pizza is a frequently recommended standout, along with other Roman-style square slices like truffle oil mushroom and buffalo mozzarella."

Customer Sentiment

Customers highly recommend this establishment, particularly praising its Roman-style pizza a taglio and specific dishes like the potato gorgonzola and truffle oil mushroom pizzas.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About MY PIE

This post specifically recommends the potato gorgonzola pizza at My Pie, with multiple commenters agreeing and highlighting it as a must-try.
This discussion highlights My Pie Pizzeria Romana as a notable establishment for Roman Pizza a Taglio in NYC.
A commenter suggests My Pie pizzeria romana, noting their potato rosemary slices are comparable to other well-regarded pizzerias.
This commenter recommends My Pie Pizzeria Romana for Roman-style pizza, suggesting it's a great option for those new to this style.
My Pie on 57th and Lex is recommended in this thread for its Roman-style square slices.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Where Can I Find This Type Of Pizza

"Commenter recommended My Pie Pizzeria Romana for Roman-style pizza, suggesting it's a must-try for New Yorkers and Neapolitans unfamiliar with this style."

Positive
Mar 23, 2026View Comment →

From post: Old School Vs New School Nyc Pizza

"This establishment is noted for serving Roman Pizza a Taglio style pizza."

Neutral
Dec 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Pizza Thats Little Different

"My Pie Pizzeria Romana is listed as a Roman pizza al taglio option in NYC."

Neutral
Oct 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Manhattan Pizza Tour My List And Other

"My Pie on 57th and Lex is recommended for Roman-style square slices."

Neutral
Oct 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Manhattan Pizza Tour My List And Other

"My Pie on 57th and Lex is recommended for Roman-style square slices."

Neutral
Oct 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: In Your Opinion Where Is The Best Pizza Bianca In

"This commenter suggested My Pie pizzeria romana, mentioning their potato rosemary slices are similar to Sullivan Street's offerings."

Neutral
Aug 23, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza

"This commenter seconds the recommendation for My Pie."

Positive
Jul 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza

"This commenter enthusiastically affirms the quality of My Pie pizzeria Romana, stating it is "So good!"."

Positive
Jul 6, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza

"My Pie pizzeria Romana, located at 57th and Lex, is highlighted as a notable remaining pizza a taglio establishment."

Positive
Jul 5, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza

"My Pie at Lex and 57th offers a potato gorgonzola pizza, which is a recommended option."

Positive
Jul 5, 2025View Comment →