TLDR
Authentic Roman-style pizza al taglio featuring superior 48-hour fermented dough. A must-try destination for square slice aficionados on Lex.
Instagram Posts References
The creator visits My Pie for a late lunch on a Sunday afternoon, praising it as her favorite and the best pizza in New York City. The pizzeria specializes in Taglio Alla Romana Pizza, made from a special mix of flours from Rome, Italy, with no added sugar, and a 48-hour dough preparation process. Each pizza is cooked at different temperature levels in a unique electric Italian pizza oven, reflecting the bakers' experience and love. The display case showcases a variety of rectangular pizza slices, including truffle oil mushroom and buffalo mozzarella, among others. She orders the Grandma Nonnino's pizza, highlighting its appealing presentation.
Details
Located on 57th and Lexington, this pizzeria specializes in authentic Roman-style pizza al taglio [2], [3]. The kitchen utilizes a 48-hour dough preparation process using flours imported from Italy, resulting in a superior crust and bake compared to local competitors [6], [7]. It is often described by locals as a hidden gem that remains underrated despite its high-quality offerings [12].
Highlights / Recommended
"The mushroom pizza is frequently highlighted as a standout choice, and the Grandma Nonnino's pizza is noted for its excellent presentation [13]."
Caveats
None explicitly noted beyond the suggestion to avoid other nearby chains due to quality concerns [10].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MY PIE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"The mushroom pizza is considered high quality."
PositiveFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"A highly underrated pizza spot that is frequently overlooked by best-of lists."
PositiveFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Mentioned as a restaurant in the general vicinity."
NeutralFrom post: Sofia Pizza Shoppe Midtown Eastues Closed
"The user recommends My Pie on Lexington as a good alternative, noting it's slightly more Roman-style than Sofia's was. They advise against Jets on 2nd Ave due to issues with underbaked crusts and mention Stretch has an outpost in The Hugh."
PositiveFrom post: Roman Style Pizza Slices Like Pqr
"This user noted that My Pie on Lexington and 57th appeared promising based on a Google search, considering it serves 'pizza al taglio'."
PositiveFrom post: Roman Style Pizza Slices Like Pqr
"This user also recommended My Pie on Lex."
PositiveFrom post: Roman Style Pizza Slices Like Pqr
"This user recommended My Pie, suggesting it has a better dough and bake compared to other options."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find This Type Of Pizza
"Commenter recommended My Pie Pizzeria Romana for Roman-style pizza, suggesting it's a must-try for New Yorkers and Neapolitans unfamiliar with this style."
PositiveFrom post: Old School Vs New School Nyc Pizza
"This establishment is noted for serving Roman Pizza a Taglio style pizza."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Thats Little Different
"My Pie Pizzeria Romana is listed as a Roman pizza al taglio option in NYC."
NeutralFrom post: Manhattan Pizza Tour My List And Other
"My Pie on 57th and Lex is recommended for Roman-style square slices."
NeutralFrom post: Manhattan Pizza Tour My List And Other
"My Pie on 57th and Lex is recommended for Roman-style square slices."
NeutralFrom post: In Your Opinion Where Is The Best Pizza Bianca In
"This commenter suggested My Pie pizzeria romana, mentioning their potato rosemary slices are similar to Sullivan Street's offerings."
Neutral