Next.js logo

MY PIE

Last Updated: 10 days ago

Phone: (917) 371-0000

Address: 690 LEXINGTON AVENUE 10022

TLDR

Authentic Roman pizza a taglio w/ 48-hr dough & unique oven. Try the potato gorgonzola!

Sentiment Overview(Based on 10 Reddit comments)

50% Positive50% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

italian 6roman 4pizza 8View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Instagram Posts References

Summary

Details

This Roman-style pizzeria offers a unique pizza a taglio experience, highly praised for its authentic flavors and preparation methods. The dough, made from a special flour mix from Rome with a 48-hour fermentation process and no added sugar, is cooked in a specialized Italian electric oven. Customer favorites include the potato gorgonzola and truffle oil mushroom slices, with many calling it the best pizza in NYC.

Food Overview

Specializing in Roman-style pizza a taglio, this spot uses a special flour mix from Rome, a 48-hour dough preparation process with no added sugar, and a unique electric Italian oven. Recommended dishes include the potato gorgonzola pizza and truffle oil mushroom pizza. It's frequently cited as one of the best pizza experiences in the city.

Highlights / Recommended

"The potato gorgonzola pizza is a standout recommendation, with other popular choices including truffle oil mushroom and buffalo mozzarella slices."

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly praise this pizzeria, with many considering it the best pizza in NYC and highlighting its unique Roman-style slices and excellent dough.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This post highlights My Pie for its potato gorgonzola pizza, calling it a recommended option. Multiple commenters agree, praising the establishment as a notable pizza a taglio spot.
A commenter suggests My Pie pizzeria romana, noting that their potato rosemary slices are comparable to those from Sullivan Street Bakery.
This discussion mentions My Pie Pizzeria Romana as a key establishment for Roman pizza al taglio in NYC, with one commenter noting it's a place that serves pizza a taglio style.
My Pie on 57th and Lex is recommended in this thread for its Roman-style square slices.

Recent Mentions

From post: Old School Vs New School Nyc Pizza

"This establishment is noted for serving Roman Pizza a Taglio style pizza."

Neutral
Dec 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Pizza Thats Little Different

"My Pie Pizzeria Romana is listed as a Roman pizza al taglio option in NYC."

Neutral
Oct 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Manhattan Pizza Tour My List And Other

"My Pie on 57th and Lex is recommended for Roman-style square slices."

Neutral
Oct 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Manhattan Pizza Tour My List And Other

"My Pie on 57th and Lex is recommended for Roman-style square slices."

Neutral
Oct 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: In Your Opinion Where Is The Best Pizza Bianca In

"This commenter suggested My Pie pizzeria romana, mentioning their potato rosemary slices are similar to Sullivan Street's offerings."

Neutral
Aug 23, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza

"This commenter seconds the recommendation for My Pie."

Positive
Jul 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza

"This commenter enthusiastically affirms the quality of My Pie pizzeria Romana, stating it is "So good!"."

Positive
Jul 6, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza

"My Pie pizzeria Romana, located at 57th and Lex, is highlighted as a notable remaining pizza a taglio establishment."

Positive
Jul 5, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza

"My Pie at Lex and 57th offers a potato gorgonzola pizza, which is a recommended option."

Positive
Jul 5, 2025View Comment →