TLDR
Roman-style pizza slices, praised for unique dough & bake. A must-try for authentic pizza a taglio [1], [2].
Instagram Posts References
The creator visits My Pie for a late lunch on a Sunday afternoon, praising it as her favorite and the best pizza in New York City. The pizzeria specializes in Taglio Alla Romana Pizza, made from a special mix of flours from Rome, Italy, with no added sugar, and a 48-hour dough preparation process. Each pizza is cooked at different temperature levels in a unique electric Italian pizza oven, reflecting the bakers' experience and love. The display case showcases a variety of rectangular pizza slices, including truffle oil mushroom and buffalo mozzarella, among others. She orders the Grandma Nonnino's pizza, highlighting its appealing presentation.
Details
MY PIE Pizzeria Romana is a lauded establishment in Manhattan specializing in Roman-style pizza, often referred to as pizza a taglio [1]. It's praised for its distinctive dough and baking techniques, utilizing a special flour mix from Rome and a 48-hour preparation process [2]. The pizzeria is noted for its high-quality ingredients and unique electric Italian pizza oven, which contribute to its exceptional crust and flavor profile [2], [3].
Food Overview
MY PIE Pizzeria Romana offers authentic Roman-style pizza a taglio, characterized by a special flour mix and a 48-hour dough preparation [2]. Popular choices include the potato gorgonzola pizza and truffle oil mushroom slices [1], [2]. The pizzeria is recognized for its superior dough and bake, distinguishing it from other pizza establishments [2], [3].
Caveats
One commenter advised against Jets on 2nd Ave due to underbaked crusts, and mentioned Stretch has an outpost in The Hugh, indirectly positioning MY PIE as a better alternative [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MY PIE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Sofia Pizza Shoppe Midtown Eastues Closed
"The user recommends My Pie on Lexington as a good alternative, noting it's slightly more Roman-style than Sofia's was. They advise against Jets on 2nd Ave due to issues with underbaked crusts and mention Stretch has an outpost in The Hugh."
PositiveFrom post: Roman Style Pizza Slices Like Pqr
"This user noted that My Pie on Lexington and 57th appeared promising based on a Google search, considering it serves 'pizza al taglio'."
PositiveFrom post: Roman Style Pizza Slices Like Pqr
"This user also recommended My Pie on Lex."
PositiveFrom post: Roman Style Pizza Slices Like Pqr
"This user recommended My Pie, suggesting it has a better dough and bake compared to other options."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find This Type Of Pizza
"Commenter recommended My Pie Pizzeria Romana for Roman-style pizza, suggesting it's a must-try for New Yorkers and Neapolitans unfamiliar with this style."
PositiveFrom post: Old School Vs New School Nyc Pizza
"This establishment is noted for serving Roman Pizza a Taglio style pizza."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Thats Little Different
"My Pie Pizzeria Romana is listed as a Roman pizza al taglio option in NYC."
NeutralFrom post: Manhattan Pizza Tour My List And Other
"My Pie on 57th and Lex is recommended for Roman-style square slices."
NeutralFrom post: Manhattan Pizza Tour My List And Other
"My Pie on 57th and Lex is recommended for Roman-style square slices."
NeutralFrom post: In Your Opinion Where Is The Best Pizza Bianca In
"This commenter suggested My Pie pizzeria romana, mentioning their potato rosemary slices are similar to Sullivan Street's offerings."
NeutralFrom post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza
"This commenter seconds the recommendation for My Pie."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza
"This commenter enthusiastically affirms the quality of My Pie pizzeria Romana, stating it is "So good!"."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza
"My Pie pizzeria Romana, located at 57th and Lex, is highlighted as a notable remaining pizza a taglio establishment."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Potato Pizza
"My Pie at Lex and 57th offers a potato gorgonzola pizza, which is a recommended option."
Positive