Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (917) 265-8254
Address: 1372 YORK AVENUE 10021
Authentic Edo-style sushi experience. Perfect balance of warm rice & cold fish. BYOB option available.
Tanoshi, the late chef Toshio Oguma's restaurant, serves 'loosey-sushi' with a focus on flavor and texture balance, offering omakase at around $135 with BYOB option.
Nestled in Lenox Hill, this Japanese eatery offers an intimate dining experience centered around expertly crafted omakase. Known for its 'loosey-sushi' approach, the focus is on the perfect balance of flavor and texture in every bite. With limited seating, it provides a personal and authentic taste of traditional sushi.
The sushi here is celebrated for its Edo-style preparation, emphasizing the contrast between warm rice and cool, fresh fish, creating a perfect balance of flavor and texture. It's consistently recommended for its authentic quality.
"The omakase experience is highly recommended, with particular praise for the Edo-style sushi that balances warm rice and cool fish. The salmon belly has been highlighted as a favorite dish."
Customers rave about the authentic, high-quality sushi and the intimate dining experience, often comparing it favorably to more expensive establishments. The BYOB policy is frequently highlighted as a significant plus.
Important Note
The restaurant offers a BYOB (Bring Your Own Bottle) option, which is a unique feature that might appeal to some diners. It is also noted for its intimate setting and limited seating.
"Replying to a query about the omakase experience, the author clarified that while they had no other omakase to compare it to, they enjoyed the intimate setting, the chef preparing each piece individually, and the freshness of the fish."
Positive"This commenter simply stated that Tanoshi Omakase was yummy and a good price."
Positive"The commenter asked what made the omakase experience special beyond the limited seating."
Neutral"For their anniversary, the couple chose Tanoshi Omakase for a special experience. They were seated in a small, intimate space and enjoyed an 8-piece nigiri, maki roll, miso soup, and a special heart-shaped roll. The salmon belly was a favorite, and they found the experience worth the price."
Positive"Tanoshi on the Upper East Side is recommended for a traditional sushi experience reminiscent of Japan, with minimalist decor and a focus on fresh fish. It's BYOB and offers half-off omakase at lunch."
Positive"This user felt Tanoshi on the Upper East Side was comparable to sushi experiences in Tokyo."
Positive"This is a highly recommended omakase restaurant within the specified budget and is known for allowing BYOB."
Positive"A brief mention recommending Tanoshi for an omakase experience."
Positive"The user suggested Tanoshi, located on York Ave."
Neutral"Tanoshi received a second recommendation, with the added benefit of being BYOB and conveniently located near a wine shop."
Positive"Tanoshi was recommended as an omakase option."
Positive"This user recommended Tanoshii Sushi as a place the original poster, who was seeking casual, high-quality, non-omakase sushi, might like."
Positive"The author anticipates that Tanoshi in the UES, a BYOB omakase spot priced at $129, might be recommended by others, though they haven't personally tried it. This is mentioned in a comment suggesting various omakase places."
Neutral"tiggat suggests Tanoshi Sushi Sake on the Upper East Side."
Neutral"Recommends Tanoshi Sushi."
Positive"Tanoshi is the best. It’s simple— Edo-style sushi. The fish is cold, the rice is warm, and every bite is perfect. I took my now-wife there for her birthday years ago, and that meal set the tone for our special occasions ever since. For the past five years, we’ve celebrated with omakase at various spots, some more expensive (some less), but none come close to Tanoshi."
Positive"I feel like either Noz market ordering alacarte or Tenoshi might be good if you happen to be on the UES"
Positive"Tanoshii is excellent. Super authentic and delicious."
Positive"Been to a bunch of sushi spots in the city including heavy hitters like Yoshino. I as well say Tanoshi is definitely up there for a no-frills, high quality experience."
Positive
