Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (929) 337-6385
Address: 110 FRANKLIN STREET 11222
Nostalgic slice shop vibe w/ classic NY pies & unique upside-down Sicilian. Casual, affordable, and lively.
Arden Shore reviews Paulie Gee's Slice Shop, a charming Brooklyn spot with a casual vibe perfect for pizza lovers, highlighting its unique "Freddie Prinze" slice and lively atmosphere.
This Brooklyn pizza joint offers a laid-back, suburban-style pizza parlor experience, complete with TVs and music. It's praised for its classic New York-style and square slices, with the unique 'Freddie Prinze' upside-down Sicilian slice being a standout. While not a destination for pizza purists, it's a reliable and affordable neighborhood spot for casual dining.
Known for classic New York-style and Sicilian slices, this spot offers a casual pizza experience. The 'Freddie Prinze' slice, an upside-down Sicilian with a sesame seed crust, is a recommended highlight. Some customers have found the plain cheese slice bland and noted that quality may have dipped since its opening. Vegan options, such as the vegan Vidalia Sicilian pizza, are also available and generally well-received.
"The 'Freddie Prinze' slice, an upside-down Sicilian with a sesame seed crust, is a highly recommended unique offering. The 'Hellboy' and 'Hellboy Squared' slices are also mentioned positively, as is the vegan Vidalia Sicilian pizza."
Customer sentiment is mixed, with many praising the casual atmosphere and classic slices, while others express disappointment with perceived declines in quality and mention a past health code violation.
Important Note
The restaurant has received a 'C' health inspection rating in the past, and some customers feel the quality has declined since its opening. The plain cheese slice has been described as bland.
"This restaurant is categorized as 'New New York Style,' featuring aspects like extended fermentation, high-quality ingredients, and potentially a mix of oven types. It offers a crispier crust and higher quality toppings."
Positive"The user tried a vegan pepperoni pie from Paulie Gee's Slice Shop but found it to be only decent, feeling they could make something similar at home."
Negative"This user listed Pauly Gee's as a place with vegan pizza/slice options."
Positive"Pauli Gee's Slices is recommended."
Positive"The user acknowledges the negative health inspection rating for Paulie Gee's Slice Shop and decides to remove it from their list."
Neutral"The commenter points out that Paulie Gee's Slice Shop received a C health inspection rating, the lowest possible, and that even before that rating, it was only decent and not worth a special trip."
Negative"The commenter believes Paulie Gee's has fallen off in quality and suggests considering other places instead."
Negative"The commenter suggests grouping pizza places by neighborhood for efficiency, mentioning Williamsburg/Greenpoint as a cluster that would be easier to visit than spread-out locations like Nick's and Di Fara's, and Paulie Gee's Slice Shop."
Neutral"The author states they like Paulie Gee's Slice Shop for pizza, noting that pizza preference is subjective."
Positive"Recommends Paulie Gee’s slice shop in Brooklyn for their vegan Vidalia Sicilian pizza, describing it as quite good and suitable for dairy-free diets."
Positive"Was hugely disappointed by Paulie Gees."
Negative"User looked it up previously and the menu didn't appeal ('didn't sing to me')."
Negative"Thought Paulie Gee's was not superlative, just a middle-of-the-road slice. Suggests better slices available elsewhere in Williamsburg/Greenpoint."
Negative"Recommended as a great pizza option in Greenpoint/Williamsburg. The commenter is partial to it and specifically loves the Hellboy and Hellboy Squared slices."
Positive"Calls it amazing for classic American-style slices."
Positive"User notes concern about Paulie Gee’s slice shop in Greenpoint having a C health rating currently."
Negative"This user hyperbolically states Paulie Gee's existence is 'proof of a loving god'."
Positive
