Detroit-style pizza masters with a polarizing reputation – some love the pies, others find them overrated or poorly executed.
Emmy Squared offers a unique take on pizza, specializing in Detroit-style pies that have garnered a dedicated following. While many rave about the distinct flavor and quality, some diners have found the experience less than satisfactory, citing issues with pizza preparation and an overall feeling of being overrated. The East Village location, in particular, has been mentioned as having closed down.
Emmy Squared is known for its Detroit-style pizza, which is a highlight for many customers. However, there are also reports of undercooked pizzas and a general sentiment from some that the restaurant is overrated. One review specifically mentions a negative experience leading to vomiting.
"While specific dishes aren't highlighted, the Detroit-style pizza is the clear standout and most frequently mentioned item."
Customers have mixed feelings about Emmy Squared. While some praise their Detroit-style pizza and consider it a favorite, others find the restaurant overrated and have had negative experiences with undercooked pizza. There's also a comment suggesting the East Village location has closed.
Important Note
The East Village location of Emmy Squared has reportedly closed down.
"Garconavecunreve suggests getting a slice from EV Pizza in the East Village and then heading to a nearby bar."
Positive"Emmy Squared is noted to have closed down and been replaced by a weed store, implying it's no longer an option for pizza."
Negative"Recounts extremely negative experiences at the Emmy Squared East Village location: one visit allegedly caused vomiting, another time the pizza was undercooked and discarded."
Negative"Agreeing it's overrated, this user notes Emily serves Detroit-style pizza."
Negative"This commenter loves Emmy's / Emily's, while acknowledging they are not 'by the slice' places."
Positive"This commenter considers Emily overrated and New Park Pizza underrated."
Negative
