Artisanal ice cream with wildly inventive flavors and legendary mint chip.
Experience inventive and artisanal ice cream flavors that are anything but ordinary. Known for its creative and sometimes daring concoctions, this spot offers a delightful escape for dessert enthusiasts. From classic favorites with a twist to unique seasonal offerings, every scoop promises a memorable culinary adventure.
This ice cream shop is celebrated for its artisanal approach, offering a wide array of creative and often surprising flavors. Customers frequently recommend the mint chip, and rave about unique offerings like pistachio soft serve, creamsicle with tangerine cotton candy, and even coffee and pumpkin flavors. While specific dishes to avoid aren't mentioned, the overall feedback focuses on the success of their inventive flavor combinations.
"Customers highly recommend the mint chip ice cream. Other praised flavors include pistachio soft serve, and inventive options like coffee and pumpkin."
Customers consistently praise the unique and high-quality ice cream flavors, highlighting both inventive creations and well-executed classics.
Important Note
The restaurant is noted for its highly inventive and sometimes unusual flavors, which might not appeal to all palates. One particularly unique flavor, 'Breast Milk Ice Cream,' was clarified to not be made from human breast milk.
"This ice cream shop is recommended as an option in DUMBO."
Positive"OddFellows is mentioned as another good option for pistachio soft serve. The author also fondly remembers a creamsicle soft serve with tangerine cotton candy from a past pop-up at Chef's Club in SoHo and finds their coffee and pumpkin flavors amazing."
Positive"The post author fondly recalls Oddfellows' early days when it was a single location with a pastry chef creating highly inventive, limited-quantity ice cream flavors, comparing them to restaurant dessert menu items."
Positive"Mint Chip is my number one favorite ice cream flavor... I enjoy Oddfellows"
Positive
