Casual, group-friendly Italian in Tribeca w/ a long history. Known for comforting dishes & a welcoming vibe.
This Italian eatery in Tribeca offers a casual yet refined dining experience, perfect for groups seeking authentic flavors. With a history stretching back to the East Village, it has evolved into a popular spot known for its comforting dishes and welcoming atmosphere. While some diners recall its earlier iterations, the current location maintains a reputation for quality Italian cuisine.
The restaurant is celebrated for its Italian cuisine, with a particular nostalgic mention of its meatloaf. While the current Tribeca location is perceived as fancier than its East Village predecessor, the overall feedback points to a satisfying and authentic Italian dining experience suitable for various occasions.
"The meatloaf at Max is highly praised, with one commenter even basing their personal recipe on it."
Customers generally have positive sentiment, often recommending it for group gatherings and appreciating its authentic Italian offerings. Some nostalgia exists for its previous locations and a more 'hole-in-the-wall' feel.
Important Note
One user mentioned regretting visiting the restaurant just before it closed permanently, implying potential closure.
"The user regrets going to Max just before it closed permanently."
Negative"The author fondly recalls Max as a "great" place and also mentions "Max Too" which opened on Amsterdam and 120th."
Positive"The author adds that Max was situated on Duane Street for about six years, noting its relatively recent relocation."
Neutral"The author recalls Max being on Duane Street 5-10 years ago, next to Staple Street, and that its former location was a "hole in the wall," potentially matching the original poster's description."
Neutral"The author states that Max was located on Duane Street about five years ago before it moved to its current Tribeca spot."
Neutral"The author expresses missing Max and reveals that their personal meatloaf recipe is based on the version they used to eat at the restaurant."
Positive"The author clarifies that their initial suggestion of Max was referring to its older location on Avenue B, not the newer Tribeca location."
Neutral"The original poster notes that the current iteration of Max does not match their memory of the restaurant's layout (e.g., no upstairs/split level), but they find the menu appealing."
Neutral"The author suggests Max, a small and unpretentious restaurant they knew from the East Village (mid 90s-2003), though it has since moved to Tribeca and appears fancier. They are unsure if it's the restaurant the original poster is thinking of."
Neutral"Recommends Max in TriBeca."
Positive"Recommends Max's in Tribeca, describing it as a casual but very good Italian option for a large group."
Positive
