TLDR
A classic, casual Italian spot in Tribeca, ideal for groups. This long-standing NYC favorite offers a solid meal with a history of beloved dishes.
Details
Max Restaurant in Tribeca offers a casual yet quality Italian dining experience, suitable for groups. While some long-time patrons recall its earlier, perhaps more unpretentious, iterations, the current Tribeca location is noted for its more upscale appearance. It's a place with a history, having been a beloved spot in the East Village and on Duane Street before its move.
Food Overview
This Italian restaurant is recognized as a good, casual option, particularly for groups. While specific dishes aren't frequently highlighted, one user fondly remembers the meatloaf, using it as the basis for their own recipe. The restaurant has a history, with patrons recalling different versions of it over the years, including a past location that was considered a 'hole in the wall'.
Caveats
One user noted that the restaurant has close table arrangements. Another user expressed regret about visiting just before it permanently closed.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MAX RESTAURANT
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Maxes Or Au Cheval
"This user described Max as 'totally fine, but not a destination place'."
NeutralFrom post: Maxes Or Au Cheval
"This user described Max as a 'lovely, modest Italian restaurant', but considered Au Cheval more distinctive."
NeutralFrom post: Maxes Or Au Cheval
"This user recommended Au Cheval over Max in Tribeca."
NegativeFrom post: Recommendations For Tribeca Area Spots For Dinner
"Max Restaurant is mentioned as another restaurant option in addition to Chambers and Frenchette."
NeutralFrom post: Recommendations For Tribeca Area Spots For Dinner
"Max Restaurant is listed as a dining option in the Tribeca area."
NeutralFrom post: Best Lasagna In Nyc
"This user recommended Max in Tribeca."
PositiveFrom post: At What Point Are Tables Too Close To Each Other
"Max Restaurant in Tribeca is called out for its close table arrangements."
NegativeFrom post: Restaurant Regrets Ive Had A Few
"The user regrets going to Max just before it closed permanently."
NegativeFrom post: Looking For A Restaurant I Once Ate At
"The author fondly recalls Max as a "great" place and also mentions "Max Too" which opened on Amsterdam and 120th."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Restaurant I Once Ate At
"The author adds that Max was situated on Duane Street for about six years, noting its relatively recent relocation."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For A Restaurant I Once Ate At
"The author recalls Max being on Duane Street 5-10 years ago, next to Staple Street, and that its former location was a "hole in the wall," potentially matching the original poster's description."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For A Restaurant I Once Ate At
"The author states that Max was located on Duane Street about five years ago before it moved to its current Tribeca spot."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For A Restaurant I Once Ate At
"The author expresses missing Max and reveals that their personal meatloaf recipe is based on the version they used to eat at the restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Restaurant I Once Ate At
"The author clarifies that their initial suggestion of Max was referring to its older location on Avenue B, not the newer Tribeca location."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For A Restaurant I Once Ate At
"The original poster notes that the current iteration of Max does not match their memory of the restaurant's layout (e.g., no upstairs/split level), but they find the menu appealing."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For A Restaurant I Once Ate At
"The author suggests Max, a small and unpretentious restaurant they knew from the East Village (mid 90s-2003), though it has since moved to Tribeca and appears fancier. They are unsure if it's the restaurant the original poster is thinking of."
Neutral