TLDR
Stunning skyscraper views paired with an inventive, multi-course tasting menu. A premier choice for romantic milestones and high-end celebrations.
Instagram Posts References
Saga NYC, led by executive chef Charlie Mitchell, offers a unique and elevated potato salad as part of its 10-course tasting menu. This rendition of the classic dish features a sophisticated blend of almonds, capers, lemon, chives, a white-verjus sabayon, and caviar, all presented in a handcrafted German porcelain bowl. The dish is designed to evoke a sense of familiarity while offering an entirely new culinary experience, reflecting the chef's philosophy of transforming comforting, home-style food into a fine-dining luxury.
Details
Perched on the 63rd floor of an Art Deco skyscraper, this two-Michelin-starred destination offers an immersive, multi-course tasting experience defined by sweeping city views [1], [2]. While the menu features creative reinterpretations of American flavors, such as a sophisticated potato salad with caviar, reactions to the food and value are mixed [2], [3], [4]. The atmosphere is undeniably romantic and high-end, making it a favored spot for celebrations despite potential concerns regarding the lengthy meal duration [1], [2], [5].
Food Overview
The restaurant serves a high-end, seasonal tasting menu featuring American-influenced dishes such as Hokkaido scallop, Australian lamb, and an innovative potato salad with caviar [1], [2], [4]. While some guests find the courses spectacular, others have noted inconsistent seasoning or balance across dishes like the madai or lamb, and some specific items like lychee rolls have received negative feedback [4], [5].
Highlights include the meticulously prepared potato salad with caviar [4] and the scallop with morels and white asparagus [5].
Diners consistently praise the breathtaking views and lush ambiance, though feedback regarding the food's value and meal duration varies significantly [2], [5]. While many view it as an exceptional, one-of-a-kind experience, others find the long, multi-hour format less suitable for casual or business-oriented dinners [5].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01lychee rolls2 mentions
- 02potato salad2 mentions
Caveats
The tasting menu experience can extend beyond four hours, which some diners find overly long and potentially unsuitable for business-focused meetings [5]. Costs can easily exceed $400 per person when factoring in wine pairings or extra drinks, which some patrons feel does not always align with the overall culinary impact [4], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SAGA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: I Visited Over 30 Bars On My Nyc Trip Heres A
"Mentioned as a very high-end, two-Michelin-star restaurant owned by the same group as Overstory."
PositiveFrom post: Peak Vs Manhatta For A Romantic Dinner With A
"The commenter suggests Saga as another great dining option."
PositiveFrom post: Solo Tasting Menu With Great Cocktails In
"The user had a positive experience with the non-alcoholic drink pairing, though they noted it might feel intimidating and could exceed the user's budget."
PositiveFrom post: Saga Crown Shy By James Kent Rip July 2026
"The reviewer had a mixed experience with the high-end meal; while some dishes like the scallop and dessert were spectacular, others were criticized for balance or spice levels. The service was described as average."
PositiveFrom post: Gift Certificate To A Highend Restaurant
"Directly recommended as a high-end option."
Positive