KOLOMAN RESTAURANT & LOBBY BAR (in ACE Hotel New York)
Updated
Phone: (212) 790-8970
Address: 16 WEST 29 STREET 10001
TLDR
Renowned for their brilliant celery root tartare and classic Viennese schnitzel, this spot balances upscale French-Austrian fare with a modern, non-pretentious vibe.
Reddit Sentiment for KOLOMAN RESTAURANT & LOBBY BAR (in ACE Hotel New York)(based on 16 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Chef Markus Glocker's restaurant, Koloman NYC, is closing its current location within the Ace Hotel New York at 29th Street and Broadway by the end of September. The restaurant has announced plans to relocate to a new space in the NoHo neighborhood.
Amber Sutherland-Namako reviews Koloman, a restaurant in Manhattan's Ace Hotel, finding it to be a "pretty good" but uneven experience with standout gougères and schnitzel, but less successful terrine and mushroom dishes.
Details
Located within the Ace Hotel, this spot offers a modern, bright setting for French and Austrian-inspired cuisine [1]. While it has garnered consistent recognition on the NYT Top 100 list and a Michelin selection [2], the overall dining experience remains a topic of mixed feedback [1]. Patrons are often polarized by the atmosphere, which has been described as exceptionally loud in its previous location [3].
Food Overview
The menu leans heavily into Austrian and French traditions, with the celery root tartare widely hailed as a brilliant, must-try dish [4]. While the schnitzel Viennoise and gougères receive high praise for their expert preparation [1], other offerings like the trumpet mushrooms and short rib terrine have been criticized as underwhelming or one-dimensional [1].
Caveats
Patrons should be aware that the restaurant has faced consistent feedback regarding its loud, challenging acoustics [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About KOLOMAN RESTAURANT & LOBBY BAR (in ACE Hotel New York)
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: New York Times Top 100 Restaurants X Michelin
"Koloman is listed on the NYT top 100 list for 2023, 2024, and 2025, with a Michelin selection."
NeutralFrom post: Esterhazy Torte
"The user confirmed that Koloman used to serve Esterhazy Torte, in response to a question about its availability in NYC."
NeutralFrom post: Esterhazy Torte
"This user mentioned that Kolomon offered Esterhazy Torte before it closed last year. The mention was in response to a query about finding the cake in NYC."
NeutralFrom post: What Are The Loudest Restaurants In Nyc
"Koloman was immediately off-puttingly loud upon entry, with the noise level being the only memorable aspect of the experience, leading to no return visit. The user hopes their new space has better acoustics."
NegativeFrom post: What Are The Loudest Restaurants In Nyc
"Koloman was immediately off-puttingly loud upon entry, with the noise level being the only memorable aspect of the experience, leading to no return visit. The user hopes their new space has better acoustics."
NegativeFrom post: My 35th Birthday This Year Falls On Rosh Hashanah
"Koloman is suggested as a potential dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Perhaps A Ignorant Question But Can Anyone
"Koloman is listed as a recommendation for good food, although its chef previously had a star at Batard and the restaurant itself does not currently have one. The user notes it is not pretentious."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favourite Beef Tartare
"This user agrees that Koloman's celery root tartare is brilliant, even for a meat lover."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favourite Beef Tartare
"This user agrees that Koloman's celery root tartare is brilliant, even for a meat lover."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favourite Beef Tartare
"This user agrees that Koloman's celery root tartare is brilliant, even for a meat lover."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favourite Beef Tartare
"This user agrees that Koloman's celery root tartare is brilliant, even for a meat lover."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favourite Beef Tartare
"Koloman is recommended for its celery root tartare, which the user found brilliant."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favourite Beef Tartare
"Koloman is recommended for its celery root tartare, which the user found brilliant."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favourite Beef Tartare
"Koloman is recommended for its celery root tartare, which the user found brilliant."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favourite Beef Tartare
"Koloman is recommended for its celery root tartare, which the user found brilliant."
Positive