Next.js logo

CAFFE PANNA

Updated

Phone: (917) 363-0207

Address: 77 IRVING PLACE 10003

TLDR

A viral destination for innovative gelato-ice cream hybrids, featuring creative daily sundaes and a signature light Italian whipped cream that draws long queues.

Reddit Sentiment for CAFFE PANNA(based on 304 Reddit opinions)

51% Positive36% Neutral13% Negative

Reddit Sentiment Over Time

Unique Posts Over Time

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo
Achievement logo

Tags

italian 22american 7dessert 6ice cream 211dessert 30soft serve 20View All

Neighborhoods

Gramercy

Instagram Posts References

The creator features Caffe Panna's Chocolate Turtle ice cream as a key component of his humorous 'El Niño diet'. He explicitly shows and eats the ice cream, expressing clear enjoyment and satisfaction. The product, labeled as 'Typical Butterfield Pint Ice Cream' by Caffe Panna, is the main culinary highlight of the post.

This post features members of the bigbackrunclub.nyc after their first long run, with Caffe Panna as their celebratory destination. The group is seen posing outside the establishment and enjoying various desserts. The sign above the entrance clearly indicates Caffe Panna and lists offerings such as sundaes, coffee, espresso, panna, granita, and affogatos. The image captures the positive and communal spirit of the running club enjoying their post-run treats.

Caffe Panna is celebrated as a viral hotspot for its exceptional ice cream, especially its decadent soft-serve creations. The image features a rich soft-serve topped generously with crushed Oreos and whole Oreo cookies, illustrating the shop's emphasis on indulgent, high-quality ingredients and creative flavor combinations that resonate with a wide audience.

Caffè Panna is an ice cream shop in New York City known for its artisanal ice creams and sundaes, often featuring unique and limited-edition collaborations. The reviewer visited for a special Laab Bar Coconut Sticky Rice Sundae, which combines mango ice cream, mango coulis, coconut caramel panna, toasted coconut, and a coconut sticky rice arancini. Despite arriving early, the line grew significantly, indicating the shop's popularity. The main sundae components were enjoyed for their vibrant flavors, but a specific component, the arancini, did not fare well when cold.

Caffè Panna is an ice cream shop in New York City renowned for its artisanal ice cream and creative, often limited-time, sundae specials. This post specifically highlights their popular sticky rice sundae, which appears to be a collaboration or inspired by Laab Bar, a Lao/Thai restaurant. The sundae features a base of mango ice cream, generously topped with whipped cream and distinctive coconut-flavored, perfectly fried sticky rice balls that are praised for being non-greasy. The popularity of such unique specials frequently leads to long queues, which the creator gladly endured, finding the dessert to be entirely worth the wait.

Caffe Panna is featured for its PB&J sundae, suggesting a creative and delicious dessert that reinterprets a classic American flavor combination.

This establishment is recommended as part of the GoCity New York Mini Guide for its authentic Italian gelato.

Caffe Panna is celebrated for serving the "BEST dessert" the reviewer has had in NYC. The pistachio passionfruit sundae is specifically highlighted for its unique and "wonderful blend of sweetness, creaminess, and nuttiness," indicating a highly memorable and satisfying dessert experience.

Caffe Panna is an ice cream shop located in Gramercy, known for its unique and frequently changing special sundaes and soft serves. The establishment garners significant attention, drawing long lines of patrons eager to try their offerings. The post specifically highlights the Tiramisu soft serve, praising it as light and refreshing, and also visually features a Saffron Passion Pistachio Sundae and a custom-made cup. It's considered one of the best ice cream shops in New York City.

Caffe Panna is an ice cream shop featured by Butterfield Market in this post, highlighting its unique and classic ice cream flavors. The star is the seasonal "Sweet Corn Pretzel" ice cream, which blends fresh sweet corn with housemade pretzel brittle, creating a delightful sweet and salty combination. Butterfield Market proudly carries this exclusive flavor as well as several of Caffe Panna's well-loved classic ice cream options.

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
Your Guide to the Best NYC Summer Restaurants and Bars
positive

Don't miss the incredible gelato at Caffè Panna, known for its unique sundae toppings like olive oil and mango coconut sticky rice.

Willa MooreMay 18, 2026
Read More →
Infatuation
Mentioned In
The Best Ice Cream Shops in New York City

Caffè Panna is renowned for its seasonal ice creams and sundaes, often Rome-inspired, drawing crowds since its opening. With offerings like affogato sundaes and daily scoop selections, the shop, named after its signature Italian whipped cream, is a must-visit.

The InfatuationMay 6, 2026

Details

Renowned for its unique gelato-ice cream hybrid texture and high-quality, seasonal ingredients [1], this spot has become a viral destination in Manhattan [2]. The menu features creative sundaes and rotating daily scoop selections, often highlighted by a signature light Italian whipped cream known as 'panna' [3]. While it consistently earns top-tier status among ice cream enthusiasts [4], it remains a polarizing figure due to long queues and frequent sell-outs [5].

Food Overview

The menu focuses on a unique hybrid between gelato and ice cream with a rich, high-quality base [1]. Popular items include the 'Cookies N' Panna' flavor [6], various limited-edition sundaes [3], and creative soft serve offerings [2], though some users find certain flavors overly sweet [7].

Highlights / Recommended

"Highly praised items include the 'Cookies N' Panna' [6], the 'PB&J' pint [9], and seasonal specials like the 'passionfruit olive oil' soft serve [10]."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • ice cream(3)
  • rainbow cookie(3)
  • red flag(3)
  • strawberry crème pie soft serve(3)
  • soft serve creation(3)
  • caffe biano stracciatella(2)
  • soft serve(2)
  • golden oreo carrot cake(2)
  • golden oreo soft serve(2)
  • pb&j pint(2)

Customer Sentiment

Sentiment is heavily polarized; while many hail it as the best ice cream in the city [4], others find it overhyped, overpriced, or occasionally inconsistent [5].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About CAFFE PANNA

A deep dive into why this shop maintains such high quality, focusing on the owner's extensive experimentation with ingredients and flavor science.
A crowd-sourced thread of favorites, highlighting creative hits like 'Banana Tracks' and the 'PB&J' pint.
A debate thread regarding the shop's value and experience, touching on the removal of seating at the Gramercy location.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"The user's favorite is the 'blue berry pancake sundae' which was a collaboration with Clinton St."

Positive
Jun 18, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Expressed a negative opinion, stating 'Don't care for them.'"

Negative
Jun 18, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Really enjoys the 'sungold sundae' and is looking forward to tomato season, implying it might be a seasonal or tomato-based offering."

Positive
Jun 18, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Considers 'PB Cornberry' top-tier and also liked the 'Caits Key Lime' collaboration."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Gave a general positive response, stating 'like, all of them'."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Highly recommends the coffee ice cream with Oreo brittle, calling it 'so good'."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Agrees that Malai is great and also has excellent soft serve."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"In response to a comment about an Indian-inspired ice cream, this user recommended Malai, an Indian ice cream place on Smith Street."

Neutral
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Strongly recommends 'BANANA TRACKS!!!', describing it as their best flavor ever, comparable to classic Moose Tracks but with banana ice cream, and thinks about it weekly."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Mentions the 'chocolate chip cookie sandwich' as a favorite."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Also had the 'PB&J' pint in May and found it 'unbelievably good'."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Recalls a 'Peanut butter oatmeal cookie' flavor with M&Ms as their first experience and the best ice cream they've had, hoping for its return."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"In response to the Golden Oreo soft serve, this user mentioned it was available in Greenpoint recently."

Neutral
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Inquired if the discussion about wait times was referring to the Caffe Panna location near Casa Mono in Gramercy."

Neutral
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Simply stated 'Rainbow cookie' as a favorite."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Found the 'rainbow cookie' and 'cookies and cream' flavors to be awesome."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Agrees that the 'Red Flag' flavor is their absolute favorite."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"Had a 'PB&J' pint recently that was 'insanely good'."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"The user still fantasizes about a past 'Hummingbird Cake' flavor and also enjoys the 'Cinnamon Toast Crunch'."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Have Been Your Favorite Caffe Panna

"The user generally doesn't prefer their pints but enjoyed a past Indian chef collaboration with mango ice cream and spiced mango sorbet. They also like the soft serve and granita with panna at the Greenpoint location, suggesting trying the granita if one likes the fruit."

Positive
Jun 17, 2026View Comment →