Artisanal ice cream with unique textures & flavors. Highly praised, worth the wait.
Caffe Panna is a highly acclaimed ice cream shop in NYC, known for its unique textures and inventive flavors. The establishment draws consistent praise for its artisanal approach, with many customers declaring it among their favorite ice cream experiences. Despite some minor quibbles about sweetness or availability, the overall consensus is that Caffe Panna offers a truly memorable dessert.
Caffe Panna is celebrated for its high-quality, artisanal ice cream with a texture described as between gelato and ice cream. Popular flavors include 'Cookies N' Panna,' 'Salted Malt Chocolate,' and various seasonal specials like 'Sweet Corn Pretzel.' While most reviews are glowing, a few note that some flavors can be overly sweet or that certain desirable flavors sell out quickly.
"Popular recommended dishes include 'Cookies N' Panna,' 'Salted Malt Chocolate,' 'Dubai chocolate ice cream,' 'Peanut Butter Affogato,' and various seasonal specials."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards Caffe Panna, often describing the ice cream as exceptional and worth waiting in line for. Some minor criticisms include occasional flavor availability issues or a perception that certain flavors can be too sweet or rich.
Important Note
Some customers find certain flavors too sweet or rich, and popular flavors can sell out quickly. One user mentioned a negative experience with melted ice cream.
"The author finds Caffe Panna's soft serve too thick and creamy for their preference, preferring their granita instead and noting a Brooklyn location."
Negative"Caffe Panna is mentioned for offering various pecan flavors, including Cinnamon Sour Cherry Pecan soft serve and Butter Pecan ice cream. They also had a lychee sundae with pecan praline ganache and a Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie Affogato Sundae."
Positive"This user suggested getting pints of ice cream from Caffe Panna using the lunch budget."
Positive"The user mentioned that Caffe Panna is a good option for dessert after visiting Rule of Thirds."
Positive"This commenter finds Caffe Panna's ice cream to be gourmet and comparable to high-end Blizzards, expressing a strong desire for it."
Positive"The commenter mentions that Caffe Panna often has coffee-based daily ice cream flavors and always offers caffe biano stracciatella, describing it as the best hard-serve ice cream."
Positive"Caffe Panna is listed as a place to get soft serve."
Neutral"The commenter mentioned Caffe Panna as an example of a high-end ice cream shop with similar pricing to Nun Left, stating their pints cost $14."
Positive"The commenter expressed a preference for Caffe Panna over Nun Left, noting that Caffe Panna's pints are priced at $14."
Positive"This commenter stated that Caffe Panna is worth the hype, especially for dessert."
Positive"The commenter intends to have a scoop of every flavor from Cafe Panna as part of their final meal, following a meal at Don Pepe."
Positive"The commenter has not tried the soft serve at Caffe Panna but is curious to hear others' opinions."
Neutral"The commenter prefers Seed+Mill, Cafe Panna, or Dolly's over Hani's for the price, suggesting these are better value options."
Positive"The commenter mentions Cafe Panna as an amazing ice cream spot, suggesting ordering ahead to avoid lines on hot days."
Positive"User is a big fan of Caffe Panna's granita, even preferring it over their ice cream."
Positive"Finds Van Leeuwen mediocre compared to Caffe Panna, Morgenstern's, and Salt & Straw, though acknowledges Van Leeuwen is still enjoyable."
Neutral"Strongly disagrees with the praise for Caffe Panna, finding it too sweet and not among their top five ice cream shops."
Negative"Caffè Panna was recommended for its gelato."
Positive"Reiterates their preference for flavors and mix-ins in ice cream, stating that while they appreciate quality, taste is paramount for them."
Neutral"Acknowledges their preference for mix-ins and plans to try Caffe Panna again due to friends' recommendations."
Neutral
