Artisanal gelato & ice cream w/ inventive flavors & unique sundaes. A must-try NYC dessert spot!
This Italian-inspired ice cream shop is a beloved spot in NYC, known for its artisanal creations and decadent sundaes. With a reputation for high-quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations, it consistently draws crowds eager to try their offerings, from classic gelato to inventive soft serves. While many consider it a top-tier dessert destination, some find the experience, particularly the pricing and occasional inconsistencies, less remarkable.
Caffe Panna is celebrated for its artisanal ice cream, gelato, and creative sundaes, often featuring unique flavors and high-quality ingredients [1, 2]. Popular recommendations include the 'Cookies N' Panna' flavor [3], the 'Affogato' [4], and various seasonal specials like 'Sweet Corn Pretzel' [5] and 'Laab Bar Coconut Sticky Rice Sundae' [6]. While many users consider it the best ice cream they've ever had, some find it too sweet, rich, or inconsistent, with occasional criticisms about flavor balance and mix-in quantity [7, 8, 9].
"The 'Cookies N' Panna' flavor is frequently highlighted as a must-try. Additionally, unique and seasonal specials like the 'Sweet Corn Pretzel' ice cream and various inventive sundaes are highly recommended by patrons."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Caffe Panna for its exceptional, high-quality ice cream and unique flavors, with many considering it a top-tier dessert destination. However, a minority find it overhyped, overpriced, or inconsistent, leading to mixed but generally positive sentiment.
Important Note
Some users have noted that Caffe Panna can have long lines, and certain popular flavors may sell out quickly. Additionally, one user criticized the business model for lacking samples and the inability to take pints to go without committing to a flavor. The Gramercy location has removed its tables and seats, and the Brooklyn location has limited seating.
"The reviewer expressed strong enthusiasm, stating they would visit every single day if possible, and gave it a perfect score of 10."
Positive"This user suggests Panna for ice cream."
Positive"This user suggests Panna for ice cream."
Positive"This user commented that Caffe Panna is the only place they've found in the city for soft serve ice cream that isn't too sweet."
Positive"This user suggested Caffe Panna's ice cream as a worthwhile NYC treat."
Positive"Responding to uncertainty about the flavor, this user acknowledges the Instagram post stated it was strawberry, but agrees the picture looked 'very blonde'."
Neutral"This user looked up the Caffe Panna special and found it looked delicious, but the picture seemed to show vanilla soft serve instead of strawberry."
Neutral"This user shared an announcement that Caffe Panna had Strawberry Crème Pie soft serve available for a limited time (Wednesday & Thursday). The description details strawberry soft serve with pie crust and panna."
Positive"This user added a positive vote for Caffe Panna."
Positive"This user suggested Caffe Panna as a replacement for Levain Bakery for those seeking sweets."
Positive"This user apologized for potentially misinterpreting the previous comment, explaining the confusion with the two Morgenstern's locations. They also noted Caffe Panna's use of premium ingredients, including imported Italian cream."
Neutral"The user clarified they were referring to Morgenstern's BANANAS, not the closed Morgenstern's, and questioned the aggressive tone of the previous commenter."
Neutral"The Brooklyn location of Caffe Panna has very few seats, but it is still considered worth the visit."
Positive"This is a straightforward recommendation for Caffe Panna as a dessert choice."
Positive"This user questioned if Morgensterns was still open, implying the previous recommendation might be misinformed."
Neutral"Despite claims of high quality, this user found Caffe Panna's dessert inedible and recommended Morgensterns for ice cream."
Negative"The Gramercy location of Caffe Panna has gotten rid of its tables and seats, which is considered an unfortunate change."
Negative"This user strongly criticized another user's negative take on Caffe Panna, calling it the 'worst take' and stating the user knows 'absolutely nothing about food or ingredient quality'."
Negative"This user countered the negative opinion on Caffe Panna's quality, asserting that they use high-quality ingredients and are respected by culinary experts, not just influencers. They also mentioned that Caffe Panna often features mix-ins from other local bakeries."
Positive"This user strongly disagreed with the quality of Caffe Panna, attributing its reputation to Instagram rather than actual taste, and suggested Morgensterns for ice cream instead."
Negative
