Best gelato & ice cream w/ unique flavors & panna topping. Expect lines, but worth it!
This charming Italian dessert spot is a must-visit for ice cream aficionados, consistently drawing crowds for its artisanal creations. With a reputation for excellence, it's a place that inspires passionate debate among locals, with many hailing it as the best in the city. Its dedication to high-quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations ensures a memorable experience, even if it means a bit of a wait.
This Italian ice cream shop is renowned for its high-quality, artisanal ice cream and gelato. Praised for its unique flavor combinations and rich texture, it consistently receives rave reviews, with many considering it the best in NYC. Popular choices include the "Cookies N' Panna" and various seasonal specials. Some customers, however, find certain flavors too sweet or overly rich, and a few have expressed disappointment with mix-in quantities or perceived value.
"Customers highly recommend trying flavors like 'Cookies N' Panna,' 'Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Infused Ice Cream,' and seasonal specials. The 'Panna' topping is also frequently mentioned as a highlight that enhances the ice cream experience."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the exceptional quality and unique flavors of the ice cream, often describing it as the best they've ever had. However, some find the establishment overrated or too expensive, and a few have noted issues with service or flavor availability.
Important Note
The Gramercy location has removed most of its seating, making it primarily a grab-and-go spot. Flavors can sell out quickly, and there can be long lines, especially during peak times.
"This user added a positive vote for Caffe Panna."
Positive"This user suggested Caffe Panna as a replacement for Levain Bakery for those seeking sweets."
Positive"This user apologized for potentially misinterpreting the previous comment, explaining the confusion with the two Morgenstern's locations. They also noted Caffe Panna's use of premium ingredients, including imported Italian cream."
Neutral"The user clarified they were referring to Morgenstern's BANANAS, not the closed Morgenstern's, and questioned the aggressive tone of the previous commenter."
Neutral"The Brooklyn location of Caffe Panna has very few seats, but it is still considered worth the visit."
Positive"This is a straightforward recommendation for Caffe Panna as a dessert choice."
Positive"This user questioned if Morgensterns was still open, implying the previous recommendation might be misinformed."
Neutral"Despite claims of high quality, this user found Caffe Panna's dessert inedible and recommended Morgensterns for ice cream."
Negative"The Gramercy location of Caffe Panna has gotten rid of its tables and seats, which is considered an unfortunate change."
Negative"This user strongly criticized another user's negative take on Caffe Panna, calling it the 'worst take' and stating the user knows 'absolutely nothing about food or ingredient quality'."
Negative"This user countered the negative opinion on Caffe Panna's quality, asserting that they use high-quality ingredients and are respected by culinary experts, not just influencers. They also mentioned that Caffe Panna often features mix-ins from other local bakeries."
Positive"This user strongly disagreed with the quality of Caffe Panna, attributing its reputation to Instagram rather than actual taste, and suggested Morgensterns for ice cream instead."
Negative"The user clarified that at 8:30 pm, only vanilla, chocolate, and 'red flag' flavors were left at Caffe Panna, and the 'red flag' was found to be inedible."
Negative"The Brooklyn location of Caffe Panna has seating, but the Gramercy location does not."
Neutral"A user questioned the claim that Caffe Panna was 'all sold out'."
Neutral"A user inquired about seating at Caffe Panna, noting that the Gramercy location used to have a decent amount of tables inside."
Neutral"In response to a negative review, this user defended Caffe Panna, stating it's regarded as one of the top ice cream shops in the country and they've never experienced a lack of quality in over 20 visits."
Positive"A user had a very negative experience at Caffe Panna, stating they waited in line, found the remaining items overpriced and gross, and advised against wasting time there."
Negative"This is a dessert place that is not a sit-down establishment, located near Union Square. The Gramercy location has removed its tables and seats, while the Brooklyn location has very few."
Neutral"This commenter finds Caffè Panna's flavors too sweet and rich, often unable to finish a cup, suggesting they aren't a fan of the specific flavor profiles offered."
Negative
