Decadent, inventive ice cream & soft serve w/ unique seasonal flavors & mix-ins. A must-try NYC dessert destination.
This beloved ice cream parlor is a go-to spot for unique and creative flavors, often featuring seasonal specials that keep customers coming back. Patrons rave about the silky texture and inventive mix-ins, with many considering it among the best ice cream experiences in the city. The establishment's dedication to high-quality ingredients and artisanal craftsmanship is evident in every scoop.
Caffe Panna is celebrated for its artisanal ice cream and soft serve, with a strong emphasis on creative flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients. Popular choices include the 'Cookies N' Panna' and various seasonal specials, like the 'Sungold tomato sundae.' While most reviews are glowing, a few users have expressed a preference for different flavor profiles or noted issues with mix-in distribution in certain flavors.
"Customers highly recommend trying unique flavors like 'Cookies N' Panna,' 'Dubai chocolate ice cream,' and the seasonal specials. The 'Salted Malt Chocolate Pint' and 'Peanut Butter Affogato' have also received specific praise."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the exceptional quality and unique flavors of the ice cream, often calling it the best they've ever had. Some minor critiques mention occasional inconsistencies in mix-ins or a preference for different flavor profiles.
Important Note
Some users have noted that certain flavors can sell out quickly, and a few have expressed that the ice cream can be overly sweet for their preference. There have also been comments about the business model, including the lack of samples and seating.
"In response to where to check for flavor drops, this commenter advised checking Caffe Panna's Instagram story daily."
Neutral"In response to a question about where to check for flavor drops, this commenter asked for the best place to look."
Neutral"The commenter loves the 'Panna Sky' flavor and mentioned that they live near the Grand Prix location, allowing them to be 'spoiled'. They advise pre-ordering due to frequent sell-outs, citing personal experiences of missing out."
Positive"The commenter was disappointed after ordering the 'levain BW collab' pint, only to find out it was oversold and they did not receive it, with no refund provided."
Negative"In response to a question about apple flavors, the commenter recalled that Caffe Panna had an 'apple crisp' pint last October and a 'Vanilla Apple Pie' pint the year before in late September."
Neutral"The commenter found the raspberry white chocolate flavor to be very good. They also mentioned appreciating some apple flavors from Salt & Straw."
Positive"Replying to a query about apple flavors, this commenter recommended the 'vanilla apple tart' from Salt & Straw as a good option."
Positive"The commenter's favorite is the 'Snickers flavor, Hungry?', but they were disappointed by the 'Chocolate ranger fudge' and 'Chocolate covered strawberry' flavors."
Neutral"Any creamsicle flavor is a favorite for this commenter, highlighting the 'orange dreamsicle' flavor from winter as a revelation."
Positive"In reply to a comment about golden oreo carrot cake, this commenter expressed strong interest and asked about the frequency of its return."
Positive"The commenter expressed envy towards those who can eat ice cream frequently enough to have specific favorite pints, referencing their own metabolism."
Neutral"The commenter is actively looking for any apple-flavored pints, checking daily. They have no specific knowledge of apple flavors existing or their quality but are hopeful."
Neutral"The commenter states that the 'lemon meringue pie' flavor is an immediate purchase for them every time it's available."
Positive"The 'Pain au chocolat' flavor is noted as a must-have, although it frequently sells out."
Positive"The commenter highly recommended the 'Chocolate croissant' flavor, specifically mentioning the chocolate batons within the croissant ice cream as being 'insane'."
Positive"The commenter expressed a strong liking for a combination of smooth peanut butter ice cream and Oreo brittle."
Positive"The commenter considers the 'Chipside Out' flavor a repeat buy, highlighting its unique salted chocolate base with white chocolate coated potato chips and dark chocolate chunks. They were particularly impressed by the saltiness enhancing the overall flavor."
Positive"The commenter found the 'rold gold' flavor to be awful and could not finish the pint."
Negative"This commenter finds the ice cream pints too sweet but highly praises the soft serve with sea salt and olive oil, describing it as a divine experience."
Positive"The commenter considers the 'red velvet' pint, a 'doordash exclusive,' to be a top-tier ice cream. They recommend indulging in it via delivery."
Positive
