NYC's premier ice cream spot. Indulge in artisanal scoops, killer soft serve & unique sundaes. Expect lines, but it's worth it!
This Italian dessert shop is a haven for ice cream lovers, boasting a consistently large crowd and rave reviews for its artisanal creations. From classic flavors with a luxurious twist to innovative seasonal specials, every scoop is crafted with high-quality ingredients for a truly memorable experience. It's no wonder this spot has earned its reputation as one of the city's best ice cream destinations.
This establishment specializes in artisanal ice cream and gelato, with a strong emphasis on high-quality ingredients and creative flavor combinations. Customers frequently rave about their unique seasonal specials, soft serves, and elaborate sundaes, with flavors like 'Cookies N' Panna,' 'Salted Malt Chocolate,' and 'Dubai Chocolate' receiving particular acclaim. While most feedback is positive, a few mention that some flavors can be overly sweet or that certain limited-edition items sell out quickly.
"Customers frequently praise flavors like 'Cookies N' Panna,' 'Salted Malt Chocolate,' and their 'Dubai Chocolate' ice cream. The soft serve, especially unique combinations like 'Noccioloreo' or seasonal specials, are also highly recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the exceptional quality and unique flavors of the ice cream, often describing it as the best they've ever had. While some find the prices high, the consensus is that the taste and experience justify the cost.
Important Note
Some customers find the prices to be on the higher side. Certain popular or limited-edition flavors can sell out quickly, especially during peak hours or seasons.
"The author and their parents enjoyed Caffe Panna even in cold weather, particularly liking the Black Forest sundae and red flag with panna."
Positive"Cafe Panna was noted for making a "damned fine" hot chocolate, which is topped with their namesake, but advised to check availability as it's seasonal."
Positive"A commenter suggested checking Caffe Panna's weekly flavor."
Neutral"Caffe Panna offers rotating cake batter ice cream flavors. Their "Birthday Cake" flavor, with house-made frosting and cake crunch, is suggested as a close match."
Positive"This user inquired if Caffe Panna's vanilla ice cream was good enough to change their opinion about what they consider generally sub-par ice cream from the establishment."
Neutral"This user states that they exclusively order the vanilla ice cream at Caffe Panna."
Positive"Initially skeptical about choosing vanilla over unique flavors at Caffe Panna, this user was proven wrong and declared their vanilla ice cream the best they've ever had."
Positive"Recommended ice cream at Caffe Panna as an option for a mother-daughter trip."
Positive"This user echoes the recommendation for Caffe Panna and mentions ordering two pints or getting it from Union Market."
Positive"Suggested as a place to take teen girls, though noted as potentially touristy."
Neutral"This user recommends Caffe Panna ice cream."
Positive"This user recommends Caffe Panna for ice cream, noting it's in Manhattan."
Positive"Caffe Panna is recommended for ice cream."
Positive"Caffe Panna is recommended for ice cream."
Positive"Caffe Panna is recommended for ice cream."
Positive"In response to concerns about melted ice cream, this user shares a positive experience shipping a cheesecake from Juniors, stating it arrived frozen solid and there was no risk."
Neutral"This user expresses strong approval of Caffe Panna's ice cream, calling it 'fkn good'."
Positive"This commenter sarcastically suggests that some people will inevitably buy the expensive Caffe Panna collaboration pack."
Neutral"The user expresses concern that Caffe Panna ice cream might arrive melted if shipped, despite understanding that Goldbelly's purpose is shipping perishables."
Neutral"This commenter suggests that influencers might receive the Caffe Panna collaboration pack for free."
Neutral
