Reddit Sentiment for JOE'S SHANGHAI RESTAURANT(based on 33 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Joe's Shanghai is a recognized runner-up for the best sit-down meal in Chinatown, famous for its iconic soup dumplings (Xiao Long Bao).
Joe's Shanghai in Chinatown is specifically recognized as one of the best places in NYC for soup dumplings, highlighting its specialty and reputation for this dish.
Details
A classic Chinatown spot renowned for its Shanghainese cuisine, particularly its highly acclaimed soup dumplings [1]. While some perceive it as a tourist destination, many still consider it a top choice for authentic flavors and a bustling dining experience, especially for those exploring the area [2]. It's a place where you can enjoy traditional dishes and a lively atmosphere, even on busy occasions like Christmas [5].
Food Overview
This restaurant is celebrated for its Shanghainese specialties, with soup dumplings being a major highlight, including both crab and pan-fried varieties [1], [10], [15], [17], [23]. Other dishes that receive mentions include cold sesame noodles, crispy shredded beef, sautéed string beans, and dim sum [4], [6], [20], [24]. While many regard it as a top spot for dumplings [1], [17], some find it overrated and recommend other establishments [12], [25]. It's also noted for having affordable options, like dumplings and sliced pork around $3-5 [2].
Caveats
One user noted that the restaurant does not accept cards and advises bringing cash, as their ATM has a fee [18]. There are also differing opinions on whether the restaurant has declined in quality or is considered a tourist trap [7], [12].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About JOE'S SHANGHAI RESTAURANT
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Soft Shell Crabs At Manhattan Chinatown
"The commenter reported that Joe's Shanghai had soft shell crabs available on the day they posted."
PositiveFrom post: Iconic Foods In Nyc
"This user considers Joe's Shanghai overrated for soup dumplings and suggests Deluxe Green Bo, Shanghai 21, or Noodle Village as better alternatives."
NegativeFrom post: Iconic Foods In Nyc
"This user considers Joe's Shanghai overrated for soup dumplings and suggests Deluxe Green Bo, Shanghai 21, or Noodle Village as better alternatives."
NegativeFrom post: Iconic Foods In Nyc
"This commenter recommends Joe's Shanghai for soup dumplings as part of a Chinatown food exploration."
PositiveFrom post: Iconic Foods In Nyc
"This commenter recommends Joe's Shanghai for soup dumplings as part of a Chinatown food exploration."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Crab Dish In Nyc
"Recommended the pan fried crabmeat soup dumplings at Joe's Shanghai."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Crab Dish In Nyc
"Recommended the pan fried crabmeat soup dumplings at Joe's Shanghai."
PositiveFrom post: Dimsum Americanized Chinese
"This user recommended Joe's Shanghai in Chinatown as a consistently good spot with a large menu, but advised bringing cash as they do not accept cards and their ATM has a fee."
PositiveFrom post: Is Din Tai Fung Worth It
"This commenter prefers Joe's Shanghai over Din Tai Fung, suggesting it as an alternative for better soup dumplings."
PositiveFrom post: Is Din Tai Fung Worth It
"This commenter recommends Joe's Shanghai for soup dumplings in NYC and also mentions their crispy beef."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Classic Restaurants That Are Baby Friendly
"This user suggested Joe Shanghai as a safer bet for baby-friendliness among the mentioned restaurants."
PositiveFrom post: You Cant Leave Nyc Without Eating
"Joe's Shanghai is listed as a recommended Asian restaurant, known for its dim sum."
PositiveFrom post: Great Eats For A Picky Teen
"Joe's Shanghai is listed as a place to get soup dumplings."
PositiveFrom post: Need A Cheap Christmas Dinner
"Joe's Shanghai in Chinatown is recommended for its soup dumplings and is noted to be busy on Christmas, requiring potential wait times and efficient dining."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Eat On Thanksgiving Day Non Tg Food
"Joe's Shanghai is suggested as a restaurant that might be open on Thanksgiving, with a question about preferred cuisine or area."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurant Tonight With 12 Year Old
"Lists Joe's Shanghai as a potential restaurant choice."
NeutralFrom post: Fav Restaurant In Manhattan Chinatown
"This commenter recommends Joes Shanghai."
NegativeFrom post: Family Friendly Restaurants Near City Hall
"Joe's Shanghai was mentioned as a possible restaurant choice in the FiDi area."
NeutralFrom post: What To Avoid In Chinatown
"Joe's Shanghai is called a tourist trap, with the user stating that many other soup dumpling places are superior and have less of a wait."
NegativeFrom post: Din Tai Fung Or Other Spot
"This commenter recommends Shanghai 21 as a good place for XLB and also suggests Joe Shanghai as a Chinatown staple, recommending it to say you've been there."
Positive