Known for its standout roast chicken and delicious pistachio cake. A top Italian spot.
This Italian eatery is a popular choice, frequently recommended for its exceptional roast chicken, often described as juicy and spectacular. Beyond the signature chicken, the pistachio cake and well-prepared pizza also receive nods. While the ambiance and food quality generally impress, potential diners should be aware that some perceive the acclaimed chicken as overpriced, and noise levels have been noted as a concern at their newer location.
The restaurant is highly praised for its Italian cuisine, with the roast chicken being a standout dish that many customers rave about. Some also enjoyed the pistachio cake and pizza. While most feedback on food is positive, a few opinions suggest the chicken might be overrated or too expensive, and one commenter found the pizza crust to be buttered.
"The roast chicken is consistently highlighted as a must-try dish. The pistachio cake and pizza are also mentioned positively."
Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, with many recommending it for its food, particularly the roast chicken. However, some find the chicken overrated or pricey, and one diner noted excessive noise levels at the new location.
Important Note
Some find the highly recommended chicken dish to be overrated or pricey. The new location has been noted as excessively noisy, potentially hindering conversation.
"Barbuto is recommended."
Positive"Barbuto is listed as a recommended dining spot."
Neutral"Barbuto is mentioned as a dining option."
Neutral"Barbuto is recommended as a dining option, along with Frenchette at the Whitney, Shukette, Tzikito, Orchard Townhouse, Cookshop, and Empire Diner."
Neutral"Barbuto is listed as a restaurant option in the Meatpacking and W Village area."
Neutral"Barbuto is simply recommended as a good restaurant choice."
Positive"The user included Barbuto in a list of recommended restaurants."
Positive"This user states that Barbuto has welcoming vibes, fitting the original poster's request for similar restaurant types."
Positive"This user suggested Barbuto is best for a long lunch on a Friday in the summer, implying it's more enjoyable when the noise level might be lower."
Neutral"This user found Barbuto's new location excessively noisy, preventing conversation, though they found the food fine and liked how the pizza crust was buttered, but wouldn't return due to noise."
Negative"This user found Barbuto's inclusion on the list 'soooooooo funny', suggesting it was an unexpected or undeserving choice."
Negative"This commenter endorses Barbuto, indicating it's a good choice for the requested dinner."
Positive"Barbuto is suggested as a potential option for a last-minute group dinner."
Neutral"Barbuto is listed as a suggested restaurant."
Neutral"eringobrah21 recommends Barbuto as a place to go in the West Village."
Positive"A commenter recommended Barbuto as a brunch option near the Whitney."
Positive"Recommends Barbuto as an alternative Italian restaurant if the user is dying for Italian food."
Positive"The commenter chooses the Chocolate Budino from Barbuto as their death row dessert."
Positive"Strongly agrees with the Barbuto recommendation, calling it the best chicken and ideal for a date night."
Positive"Asserts that Barbuto should be mentioned in the discussion of best chicken."
Positive