Dependable sushi w/ good quality fish & great value. Popular, but be ready for a wait - no res.
This Japanese sushi spot is a popular choice for those seeking a dependable and delicious meal, with many praising its good quality fish and great value. It's often recommended for its consistently good sushi, though some diners note it can be crowded and doesn't take reservations.
The sushi here is frequently recommended for its good quality and value, with many users praising it as a consistent and satisfying option. However, there are also strong negative opinions, with some critics describing the fish as poorly cut and too cold, and the rice as bland and too hot. Some users also note that the restaurant may have limited wild-caught options.
"While specific dishes aren't consistently highlighted, 'The Nozawa Trust Me' tasting menu is mentioned positively. Cooked crab and lobster hand rolls are also recommended for those avoiding raw fish."
Customers generally find the sushi to be of good quality and value, making it a reliable choice. However, some reviews are critical, citing issues with fish preparation and rice quality, and the restaurant is known for being crowded.
Important Note
The restaurant does not take reservations and can be crowded, often leading to waits of 30-45 minutes or more. Some diners have expressed strong negative opinions regarding the quality of the fish and rice.
"The user criticizes Sugarfish for not using particularly quality fish and having a boring selection. The fish is also described as being cut poorly and served ice cold, hindering the taste. The rice is noted as being hot and loose, making it difficult to eat, and overall assembly is described as subpar."
Negative"This user states that Sugarfish is awful chain restaurant sushi."
Negative"The original poster mentions loving Sugarfish but seeking a fusion style, which Sugarfish does not offer. They also recall liking Sushi Samba & Monster Sushi in the past, though acknowledge these might be considered 'crap' by sushi purists."
Neutral"Sugarfish is described as the 'Olive Garden of sushi' but still offers quality, appealing to those who prioritize that over other factors."
Neutral"Sugarfish is mentioned alongside Nobu as a potential option."
Neutral"The commenter, who has a serious sesame allergy, mentioned that Sugarfish has accommodated them. This was in response to a user seeking allergy-friendly sushi options."
Positive"Sugarfish is mentioned as a suggestion."
Neutral"The user is hesitant to try this restaurant due to mixed reviews, despite it being a potential option for sushi."
Neutral"This user noted that Sugarfish is thriving in NYC, indicating its popularity and success in the city."
Positive"Sugarfish is still considered good, despite not being as amazing as before, and fits the budget. The Nozawa Trust Me tasting is recommended."
Positive"Sugarfish is mentioned as being close by and popular for sushi, although the original poster did not ask for sushi recommendations."
Neutral"A strong negative opinion stating Sugarfish is 'straight up garbage.'"
Negative"Defends Sugarfish, suggesting that negative opinions might stem from it being 'cool to hate.' The commenter notes that while not worth a long wait, it's often accessible for lunch."
Positive"A brief, strong negative opinion stating Sugarfish is 'awful.'"
Negative"A negative opinion on Sugarfish, stating it was just okay and surprising given its popularity. The user implies it's not worth the hype."
Negative"The user is looking for something more varied and creative than sushi, expressing a preference against it for their dining situation."
Negative"This restaurant offers a tasting menu that is not excessively expensive and is fine for one person to order while others do not, especially if the person enjoys sushi."
Positive"Sugarfish offers cooked crab and lobster hand rolls, which are a good option for those avoiding raw fish. The user who received the recommendation plans to add them to their list."
Positive"Sugarfish is mentioned positively, with a specific note that it's particularly good for lunch."
Positive"The user agrees that Sugarfish is good value for money, stating they prefer it over many more expensive places, and has had good luck with shorter waits at the Brooklyn location."
Positive
