TLDR
Iconic NYC bakery w/ famously thick, decadent cookies—a must-try, melt-in-your-mouth experience.
Instagram Posts References
Nadi.in.newyork visited Levain Bakery, which she considers to have the best cookies in the entire city, specifically to try their newly released Lemon and Carrot Cake cookies. She navigated the beautiful streets of the Upper West Side to reach the bakery. Her overall sentiment for the bakery remains very positive due to the quality of their cookies and the delightful experience with the new Lemon flavor.
Details
This beloved NYC institution is famous for its incredibly thick, rich, and decadent cookies. Each cookie is a substantial treat, often described as a cake-like delight. While some find them a bit too sweet or heavy, many consider them to be among the best in the city, especially when enjoyed warm.
Food Overview
The bakery is renowned for its generously sized, cake-like cookies, particularly the chocolate chip walnut. While many adore their richness and unique texture, some find them overly sweet or prefer a thinner cookie. The oatmeal raisin and lemon cookies have also received positive mentions.
Caveats
Some customers find the cookies to be excessively sweet, rich, or have a texture that is too cakey or crispy on the edges, which may not appeal to everyone's preference for a traditional chewy cookie.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LEVAIN BAKERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Whats Your Slightly Overpriced Nyc Treat That
"This user suggested Levain cookies as an example of a calorie bomb "NYC treat" that originated in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Your Favorite Dessert Spot On
"Levain was mentioned as a dessert spot."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Your Favorite Dessert Spot On
"Levain Bakery was suggested as a place for cookies."
PositiveFrom post: Low Food Budget Suggestions
"Levain Bakery cookies, available at multiple locations, were very popular with one reviewer's husband, and while the reviewer found them good, they weren't amazing, noting their unique thick and cakey texture."
NeutralFrom post: Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
"The user strongly agrees with the positive sentiment regarding Levain's oatmeal raisin cookie."
PositiveFrom post: Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
"Contrary to popular opinion, the user states that the oatmeal raisin cookie is their personal favorite at Levain."
PositiveFrom post: Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
"The user states that Levain's oatmeal raisin cookie is their preferred choice and the best they've ever had."
PositiveFrom post: Chewiest Chocolate Chip Cookie Zero Crisp
"The original poster clarifies that Levain cookies, while objectively good, do not meet their ideal of a fully chewy cookie without crispy exteriors or raw interiors."
NegativeFrom post: Chewiest Chocolate Chip Cookie Zero Crisp
"A user notes that Levain cookies are massive and have crispy, gooey, and raw bits, suggesting them for those who prefer a doughy texture, but potentially not fitting the 'no crisp' criteria."
NegativeFrom post: Chewiest Chocolate Chip Cookie Zero Crisp
"A user suggests microwaving a Levain cookie in a brown bag for 20 seconds to eliminate any crispiness."
NeutralFrom post: Chewiest Chocolate Chip Cookie Zero Crisp
"A user considers Levain's cookies to be the softest and their favorite."
PositiveFrom post: Chewiest Chocolate Chip Cookie Zero Crisp
"A user expresses preference for gooey/chewy cookies and states they have never encountered a crispy or crunchy chocolate chip walnut cookie from Levain."
PositiveFrom post: Chewiest Chocolate Chip Cookie Zero Crisp
"A user states that Levain cookies are not chewy and have a prominent crisp when first bitten."
NegativeFrom post: Chewiest Chocolate Chip Cookie Zero Crisp
"The original poster acknowledges Levain's middle is good but critiques its crunchy, scone-like edges and an unfavorable edge-to-center ratio for their preferred texture."
NegativeFrom post: Chewiest Chocolate Chip Cookie Zero Crisp
"A user had a Levain cookie recently and found the bottom to be crispy and crunchy, which doesn't fit the desired texture."
NegativeFrom post: Chewiest Chocolate Chip Cookie Zero Crisp
"A user recommends Levain Bakery, mentioning they are currently eating one of their cookies."
PositiveFrom post: Solid Chocolate Chip Cookie
"The user cannot stand Levain cookies, describing them as 'nasty stuff'."
NegativeFrom post: Solid Chocolate Chip Cookie
"The user finds Levain's cookies horrible."
NegativeFrom post: Solid Chocolate Chip Cookie
"The user preferred Culture Espresso's cookie over Levain's."
NegativeFrom post: Solid Chocolate Chip Cookie
"The user's girlfriend liked Culture Espresso's cookie more than Levain's."
Negative