Details
This ice cream parlor is a must-visit for unique soft serve flavors like taro and cookie monster. While many rave about the creative combinations and quality, be aware of potential location-specific issues, such as unpleasant odors reported at the MacDougal Street branch. Overall, it's a top-tier spot for adventurous dessert lovers.
Food Overview
This establishment is celebrated for its innovative soft serve ice cream, with popular choices including taro and cookie monster flavors. While the quality and uniqueness of the offerings are frequently praised, one commenter had a particularly negative experience at the MacDougal Street location, citing a strong, unpleasant odor.
Caveats
One reviewer strongly advised against the MacDougal Street location due to a persistent and unpleasant odor.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SURREAL CREAMERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Birthday Dinner In Nyc Italianamerican Recs
"Surreal Creamery was mentioned as a spot for interesting soft serve flavors."
PositiveFrom post: Soft Serve In Nyc
"The author recommends the taro/matcha swirl at Surreal Creamery but strongly advises against the MacDougal Street location due to a persistent unpleasant smell."
NegativeFrom post: Soft Serve In Nyc
"The author had a bad experience at the MacDougal Street Surreal Creamery location due to a "worst basement smell ever.""
NegativeFrom post: Hanis Soft Serve
"Surreal Creamery is highlighted as a favorite for its taro or cookie monster soft serve options."
Positive