TLDR
Authentic Tokyo-style noodle shop serving top-tier, wallet-friendly udon in an intimate, hole-in-the-wall setting.
Instagram Posts References
Udon St Marks is described as a hole-in-the-wall restaurant that serves arguably the best udon in New York City, at very affordable prices. The cheapest bowl costs under $9 before tax. The restaurant has an authentic Tokyo-style atmosphere, with J-Pop music, a regular clientele, and a small queue, making diners feel like they are in a neighborhood noodle shop in Tokyo. The staff, like Mao, are noted for their kindness and attentiveness. The noodles are imported directly from Japan and fried to order, contributing to their freshness. Popular dishes include the simmered beef udon, which is a best-seller, and katsu curry.
Will Hartman reviews this classic, cash-only East Village udon spot, highlighting its status as an affordable student favorite that delivers satisfying, consistent Japanese comfort food.
Details
Transporting diners to a quiet street in Tokyo, this hole-in-the-wall spot in the East Village specializes in affordable, authentic udon noodles [1]. Known for its casual atmosphere and J-Pop soundtrack, it has built a loyal following as a reliable destination for high-quality, dashi-based soups [2]. While some patrons fondly recall its former iteration as Udon West, it remains a beloved local favorite for budget-friendly Japanese comfort food [2], [3].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on Japanese comfort classics, with high-quality udon served in a well-balanced, salty dashi broth [2]. The simmered beef udon is a standout best-seller [1], and diners also frequently praise the value of the udon sets paired with katsu or shrimp tempura [2]. While some long-time fans miss specific legacy items like gobo tempura [3], the restaurant remains a go-to for niku udon and various donburi bowls [3], [4].
Customer Sentiment
Patrons consistently express strong appreciation for the authentic atmosphere and affordable pricing, often describing the experience as a nostalgic neighborhood staple [1], [2]. While the service is noted as kind and attentive, guests are reminded that the establishment is cash-only and tips are highly encouraged [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About UDON ST MARKS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Are Your Top 3 Most Frequented Restaurants
"The user visits for the niku udon."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Top 3 Most Frequented Restaurants
"The user goes specifically for the chige nabe udon, which may no longer be on the menu."
PositiveFrom post: Anywhere I Can Find Authentic Japanese Tamagotchi
"A budget-friendly spot for udon noodles; the reviewer enjoys their donburi, though they were uncertain if they serve oyakodon."
PositiveFrom post: Is There Anywhere I Can Find Authentic Kyotostyle
"The original poster is inquiring about this restaurant as a potential location to find a specific Kyoto-style udon broth."
NeutralFrom post: Udon West Vs Udon St Marks
"This user compares Raku to Udon West, suggesting Raku might have better udon. However, they fondly recall Udon West evoking a nostalgic feeling of cheaper udon and pre-drinking meals from 2010."
NeutralFrom post: Udon West Vs Udon St Marks
"This user believes the owner is the same for Udon West and Udon St Marks, suggesting a name change to avoid franchise fees. They noted that some items like gobo tempura are no longer available."
NeutralFrom post: Udon West Vs Udon St Marks
"This user is asking if Udon West has reopened and states it was the best in their opinion."
PositiveFrom post: Udon West Vs Udon St Marks
"This user believes Udon West and Udon St Marks are the same place, with a similar menu, and that the rebranding was due to water damage."
NeutralFrom post: Best Udon Soup Ues
"The commenter recommended St. Marks Udon as a good option for udon soup, specifying its location in the East Village, not the UES."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Plan Ideashelp Please
"Udon St Marks is recommended as a more low-key alternative to Raku, with a bar where you can watch food preparation and a few tables available."
PositiveFrom post: Missing Japan
"Udon St. Marks is loved by the user, who notes it used to have a different name."
Positive