NYC's premier speakeasy cocktail bar; craft off-menu drinks in an intimate setting. Arrive early for a taste of cocktail perfection.
Step into the world of Attaboy, a renowned speakeasy cocktail bar that consistently ranks among the nation's best. This hidden gem, tucked away on Eldridge Street, offers an intimate and exclusive experience, eschewing a traditional menu for expertly crafted, off-menu cocktails. Patrons are advised to arrive early, often 30 minutes before opening, to secure a spot in this popular establishment. While the wait can be long, most agree that the unique cocktail creations, such as the 'Electric Current Fizz,' are well worth it. Attaboy is the perfect destination for those seeking a sophisticated and memorable cocktail experience, embodying the spirit of classic cocktail craftsmanship.
Attaboy is celebrated for its exceptional cocktails, with many hailing it as the premier cocktail bar in the country. The bar operates without a menu, allowing patrons to order classic or off-menu drinks. A standout recommendation is the 'Electric Current Fizz.' While the drinks are generally a hit, one user felt the cocktails weren't personalized to their stated preferences.
"The 'Electric Current Fizz' is specifically recommended as a unique and enjoyable cocktail. The bar's specialty is off-menu classic cocktails."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Attaboy, frequently referring to it as the best cocktail bar in the country and their personal go-to spot. Many recommend arriving early to ensure entry, with some suggesting 30 minutes before opening. While most experiences are highly positive, a few users found it 'meh' or disappointing, with one noting that drinks weren't tailored to their preferences. The bar's no-menu policy and the possibility of a wait are common points of discussion.
Important Note
Expect long waits, especially on weekend nights, and it's advisable to arrive well before opening to ensure entry. Some patrons have had mixed experiences, with one finding the drinks not tailored to their preferences.
"A user mentions Good Guy's, located next door to Attaboy, as a venue for a BCB event. Attaboy itself is only mentioned as a landmark in relation to the event location."
Neutral"Attaboy is recommended as a beautiful cocktail bar that fits the original poster's request."
Positive"The user has a tradition of getting a drink at Attaboy when visiting NYC and intends to continue this tradition during their trip to the Lower East Side."
Positive"The user itseasyummk agreed Attaboy is the best (in context of a list also mentioning Superbueno and D&C)."
Positive"The user Miserable_Put5273 found that Attaboy lived up to the hype."
Positive"The user morosehuman felt Attaboy lived up to the hype."
Positive"Attaboy is their favorite with consistent quality and no bad drinks experienced. Suggests arriving before opening to put your name in."
Positive"Attaboy was the standout cocktail bar, recommends fitting it in. They have a good system where you can put your name in and they will call you."
Positive"Recommends ordering the Electric Current Fizz at Attaboy."
Positive"Attaboy is their favorite."
Positive"Attaboy is one of their top four recommendations. Suggests arriving 20 minutes before opening to ensure entry and opting for bar seating."
Positive"Attaboy is small and will have a long wait, possibly unable to get in."
Negative"Mentioned as a potential pre-dinner drinks spot near Wildair in the Lower East Side."
Neutral"Reviewer calls Attaboy their go-to spot and advises arriving 30 minutes before opening to secure entry."
Positive"Commenter feels Attaboy is 'meh' and doesn't justify the long waits often experienced."
Negative"Commenter ranks Attaboy as one of their favorites and suggests prioritizing it, although noting it can be tough to get into."
Positive"Recommended as one of the Sasha Petraske bars good for ordering off-menu classics."
Positive"Recommended, noting that the bar doesn't have a menu, fitting the request for off-menu orders."
Positive"Included in a list of recommended bars for ordering off-menu cocktails."
Positive"Recommended, though the commenter humorously notes that off-menu orders often result in a Penicillin."
Neutral"Recommended by name as a suitable bar."
Positive"What's the fourth picture of the metal door?"
Neutral"I was not impressed with Attaboy. Quite disappointed actually for it being touted as a cocktail bar with no menu."
Negative"What is that clandestine looking spot A/B 134?"
Neutral"I've been to Attaboy twice, the first time super disappointing, the second time was amazing."
Neutral"What is the AB 134 door?"
Neutral"Expected more; drinks were kinda just made for you and not actually based on what you tell them (we are cocktail people)"
Negative"Attaboy. Nice"
Positive"For a pure cocktail experience, go to Attaboy."
Positive"Attaboy isn't that hard to get into unless it's Friday or Saturday night. It's the best cocktail bar in the country."
Positive"Attaboy doesn't take reservations, get there by 420-430 if you want to get in right away. The wait is worth it."
Positive"Better options in the neighborhood, such as Attaboy."
Positive
