TLDR
A top-tier bakery w/ amazing sourdough & baguettes. Don't miss the Duo cookie or quality brioches!
Details
This bakery is celebrated for its exceptional bread, including highly recommended sourdough and baguettes, with a French baker at the helm. Customers also rave about their Duo cookie, a perfect blend of crunchy and chewy, and their praline and pearl sugar brioches are noted for their quality [1], [2], [3], [4], [5]. They also offer a well-regarded pain de mie, a versatile French bread perfect for sandwiches [6], [7].
Food Overview
The bakery is lauded for its artisan breads, particularly sourdough and baguettes, with one user claiming their baguette surpasses even renowned establishments [1], [2]. The Duo cookie is a must-try, described as having a perfect texture between crunchy and chewy [3]. Additionally, their praline and pearl sugar brioches are noted as being comparable to those from high-end patisseries [4]. The pain de mie is also a recommended choice for sandwiches [5], [6].
Caveats
One user found the brioche buns to be overpriced for burgers, despite recommending the bakery for them [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BREAD STORY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Can I Get An Unsliced Square Loaf Of Bread
"Bread Story, located between 15th and 16th on First, has nice pan de mie, which is a type of square loaf suitable for the user's request."
PositiveFrom post: Where Is The Best Place To Buy Brioche Buns In
"The user thanked the previous commenter and stated they would try Bread Story."
NeutralFrom post: Where Is The Best Place To Buy Brioche Buns In
"The user recommended Bread Story as a place for brioche buns, noting its downtown location, but considered it overpriced for burgers."
NegativeFrom post: Whole Wheat Bread In Manhattan
"This comment highlighted Bread Story near Stuytown, praising their cereal bread and buckwheat baguette, noting they offer slicing services but the sugar content is unconfirmed."
NeutralFrom post: Irish Soda Bread Where Do You Buy Yours
"States they just bought Irish Soda Bread from Bread Story on 1st Ave today."
NeutralFrom post: Best Artisan Bread
"This user clarifies that Bread Story is located near *the* East Village."
NeutralFrom post: Best Artisan Bread
"This user calls Bread Story 'God tier' and states they go very often."
PositiveFrom post: Best Artisan Bread
"This user claims Bread Story has the actual best baguette in the city, surpassing Le Fournil."
PositiveFrom post: Best Artisan Bread
"Bread Story in Stuytown, near the East Village, is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Are There Any Local Bakeries That Sell Bread That
"The pain de mie from The Bread Story is highly recommended and considered very good."
PositiveFrom post: Are There Any Local Bakeries That Sell Bread That
"The Bread Story on 16th and 1st Ave is mentioned as a place that might have pain de mie, a French bread similar to sandwich bread."
PositiveFrom post: French People In Nyc Where Has Best Croissants In
"This user noted that Bread Story's praline and pearl sugar brioches are reminiscent of those from Maison Kayser."
PositiveFrom post: French People In Nyc Where Has Best Croissants In
"As a healthcare worker, this user appreciated the discount offered at Bread Story."
PositiveFrom post: French People In Nyc Where Has Best Croissants In
"This user mentioned liking Bread Story for bread and appreciated the discount and nice worker."
PositiveFrom post: French People In Nyc Where Has Best Croissants In
"This user recommended Bread Story for fresh bread, noting that the baker is French and sometimes speaks French."
PositiveFrom post: Crunchy Chocolate Chip Pecan Cookie
"Replying to a recommendation for Bread Story, this user indicated that a cookie that is not chewy would be acceptable."
NeutralFrom post: Crunchy Chocolate Chip Pecan Cookie
"The commenter recommended Bread Story for a chocolate chip pecan cookie, noting it's called the Duo cookie. They described its texture as perfectly in between crunchy and chewy."
PositiveFrom post: Best Croissant For Mom Who Grew Up In Aix En
"This commenter recommended Bread Story next to StuyTown."
PositiveFrom post: Best Croissant For Mom Who Grew Up In Aix En
"This commenter recommended Bread Story next to StuyTown."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Bakery Cookie
"This user calls the Duo cookie at Bread Story a real gem."
Positive