Massive, authentic Italian sandwiches w/ bold flavors & fresh combos. A taste of Florence w/ generous portions, though can be pricey. Worth it for the 'La Regina' or 'La Paradiso'!
This Italian sandwich shop, originating from Florence, has made a significant splash in NYC. Known for its massive schiacciata sandwiches filled with high-quality ingredients, it offers a taste of authentic Tuscan flavor. While the price point and portion sizes have sparked discussion, many agree that the sandwiches are delicious and a satisfying meal, especially the La Paradiso with mortadella and pistachio cream.
This eatery specializes in large Italian sandwiches, primarily using schiacciata bread, which is similar to focaccia. Popular choices include the 'La Paradiso' with mortadella and pistachio cream, and 'La Regina' with prosciutto crudo and pistachio cream. While many rave about the quality and generosity of the ingredients, a few find the NYC prices high and the sandwiches smaller than their Italian counterparts.
"The 'La Paradiso' sandwich, featuring mortadella, stracciatella, and pistachio cream, is frequently praised and highly recommended. Other popular choices include 'La Regina' and various porchetta sandwiches."
Customers generally have a very positive impression of the sandwiches, often praising their size and unique Florentine flavors, though some find them to be on the pricier side for NYC.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that the NYC location may be smaller and more expensive than the original Florence locations, and the bread quality might differ. Long lines can also be a deterrent for some.
"As a fellow Californian, the commenter feels Al'Antica Vinao is not worth the US markup compared to its pricing in Italy."
Negative"The commenter found Al'Antica Vinao to be a very mediocre sandwich and not worth the price in NYC."
Negative"As someone who eats sandwiches professionally, the commenter finds Al'Antica Vinao to be unexceptional."
Negative"The commenter agrees that Al'Antica Vinao is widely available and considers it overhyped."
Negative"The commenter suggests Al'Antica Vinao is available in LA and recommends focusing on NYC-specific items like Veselka or pierogis in Greenpoint."
Negative"The commenter states Al'Antica Vinao is a chain from Italy and that many non-chain places better represent Italian-American sandwiches."
Negative"The commenter recommends Faiccos over Al'Antica Vinao for Italian sandwiches."
Negative"The original poster mentioned they don't visit LA or Boston often but have memories of the place being good."
Positive"Stated that All'Antico Vinaio is expanding across the US, with multiple locations in NYC and also in LA and Boston."
Neutral"The original poster was delighted to confirm the existence of the sandwich shop in NY, as they don't frequently visit Florence."
Positive"Confirmed that the NYC location is the same Florentine sandwich place."
Positive"The original poster inquired if this was the same sandwich place they enjoyed in Florence, Italy, expressing eagerness to revisit it."
Positive"All'Antico Vinaio is recommended as a spot for sandwiches, noted as not a sit-down experience."
Positive"Antico Vinaio was mentioned as a food option."
Neutral"The commenter suggests All'Antico Vinaio for Italian sandwiches, mentioning the 'Inferno' as a favorite but stating all their sandwiches are great."
Positive"All Antico Vinaio is mentioned as a great option, but the commenter also suggested exploring the numerous restaurants near the Intrepid."
Positive"All'antico Vinaio is mentioned as a dining option in Midtown."
Neutral"All'Antico Vinaio is mentioned as a place to get sandwiches."
Neutral"Al Antico Vinaio is recommended for Italian paninis."
Positive"In response to a comment about the price difference between NYC and Florence locations, the author confirmed they would try the NYC All'Antico Vinaio when back in the city."
Positive
