Innovative Persian tapas with standout kashk bademjan & lamb dishes.
Eyval stands out as an upscale Persian restaurant that has garnered significant praise for its innovative approach to traditional cuisine, particularly its small plates. Many patrons have been "wowed" by the unique flavors and creative dishes, with specific mentions of their kashk bademjan and lamb dishes. While most reviews are overwhelmingly positive, a few diners have expressed disappointment, citing issues with seasoning or perceived value.
Eyval offers a modern take on Persian cuisine, with many customers highlighting its tapas-style small plates. Dishes like kashk bademjan, lamb, and eggplant are frequently recommended. Some diners noted that certain dishes could benefit from more salt or were overpriced, while others found it to be among their best dining experiences.
"Customers frequently recommend the kashk bademjan, lamb dishes, and short ribs. The citrus, cabbage, and date salad is also mentioned as a dish worth returning for."
Customers generally have a very positive view of Eyval, frequently praising its unique Persian-inspired tapas and upscale atmosphere. However, a minority find it disappointing or not authentically Persian, with some mentioning issues with saltiness or perceived value.
Important Note
Reservations are highly recommended as it can be difficult to get a table. Some find the food to be not authentically Persian or lacking in certain elements like saltiness, and a few consider it overpriced for the portion sizes.
"The citrus, cabbage, and date salad from Eyval is a dish this commenter would go back for."
Positive"This user clarified that while $48 for four scallops is pushing it, $24 for four at a nice restaurant is a good deal."
Neutral"Eyval is mentioned as one of the commenter's favorites for fresh middle eastern bread."
Positive"Responding to a comment about Eyval's location, this user questioned the description of Morgan L as being in the 'middle of Williamsburg'."
Neutral"This user humorously commented that a dish needed more sesame seeds."
Neutral"This user found Eyval's kebabs and yogurt-lemon dip good but felt the overall bill for two kebabs and drinks was too high for the portion sizes, leading them to still be hungry afterwards."
Negative"This user advised that the original poster made a mistake by ordering Western dishes at a Persian restaurant, emphasizing that the authentic Persian stews are the main draw."
Neutral"This user countered the suggestion that $48 for four scallops is expensive, stating that $24 for four at a nice restaurant is a relatively good deal."
Neutral"Responding to a comment about scallop prices, this user expressed disbelief at the idea of paying $48 for four scallops, finding it absurd."
Neutral"In response to a linked reel, this user agreed that the food looked delicious."
Positive"This user stated that the original poster was wrong about their opinion of Eyval."
Negative"This user also had a disappointing dinner at Eyval a couple of years prior, finding better Persian food at less prominent spots, though appreciating the ambiance."
Negative"This user, identifying as first-generation Iranian-Armenian from Queens, stated that there is better and more authentic Persian food available on Long Island and listed several other Persian and Armenian restaurants."
Negative"This user strongly disagreed with the original poster's negative review, stating that Eyval 'fucking slaps' and other dishes they've tried were excellent."
Positive"This user completely agreed with the negative sentiment towards Eyval, calling it average at best and stating their Persian mother-in-law makes better food."
Negative"This user defended Eyval, stating that not all good dishes need to be heavily salted or seasoned. They described Eyval as a solid spot, though not particularly authentic."
Positive"This user agreed that Eyval was mid, stating their date, who loved the restaurant, also found the food dry and bland, though they enjoyed the cocktails."
Negative"This user commented that $24 for four scallops seemed reasonable, implying the original poster might be mistaken about the price being too high."
Neutral"The user praised the gormeh sabzi at Eyval, calling it so excellent they would never forget it, and acknowledged that taste is subjective."
Positive"This user made a personal comment about the original poster, suggesting they might be British, dislike Iranians, or both, in response to the negative review."
Neutral
