Iconic NYC hot dogs and famous papaya drinks.
Gray's Papaya stands as a quintessential New York City institution, celebrated for its exceptionally good and affordable hot dogs. It's a go-to spot for a quick, classic New York snack, often paired with their famous papaya drink. This beloved eatery is considered a must-try for both locals and visitors seeking an authentic taste of the city.
Gray's Papaya is primarily known for its hot dogs, which many consider to be among the best in the city. The papaya drink is also frequently recommended to go with the hot dogs. While most feedback is positive, one commenter found the hot dog to be the 'worst' they've ever had, and another suggested that street carts might offer similar quality for a lower price.
"The classic combination of two hot dogs paired with their famous papaya drink is highly recommended."
Customers have a generally positive view of Gray's Papaya, with many considering it an iconic New York institution and a great spot for affordable hot dogs. Some users specifically praise the papaya drink as a perfect accompaniment.
Important Note
One commenter described their hot dog as the worst they've ever had, and another suggested that street carts might offer similar quality.
"Grays Papaya is mentioned as a place for hot dogs."
Neutral"This user recommends Gray's Papaya, noting it's as much for the papaya juice as for the hot dogs."
Positive"Gray's Papaya's breakfast special, which includes a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich with coffee, is highlighted as a great deal for $3."
Positive"Gray's Papaya is listed as a place to consider for cheap eats in NYC."
Positive"The commenter stated that Gray's Papaya was the worst meal they had in NYC."
Negative"The commenter advises skipping Gray's Papaya."
Negative"The commenter suggests that hot dog carts near museums like the Natural History Museum or specific carts like Billy's Hot Dog Cart on Central Park West might be better options than Gray's Papaya."
Negative"Gray's Papaya is listed as one of the commenter's top ten most frequented spots in the area."
Positive"Grays Papaya was listed as a favorite spot for quick bites on the Upper West Side."
Neutral"Grays Papaya was mentioned as a place for quick bites. Although no longer cheap, the classic combination of 2 hot dogs and a papaya drink was noted as always satisfying."
Neutral"The commenter lists Gray's Papaya among several places, noting that not all are bad but some are overhyped."
Neutral"Gray's Papaya is noted as being convenient and cheap but culinarily unremarkable, suggesting street carts offer similar quality."
Neutral"A nostalgic comment suggesting Nathan's used to offer a wider variety of condiments like sauerkraut and onions."
Neutral"Gray's Papaya is described as 'the answer'."
Positive"Nathan's hot dogs are seen as distinct, often pushing chili cheese dogs and lacking traditional sauerkraut and Sabrett-style onions."
Negative"Gray's Papaya is considered the gold standard for hot dogs, with a mention that the original Nathan's is good but not worth a special trip."
Positive"The author confirmed that Dog Day Afternoon does indeed use the distinctive radioactive relish for their Chicago-style hot dogs."
Positive"Gray's Papaya was a popular late-night spot for club-goers in the 90s and early 2000s, offering an enjoyable experience even for those slightly inebriated."
Positive"The author enjoyed the bratwurst and currywurst at Schaller's Stube, wishing brats were as common as hot dogs in NYC."
Positive"Gray's Papaya is considered an elite establishment and a treasure of the Upper West Side."
Positive
