Last Updated: 26 days ago
Phone: (212) 799-0243
Address: 2080 BROADWAY 10023
Iconic NYC hot dogs & their famous papaya drink - a quintessential, affordable grab-and-go experience.
This classic New York City hot dog stand is a beloved institution, celebrated for its affordable and delicious hot dogs. Beyond the savory, their unique papaya drink is a must-try, offering a refreshing counterpoint to the salty dog. It's a no-frills spot that has been serving up this iconic combination for years, making it a go-to for a quick and authentic taste of the city.
The star of the show at Gray's Papaya is undoubtedly their hot dogs, which are consistently praised for their taste and snap. Many recommend pairing them with the signature papaya drink, often described as uniquely refreshing. While the hot dogs are a hit, some have found them to be the 'worst' they've ever had, though this is a minority opinion. The establishment also offers a very affordable breakfast special with a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich and coffee.
"The classic hot dog, often recommended with mustard and sauerkraut, is a must-try. Don't miss out on their signature papaya drink, which is frequently suggested as the perfect accompaniment. Their breakfast special, a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich with coffee, is also highlighted as an excellent, budget-friendly option."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Gray's Papaya for its classic, delicious hot dogs and unique, refreshing papaya drink. It's considered an iconic, affordable New York culinary experience, though some note its popularity has led to increased crowds.
Important Note
While generally praised, some reviews suggest that the restaurant's popularity, potentially fueled by social media, has led to increased crowds and longer wait times, detracting from its original quick-service appeal. Additionally, it is a take-out only spot and does not have a bathroom.
"Gray's Papaya was suggested, likely as a budget-friendly option, in a thread discussing affordable places to eat in NYC."
Neutral"This commenter recalled Chelsea Papaya's hot dogs being very similar to Gray's Papaya on the Upper West Side from about ten years ago."
Neutral"This commenter recalled late-night hot dog combos with papaya drinks from Gray's Papaya and mentioned a large customer turnout during a blackout when power was lost."
Positive"This user stated that if Gray's Papaya were to open in the former Papaya Dog location, they believe it would be very successful."
Positive"This user states they travel from Brooklyn to Gray's Papaya on 72nd street a couple of times a year for what they consider the best dogs."
Positive"This user reminisced about having lunch at Gray's Papaya with their coworker about twice a week, describing it as a great sketchy lunch."
Positive"In response to the recommendation of Gray's Papaya, this commenter expressed a preference for a closer option than the UWS."
Neutral"This commenter expressed missing Gray's Papaya, which they believed was located on 8th Street."
Negative"This user recommended heading uptown to Gray's Papaya."
Positive"Clarifying that Gray's Papaya grills their hot dogs, which aligns with the user's preference for grilled dogs, though not boiled as initially inquired."
Positive"This user recommends Gray's Papaya as a place to find the desired hot dog with a good snap."
Positive"The commenter questions where to find a definitive NYC hot dog, mentioning Gray's Papaya as a possibility but concluding Chicago has superior hot dogs."
Neutral"The Halal cart at 72nd & Broadway is open until around 4 AM and is a decent option when needed, though not the best."
Neutral"Gray's Papaya is recommended for take-out but does not offer sit-down dining or a bathroom."
Neutral"Gray's Papaya was suggested as an obvious and easy cheap eat option. However, it is a take-out only spot without a bathroom."
Neutral"The user lists Gray's Papaya alongside Papaya King for their hot dogs with mustard kraut."
Neutral"Gray's Papaya was mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"The commenter suggests Gray's Papaya as a place to get a more local-style hot dog, as opposed to generic street vendors."
Positive"The commenter describes their ritual of getting 3 hot dogs with the works and a large papaya drink from Gray's Papaya as a pre-game for visiting The Met."
Positive"A short comment agreeing with the recommendation of Gray's Papaya."
Positive
