Iconic NYC hot dogs & papaya drinks. A classic, affordable bite.
A true NYC institution, this spot is celebrated for its classic American hot dogs, often recommended as a must-try for an authentic taste of the city. Visitors frequently pair their hot dogs with the signature papaya drink, a combination that has become synonymous with the establishment. While some debate its current popularity, many locals and visitors alike continue to frequent it for a quick, affordable, and satisfying bite.
This eatery is renowned for its American-style hot dogs, often highlighted as a quintessential New York experience. The papaya drink is frequently recommended as the perfect accompaniment. While most feedback is positive, with many calling the hot dogs 'the best' or 'unbeatable', a few negative comments exist, with one user describing it as the 'worst' meal they had. Some also feel it has become too touristy and less of a local gem.
"The classic combination of hot dogs, especially with mustard and sauerkraut, is highly recommended. The papaya drink is also a popular choice to pair with the hot dogs."
Customers largely praise the iconic hot dogs and papaya drinks as a classic and affordable NYC experience, though some recent feedback suggests it's become more tourist-heavy.
Important Note
The restaurant has faced criticism for becoming overly popular with tourists due to social media, leading to longer wait times and a less authentic experience for some. There are also conflicting opinions on the quality, with a few users stating it's one of the worst meals they've had, while the vast majority praise it.
"The user lists Gray's Papaya alongside Papaya King for their hot dogs with mustard kraut."
Neutral"Gray's Papaya was mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"The commenter suggests Gray's Papaya as a place to get a more local-style hot dog, as opposed to generic street vendors."
Positive"The commenter describes their ritual of getting 3 hot dogs with the works and a large papaya drink from Gray's Papaya as a pre-game for visiting The Met."
Positive"A short comment agreeing with the recommendation of Gray's Papaya."
Positive"Gray's Papaya is mentioned as a place the commenter goes to."
Positive"This commenter humorously suggested Gray Papaya as a place to wear a tuxedo."
Neutral"This user simply states to go to Papaya King."
Positive"This user confirms Gray's Papaya on 72nd is the correct answer."
Positive"This user states Gray's Papaya is not as iconic as street vendors, only learning about it after visiting New York from a local."
Neutral"This user suggests that 'papayas' are more authentic now and advises caution with street carts, recommending asking for prices and paying cash if opting for one."
Neutral"This user notes that Gray's Papaya hot dogs are around $3, contrasting with tourist-oriented stands selling dogs with kraut for $8."
Positive"This user recommends Gray's Papaya for a tastier first NYC hot dog experience over street carts, stating they are often overpriced and comparable to homemade ones."
Positive"This user directs others to Gray's Papaya on 72nd street."
Positive"This user would prefer Gray's Papaya over a random street vendor hot dog, believing the vendor would likely be fine too."
Positive"This user reiterates their love for Gray's Papaya and good hot dogs in general."
Positive"This user enjoys Gray's Papaya and its variants but finds Crif Dogs tastier, specifically mentioning the everything seasoning and cream cheese dog."
Positive"This user declares Gray's Papaya on 72nd St and Broadway as the absolute best hot dog in NYC."
Positive"This user's favorite is the Gray's Papaya hot dog with kraut and onions, recommending it with a fruit drink to balance the saltiness and sweetness."
Positive"This user notes that while 'dirty water dogs' are iconic NYC street food, they are not the best choice for hot dogs."
Neutral
